"Fully protecting" your car?
"Fully protecting" your car?
Author
Discussion

CAJ83

Original Poster:

7 posts

139 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Hi guys, new member here, been lurking for a few years but finally decided to sign up as an actual member.

Anyway a bit about me, I've worked in the motor trade for the last 5 years as a sales person and the main focus point for us tends to be finance penetration and add ons, the cars tend to be little more than entrance points to get your products in. Despite what some people think about the huge amounts of profit there are in the cars themselves, the reality is the profit margins are small, especially on new cars.

Moving on, I fully appreciate that most people don't walk into a dealership with the intention of buying asset protection, paint protection, tyre and alloy and extended warranties, especially when you can bolt on about £2000 worth of "add ons" to a purchase. I also understand that some customers hate the product presentations, but unfortunately we sales people are just doing our job.

Now I obviously tend to come across common objections for each of the products, and as part of the sales process we're told to "throw the hooks in" etc, and while there are customers out there that will never buy any add ons, there are some that can be swayed into it when you build value into a product, or of course those that are happy to take a car "fully protected" as long as it's in their monthly budget.

Anyway while I've rambled on a bit (sorry), how many of you tend to "fully protect" your cars? For those that don't, why don't you? Do you not see any value in the products? Is it price?

Yes some of you are probably aware that the brilliant paint and interior protection is often just slapped on by the valeters in 20 minutes and the mark up is huge etc, but I'm just genuinely interested in getting opinions from people on here, who I feel will give an honest reason as to why they like, dislike certain products.

For example I'm genuinely shocked when someone doesn't take Asset protect (or G.A.P as it's often referred to) as it's a great product in my opinion. Paint protection whether it be GardX, Diamondbrite, SuperGuard etc is not worth the cost in my opinion, although obviously in doing my job I'd never say that (good being anonymous behind a keyboard eh?!)

P.S I have noticed that car sales people aren't well liked here, but we're not all the same smile



Edited by CAJ83 on Tuesday 7th April 22:19

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Sorry, but this just sounds like a salesman trying to get the customer to tell them why the 'hard sell' didn't work, so that they can try a different tactic next time.

I just stop listening and tell them that they either STFU and sell me the car or I'm walking.

My pet hate is when they blatantly lie and say "legally, I have to waste 30 minutes of your time trying to sell you these st add-ons that you can get for a tenth of the price somewhere else" - whether that's paint protection potions or GAP/RTI policies.

A BMW dealer even tried to get me to pay £250 for tyre insurance that would only cover 1 tyre.

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
For example I'm genuinely shocked when someone doesn't take Asset protect (or G.A.P as it's often referred to) as it's a great product in my opinion.
Have you ever considered that your marks will likely just go and buy it elsewhere but at a cheaper price?

I also agree that it's a vital insurance to have if the vehicle is expensive.

CAJ83

Original Poster:

7 posts

139 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
Sorry, but this just sounds like a salesman trying to get the customer to tell them why the 'hard sell' didn't work, so that they can try a different tactic next time.

I just stop listening and tell them that they either STFU and sell me the car or I'm walking.

My pet hate is when they blatantly lie and say "legally, I have to waste 30 minutes of your time trying to sell you these st add-ons that you can get for a tenth of the price somewhere else" - whether that's paint protection potions or GAP/RTI policies.

A BMW dealer even tried to get me to pay £250 for tyre insurance that would only cover 1 tyre.
I'm sorry if my post has come across as me simply fishing for "tactics", or ideas on how to deal with objections. I've posted here fully aware that most people on this forum are switched on, and not likely to take some of the products offered.

The average customer doesn't tend to post on car forums etc, people on pistonheads are a minority I would say. And besides I tend to ask customers why they don't want to take the products out, why they don't see the value etc


With regards to having to go through the procucts etc, we are regulated by the FCA and we do have to tell you about the products, if you don't wish to take them that's fine, and you have to sign a form as you know saying that you've been offered the products but have declined them. That then prevents a scenario where you drive away with your car, it gets written off, and you then take legal action because you would have taken G.A.P out had you been offered it.

Edited by CAJ83 on Tuesday 7th April 22:41

CAJ83

Original Poster:

7 posts

139 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Motorrad said:
Have you ever considered that your marks will likely just go and buy it elsewhere but at a cheaper price?

I also agree that it's a vital insurance to have if the vehicle is expensive.
Yeah absolutely, there are customers that even bring up the cheaper Internet policies during their objections.

