How easy/difficult would it be to alter gear ratios?
How easy/difficult would it be to alter gear ratios?
Author
Discussion

Doxster

Original Poster:

48 posts

236 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Sorry if this topic has been covered before. I didn't find anything on a quick search.

How difficult would it be to alter the gear ratios on a modern performance car? (Ignoring the obvious invalidation of warranty).

The press are forever lamenting the overtly long ratios on a number of fantastic modern sports cars (Here's looking at you Porsche) which seems to hobble both their performance figures and their ability for their drive trains to be fully enjoyed on UK/ Australian roads.

I have no engineering qualifications so have no idea how difficult or easy it could be?

Imagine how much fun a 2.7 Cayman/Boxster would be with shorter ratios - allowing you to rev the ring off it in at least the first 3 gears before reaching licence losing territory.

There surely must be an aftermarket opportunity for a reputable tuning house/ gearbox manufacturer?

Are manufacturers purposely over gearing cars in order to shorten 0-60 times/ hobble overall performance/ chase ridiculous EU economy restrictions?

Please enlighten me.

john2443

6,554 posts

242 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Look for Hewland. They make racing gearboxes. The most famous version, used on single seaters, sticks out of the back of the car, as well as the gears inside the gearbox you have a whole load of others that can easily be put in there instead so you can fine tune the ratios to suit a circuit. EG if 3rd is slightly too high for a particular straight you can change the ratio from .6 to .59 (made up numbers as an example). There might be a whole load of different ones for third so you can have .5, .51, .52, .53, .54 etc and the same for all the others.

I think that from an engineering point of view there's no problem at all to have a gearbox that does what you are asking for. From a cost point of view there might be!

griffin dai

3,345 posts

180 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
What car is it? Are there any other models in the line up with different ratio boxes fitted that you can swap over?

I did it on the last car as they came with 3 different ratios depending on model/spec. Went from 3.61 (too tall geared for me) to a 4.45 (bonkers!!!) to a 4.05 which was the best all rounder but always wanted to go back to the 4.45

Boxes were cheap as chips for these cars though.....

Markgenesis

555 posts

163 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Fitting smaller wheels and tyres has the same effect as lowering the gear ratio's.

Even just going down a profile in tyre, eg, 50 to 40.

Will alter the speedo reading too though.

DonkeyApple

70,899 posts

200 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Markgenesis said:
Fitting smaller wheels and tyres has the same effect as lowering the gear ratio's.

Even just going down a profile in tyre, eg, 50 to 40.

Will alter the speedo reading too though.
True, as would changing the diff. However, I think the OP is referring to not lowering or raising all ratios equally but in effect changing the individual ratios to in effect produce a shorter ratio box rather than just a lower or higher final drive.

My tuppence is that it's quite easy with traditional manual gearboxes but I have absolutely no idea how easy or complex this is with modern auto/semi auto boxes.

I imagine that if someone hasn't done it then it'll be rather expensive.

Doxster

Original Poster:

48 posts

236 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies so far. Very informative.

What I was trying to get at was - say I bought a 981 2.7 boxster, would it be possible to 'improve' ie lower the gear ratios so that 2nd say ran to 55-60mph rather than 80+ and 3rd to less than 100 etc. Looking at the gearbox as an individual entity and ignoring wheel size etc etc.

What does altering the final drive ratio do to the rest of the ratios? Does it effectively lower them all?

Would it mean a whole new gearbox or could you modify the existing box?

Doxster

Original Poster:

48 posts

236 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
And I'm also talking about manual gearboxes rather than complex auto/twin clutch/ semi-auto.

Thanks

DonkeyApple

70,899 posts

200 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
You just swap the cogs in a manual.

If you look at some of the Tremec or Getrag gearboxes or generally any mass produced gearbox that has been used in multiple applications then you often find there are a range of off the shelf options.

But, in most cases it is a longer final drive or a digger ratio for 1st for trucks.

Your first step is to find out what the gearbox is in the car. Then see if there are already options or then go to one of the indy manufacturers and get your set made up. The latter being rather costly.

xRIEx

8,180 posts

179 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Doxster said:
What does altering the final drive ratio do to the rest of the ratios? Does it effectively lower them all?

