Car classifieds - describe your ideal website
Discussion
Just wondering if you were in charge of designing the ideal car classifieds system, what would be your must-haves and the icing on the cake?
Are you happy with the existing options?
I quite like all the features on PH's classifieds but always end up having to check AutoTrader etc. too to make sure I've scoured the whole market. My issue is that both are pretty clunky when you're setting up the search.
Are you happy with the existing options?
I quite like all the features on PH's classifieds but always end up having to check AutoTrader etc. too to make sure I've scoured the whole market. My issue is that both are pretty clunky when you're setting up the search.
hornetrider said:
The opposite of the way PH has done it.

Auto Trader isn't bad in terms of interface, but the restrictions on search terms are daft and unnecessary. All it needs is text fields where you can enter precisely the ranges you want for price, age, engine size / whatever. Limiting you to settings like "2.0 to 2.5 litres", "over 10 years old" and suchlike is idiotic.
I actually like the configurability options of the PH sales, at least for searching for something to buy. It's nice to see what V8s are on the market, or something front engined and rear wheel.
One thing I think is missing from a number of sites (or maybe it's just me) is ruling out particular makes, i.e. I might want to search for V8s, but don't want a BMW. I know I can pick all the makes I want, but I might want to see something that I might not know about, and know I can do this by selecting all and unselecting BMW, but it'd be convenient to just add "None of these makes"
Also, the "newly added" option is good to save looking at the same adverts over and over again.
One thing I think is missing from a number of sites (or maybe it's just me) is ruling out particular makes, i.e. I might want to search for V8s, but don't want a BMW. I know I can pick all the makes I want, but I might want to see something that I might not know about, and know I can do this by selecting all and unselecting BMW, but it'd be convenient to just add "None of these makes"
Also, the "newly added" option is good to save looking at the same adverts over and over again.
I like the idea of omitting certain makes. Whilst looking for an estate recently, all the searches threw up things like Vauxhall Agilas and Suzuki Wagons and boxy things like that, it would be better if I could have just blocked those. Thankfully the PH classifieds lets you set a minimum BHP!.... I always had to revert to Parkers though as they were the only ones who had dimensions so I knew what would fit in the garage....
being able to search for GTI/Sport versions on all models. I know you can do a search on sites, but sometimes I don't know what I fancy but I might want the top end of all cars and knowing and then searching for each model is a chore. does this make sense? you can't just type in sport as some cars are GSI/SRI/Type R/VRS etc.
I'd like a site that prevented the misrepresentation of what's being sold, e.g.:
People who put 120 miles instead of 120,000
Also interior colour should be a search field (with a mandatory completion)
Also a site that didn't insert irrelevant "Sponsored Adverts" into the search results (Autotrader will insert a 520d into the results of a search for a 3 litre / 6 cylinder car)
Every site (eBay, Autotrader and PH) has some good / bad points:
eBay's ability to limit the model year of a car is useful, also sorting by latest listings is good, inability to define engine size is a pain, inconsistent prevention of keyword spamming is crap (520d, not 530d, 535d, 540i, Audi.....).
Autotrader's lack of enforcement of information truthfulness (mileage misrepresentation mainly) is a pain.
People who put 120 miles instead of 120,000
Also interior colour should be a search field (with a mandatory completion)
Also a site that didn't insert irrelevant "Sponsored Adverts" into the search results (Autotrader will insert a 520d into the results of a search for a 3 litre / 6 cylinder car)
Every site (eBay, Autotrader and PH) has some good / bad points:
eBay's ability to limit the model year of a car is useful, also sorting by latest listings is good, inability to define engine size is a pain, inconsistent prevention of keyword spamming is crap (520d, not 530d, 535d, 540i, Audi.....).
Autotrader's lack of enforcement of information truthfulness (mileage misrepresentation mainly) is a pain.
Pistonheads has the right idea with selection criteria based on a cars attributes rather than just its make and model, fuel type, no. of doors etc. However Autotrader has more cars on it.
Some sort of broker site that checks them all including ebay, gumtree etc. would be good with the same things as pistonheads plus the ability to check boxes on options that were available on each specific car e.g. heated seats can be selected when looking for BMW 5 series but no point having it as a possible option if looking at Ford Kas (I'm sure someone will probably correct me to say you can get heated seats on a Ford Ka but you get the idea). That would also be good if you were doing a generic search including a specific option you wanted but were considering multiple cars as different manufacturers have different terms for the same thing, like Mercs distronic plus vs. others adaptive cruise control, saves you typing every name for it individually.
Some sort of broker site that checks them all including ebay, gumtree etc. would be good with the same things as pistonheads plus the ability to check boxes on options that were available on each specific car e.g. heated seats can be selected when looking for BMW 5 series but no point having it as a possible option if looking at Ford Kas (I'm sure someone will probably correct me to say you can get heated seats on a Ford Ka but you get the idea). That would also be good if you were doing a generic search including a specific option you wanted but were considering multiple cars as different manufacturers have different terms for the same thing, like Mercs distronic plus vs. others adaptive cruise control, saves you typing every name for it individually.
Autotrader is almost prefect, it needs a few things though. The ability to filter cars by year instead of age (up to ten years) needs to be implemented. Also would like it so that all adverts have to have mandatory information: pictures, mileage, MOT length. Nothing worse than an advert lacking those things.
I have suggested this to PH over the years but its been ignored:
Fields to be completed by private individuals >
1. Sellers own name on V5 - this weeds out the "home trader auction house ebay types", if it isn't there you are a trader, none of this "bought for the wife but too fast for her" nonsense.
2. Length of time car owned in years and months.
3. VCAR status upfront.
4. The words "not for the faint hearted" to be completely banned....



Fields to be completed by private individuals >
1. Sellers own name on V5 - this weeds out the "home trader auction house ebay types", if it isn't there you are a trader, none of this "bought for the wife but too fast for her" nonsense.
2. Length of time car owned in years and months.
3. VCAR status upfront.
4. The words "not for the faint hearted" to be completely banned....




Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