But there's a reason why some are cheaper, it's like mobile phone insurance, when you go directly with the network you pay higher but you generally get a replacement within 24 hours. Unlike say mobile insurance banks provide or protect your bubble etc that involve filling out lots of forms, and weeks to get a replacement.

I appreciate that gap cover sold by a dealership doesn't equate to a faster payout necessarily, but just trying to highlight the fact that cheaper isn't always better.

It's the same with car insurance, some of the cheaper premiums are all well and good....Until you need to claim.

J4CKO

47,109 posts

231 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Because it is all bks ?

They get you when you are in the frame of mind of a new purchase, you ant to protect it and make the experience extra special but in reality it is snake oil, GAP insurance ? I just insure it via my normal policy, "Paint Protection", does it protect it from peoples carelessly slung open doors ? well thats a load of crap then.

It is the same reasoning I use when I buy a TV, I dont need 10 years warranty as frankly, after three I will bin it and buy a new one if it breaks and I dont need a £49 Gold plated HDMI cable as a standard £1 off Amazon does the job as well.

It may be a bit more honest just to ask for some extra cash off the customer rather than the snake oil, but I cant blame them for trying.

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
With regards to having to go through the procucts etc, we are regulated by the FCA and we do have to tell you about the products, if you don't wish to take them that's fine, and you have to sign a form as you know saying that you've been offered the products but have declined them. That then prevents a scenario where you drive away with your car, it gets written off, and you then take legal action because you would have taken G.A.P out had you been offered it.
I understand the FCA and the insurance angle - it's just that all the 'vanity add-ons' seem to always come after the 'FCA says we have to hard sell this overpriced insurance' spiel, which makes the naive car buyer think there's something 'legally required' about tyre insurance or higgs boson paint protection coating.

I just assume the salesman is trying to screw me over at every opportunity - and will do for a less savvy customer.

Fox-

13,578 posts

277 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
I don't take paint protection becuase I can do it myself for less money.

I don't take GAP because the same product can be found on the internet for 25% of the price the dealer is asking for. I'd have purchased GAP on my last car had the dealer offered it at £99 - as I could find online - not £499.

I don't take finance because if I wanted finance I could find a personal loan at a far better rate with a high street lender.

When I go to a car dealer it's because I wish to purchase a car. Not a finance product, or some polish, or whatever else - a car. It genuinely amazes me how obsessed some salesmen are and how generally poor the sales technique is at times. I once had a salesman begun the 'Have you thought about Supaguard' chat before we'd even made it over to the car in question. No attempt to build desire for the product, no wait for me to experience and want the car. Just straight in..

CAJ83

Original Poster:

7 posts

139 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Because it is all bks ?

They get you when you are in the frame of mind of a new purchase, you ant to protect it and make the experience extra special but in reality it is snake oil, GAP insurance ? I just insure it via my normal policy, "Paint Protection", does it protect it from peoples carelessly slung open doors ? well thats a load of crap then.
.
I'd agree that paint protection is not worth getting, I made sure my family members didn't take certain add ons when I went with them to purchase their car.

But with G.A.P there are definite positives, imagine a scenario where Mrs Jones is 2 years into a 5 year HP on her Vauxhall Corsa that she bought on 0% with no deposit, if she has a crash and her car is declared a total loss, she's going to need to find that shortfall, and as you can probably guess, a car like that is certainly going to have negative equity.

CAJ83

Original Poster:

7 posts

139 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
I understand the FCA and the insurance angle - it's just that all the 'vanity add-ons' seem to always come after the 'FCA says we have to hard sell this overpriced insurance' spiel, which makes the naive car buyer think there's something 'legally required' about tyre insurance or higgs boson paint protection coating.

I just assume the salesman is trying to screw me over at every opportunity - and will do for a less savvy customer.
Unfortunately you're quite right that some sales people will try to "screw people over", it's morally wrong but it happens.

The type of customer usually is someone desperate for credit, and they're just happy to be driving away a new car for £200 a month, even though they could have had that same car for £150 a month without all the add ons.


Roo

11,504 posts

238 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
You're new to this car sales and Internet malarkey aren't you.