Would it mean a whole new gearbox or could you modify the existing box?
Yes it does. It would (should) also be the same process for manual and auto gearboxes; if a car has a separate gearbox and diff (as most FE/RWD do) rather than a transaxle, you wouldn't even touch the gearbox.

DonkeyApple

70,899 posts

200 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
One question to ask is does the previous model Boxster have these long ratios on its 6 speed manual? And if not, is it the same gearbox?

kambites

71,718 posts

252 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
As someone said above, if you're happy with lowering all the ratios by the same amount, the obvious thing to do would be to replace the differential.

DonkeyApple

70,899 posts

200 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
It looks like the earlier 6 speed was from Getrag and the latest one is from Aisin.

The smaller Camaros use an Aisin 6 speed as do plenty of other cars.

I would confirm that it is an Aisin box and then get the spec details and look around for one with a different set of ratios. I'd be surprised if their weren't alternative ratios for other manufacturers. You might get lucky.

bigkeeko

1,370 posts

174 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
I changed the diff ratio on a car once. I went from 3.27s on a car I had a couple of years back to 4.10s. Made a noticable difference in performance. Sounds strange but the way I`d describe it was it felt like the car had lost weight or had been stripped out. 2nd gear pulled like 1st did before, 3rd like 2nd etc. Mine was a auto. I bought a handheld tuner adjust the settings in the auto box and to re calibrate the speedometer.

Edited by bigkeeko on Monday 6th April 08:30

dxbtiger

4,556 posts

204 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
bigkeeko said:
I changed the diff ratio on a car once. I went from 3.27s on a car I had a couple of years back to 4.10s. Made a noticable difference in performance. Sounds strange but the way I`d describe it was it felt like the car had lost weight or had been stripped out. 2nd gear pulled like 1st did before, 3rd like 2nd etc. Mine was a auto. I bought a handheld tuner adjust the settings in the auto box and to re calibrate the speedometer.

Edited by bigkeeko on Monday 6th April 08:30
On a Mustang by any chance?

Quite a popular mod here.

bigkeeko

1,370 posts

174 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
dxbtiger said:
On a Mustang by any chance?

Quite a popular mod here.
Yes, a 2003 SN95 GT. I reckoned the 3.27s were in there just to appease some regulatory body. The 4.10s woke the car up.

996TT02

3,342 posts

171 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
The one answer is that everything is possible, it's just a question of cost.

In more detail, if there exists an aftermarket (or factory) solution then you know the cost, if there does not, then you don't, and it's likely to become much more expensive.

Since what you really wanted to ask (ultimately, consciously or not) was the cost, then you could decide what car you are talking about and look into it in some detail.

As others have pointed out, if you want all over shorter ratios, you'd look at the diff side of things, not the box ratios per se. You would change the ratios if you wanted them (generally) closer together i.e. less of a rev drop between one ratio and another. Racers often want both!

ZX10R NIN

30,662 posts

156 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
The easiest way is to alter your Final Drive it's an easier & cheaper solution.

DonkeyApple

70,899 posts

200 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
ZX10R NIN said:
The easiest way is to alter your Final Drive it's an easier & cheaper solution.
I did get the impression that the top gears were fine as they are cruising gears but that the new Boxster has very long driving gears that many have said spoils the point of opting for the manual as the spacings and ratios aren't matched to English roads.

If this is correct then it can only be resolved by changing the early cogs to effectively have a 'close ratio' first half of the box.

Mound Dawg

1,931 posts

205 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
It's quite common in older rear drive Alfas to do this. Smaller engine versions come with lower diff ratios so you just lop a rear axle from a 1300 or 1600 into your 1750/2000 and you're away.

For the later 3 litre 75 which has a 3-point-something diff ratio you just fit the 4.1 from a Twinspark and they go like stink but then you're bouncing off the rev limiter at 135mph.


Doxster

Original Poster:

48 posts

236 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for the input everyone. It has given me something to think about.

May try asking the question on some of the american Porsche forums to see if it's been done - They seem to be a bit more liberal with their approaches to car modification.