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
But with G.A.P there are definite positives, imagine a scenario where Mrs Jones is 2 years into a 5 year HP on her Vauxhall Corsa that she bought on 0% with no deposit, if she has a crash and her car is declared a total loss, she's going to need to find that shortfall, and as you can probably guess, a car like that is certainly going to have negative equity.
We're not claiming GAP/RTI is a bad product - we're saying the product offered by the shysters at a dealership is not value for money and we'd wish you'd stop trying to say that the dealer is 'adding value' by adding a zero to the end of the price and saying it's the best thing since sliced bread because it now has a marque logo on the leaflet.

Mopar440

410 posts

143 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
With regards to having to go through the procucts etc, we are regulated by the FCA and we do have to tell you about the products,
That is there for the protection of the customer, not the dealer, I think you'll find.


2.5pi

1,091 posts

213 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
I'd agree that paint protection is not worth getting, I made sure my family members didn't take certain add ons when I went with them to purchase their car.

But with G.A.P there are definite positives, imagine a scenario where Mrs Jones is 2 years into a 5 year HP on her Vauxhall Corsa that she bought on 0% with no deposit, if she has a crash and her car is declared a total loss, she's going to need to find that shortfall, and as you can probably guess, a car like that is certainly going to have negative equity.
You're right GAP has a place , for customers who can't bridge the GAP if their funded vehicle gets totalled.

Thankfully it's available at far lower prices than dealers charge 😄

talksthetorque

10,821 posts

166 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Imagine Mrs Jones had exactly the same experience only she had bought GAP at 20% of the price you were trying to charge her. She'd still have met the finance obligations, and she'd have an extra £400 in her pocket,

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
With regards to having to go through the procucts etc, we are regulateoby the FCA and we do have to tell you about the products, if you don't wish to take them that's fine, and you have to sign a form as you know saying that you've been offered the products but have declined
Do FCA really say that you legally need to offer paint protection, and the consumer needs to decline in writing?

UK345

441 posts

189 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
The only real product which makes sense is the service plan. Except from that waste of time. I used to work at a service desk for a massive car sales company and often had to tell people that had forked out money for these plans that their problem wasn't covered. The dealer want the most money out the customer yet when the tables are turned and they need to pay up they try get out of it.

Personally i wouldn't deal with a pushy salesperson. I'd just take my business elsewhere. I once visited a dealership and was approached by a salesperson while his manager who was watching his every move (don't think he had hit targets). I said i was only in for a look yet he still stuck with me. When i left i noticed the manager and the salesperson were staring at me leaving the dealership.

Lets face it the majority of sales people are a pain in the ass.


J4CKO

47,109 posts

231 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
J4CKO said:
Because it is all bks ?

They get you when you are in the frame of mind of a new purchase, you ant to protect it and make the experience extra special but in reality it is snake oil, GAP insurance ? I just insure it via my normal policy, "Paint Protection", does it protect it from peoples carelessly slung open doors ? well thats a load of crap then.
.
I'd agree that paint protection is not worth getting, I made sure my family members didn't take certain add ons when I went with them to purchase their car.

But with G.A.P there are definite positives, imagine a scenario where Mrs Jones is 2 years into a 5 year HP on her Vauxhall Corsa that she bought on 0% with no deposit, if she has a crash and her car is declared a total loss, she's going to need to find that shortfall, and as you can probably guess, a car like that is certainly going to have negative equity.
Surely if it is insured, the insurance company will pay out an appropriate value, Mrs Jones sorts herself out another car with the proceeds and keeps paying the payments ?




CrgT16

2,527 posts

139 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
I think most add one are not good value for money. Paint protection is one of those ridiculous rip offs!!

I have taken GAP in a few cars and I understand there are differences between GAP and RTI. on a PCP perhaps GAP gives piece of mind and in my view it is cheap.

Again each one to their own. For me I guess it depends on the car but only add on I consider is GAP, all the rest is not worth it for me... Always feels like a rip off.

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
CAJ83 said:
I also understand that some customers hate the product presentations, but unfortunately we sales people are just doing our job.

Now I obviously tend to come across common objections for each of the products, and as part of the sales process we're told to "throw the hooks in" etc, and while there are customers out there that will never buy any add ons, there are some that can be swayed into it when you build value into a product, or of course those that are happy to take a car "fully protected" as long as it's in their monthly budget
Avoiding any contact with people like you is why I enjoyed the process of leasing my car and why I'm likely to do it again.

If I never have to have any contact with a shiny-suited car salesman trying to sell me tyre insurance and Supagard dross I'll be very happy indeed.

I have GAP from ALA. Nothing else is remotely worth it.