2.5k, comfy, safe, and quick
2.5k, comfy, safe, and quick
Author
Discussion

FD3Si

Original Poster:

857 posts

175 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Snooore, a what car...
Unfortunately I'm having to sell my Clio 172 cup as my littl'un hates it, so I need a replacement.
He seems a bit sensitive to the massive road and engine noise, which is fair enough, it's blummin' noisy in the back!

So I need a replacement - I figured that looking at my requirements, a car that's 'fun' in terms of chassis isn't really do-able(these don't tend to be compatible with a requirement for quietness!), so I'm inclined to go the other way and with something that's got a reasonable turn of speed in a straight line, but is comfy and refined.
So, requirements:

- Reliable
- Good turn of speed ( >200bhp)
- quiet inside
- Safe for the lil' dude
- under 2.5k
- quite a lot of life left in it.
- Manual

A fun chassis would, as mentioned be a bonus, but I've accepted dthat with my other requirements it's not really do-able.
I don't do loads of mileage, so economy isn't top priority.

Current main contenders are 9-5 HOT Aero and S60 T5, but both seem quite thin on the ground (for manuals, anyways)

An RX8 would be perfect, but there's already a rotary in the household, I can't be doing with doubling the amount of yearly rebuilds.
Also ruled out an E46 as we've already got one!

So, fire away...

Edited by FD3Si on Wednesday 8th April 09:18

R2T2

4,089 posts

153 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Grande Punto T-Jet?

1.4 Turbo, so fairly economical.
120hp/155lb-ft
Not riddled with faults like previous Fiats.
ISOFIX
5 Star NCAP.

Good cars, the Abarth 500/Grande Punto turbocharger swaps straight in so teamed with a remap 170-190 is manageable.

Make sure the cambelt has been done recently, as it will need to be done by age.

They're also a lot quicker than the figures suggest, Fiat claim 8.9 to 60, but I managed 8.3 with a full tank of fuel and to fat sods in the back in wet conditions.

In the dry, running on fumes with a lightweight driver 7's should easily be manageable.

confused_buyer

7,143 posts

212 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
9-5 and S60 are good options. Something like an Accord Type-S might be worth a look as well.

FD3Si

Original Poster:

857 posts

175 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Re: The Punto - Good suggestion, but at the risk of sounding like an arse, I want more than 120bhp. I think I've become a bit spoiled! If I have to sacrifice the 'fun' aspect, I at least want something with a good turn of speed biggrin

Other thing I was looking at was Mondeo ST24s, but they seem a bit bottom of the barrel for my budget.

Edited by FD3Si on Wednesday 8th April 08:37

Session8

145 posts

172 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
I think your two main contenders will crop up in a lot of people's suggestions. Both cars meet your criteria and both are quite well respected.

I've got a 9-5 HOT Aero Estate that I use as a work hack and carrying duties. My weekly commute is two 300 mile journeys which in the Saab I can do in one stint which to me is a mark of how comfatable the car is. It's by no means a hot hatch for handling but the chassis is more than adequate to let you know what is going on, Bhp & tourqe are more than adequate to facilitate quick progress, two or three car overtakes are dispatched with ease and a bit of a grin (when safe to do so of course).

I bought mine well under your budget with under 90k on the clock, FSH and a stack of receipts. Both front seats are electric, all seats are heated, full leather. Heated mirrors, dimming mirrors etc etc. All of it works and has cost me nothing in the last 25k apart from servicing.

The only downside for you is the majority are autos as you've already identified, I was never an auto man prior to the 9-5 but the 5 speed auto in the car suits it very well. It's never caused a problem if I need to press on, pop it in sport mode and it holds the gears just right a changes quick and clean.

Good luck in your search.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Haha, I came on to say a Saab 9-5 or S60, but you might also want to look at a Saab 9-3. Should be able to pick up a manual T6 S60 for your budget if you're willing to wait for one to come along, and then when you get bored of it 290 or more BHP is only a remap away. Even the 200bhp 2.5T has plenty of go though.

You could also look at V6 Mondeos? Not sure what an ST220 is worth these days but I wouldn't be surprised to see plenty for less than £2500.

BritishRacinGrin

26,714 posts

191 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Renaultsport Megane? Are they in this kind of price bracket yet?

TVR keith

1,917 posts

253 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
MX5

FD3Si

Original Poster:

857 posts

175 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Megane would be good, but in that price they're dogs.

Re: The Auto thing - a lot of it it because our other car (e46 330i) is an auto, I'd quite like a manual, although I guess I'll try an auto Saab (but I've ruled it out on the S60 for reliability reasons)

My other half isn't keen on the Mondeo, but I'll try one to see if I can convince her. How do they deal with higher mileages? Everyone I know with a Mk3 seems to have quite a few issues (albeit ones with cheap parts!) at post 100k.

How do the 2.5T S60's compare to the T5?

TVR keith said:
MX5
That's hilarious, where did you come up with that? Was it whilst a well built company director was hammering frozen sausages into your lawn? You could give Alan Carr a run for his money. Laugh? I nearly did.*

  • I really didn't at all.

lickatysplit

473 posts

161 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
I assume with having a child it needs to be some sort of saloon or at least 4 seats?
does it have to be FWD?
what about an older Merc CLK? Manuals are a bit thin on the ground though
Jag S-type?
or, an MG ZT-T, you might even find a V8 in your price range these days. I owned one of these and a jag S-type many years ago and I was gutted I got rid of the ZT TBH.

scarble

5,277 posts

188 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Having skimmed over the requirements, my first thought was a 1*2, then I read again laugh

Why not a full fat 1*2? They're quieter and softer than the Cup. If you can find one without Eibach springs it'll be even softer. They also have side airbags if that's a good thing for you? Although only in the front I think.

I have a feeling Renaults in general are safer than anyone would give them credit for too, Renault really put a lot of work into crash safety of the shell and no doubt many have been crash tested on track days.

The CTR is a bit quieter too.
Alternatively, buy him some earplugs or cute little earmuffs?

Edited by scarble on Wednesday 8th April 09:21

andy-xr

13,204 posts

235 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Just take him out in the BMW?

FD3Si

Original Poster:

857 posts

175 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
No need for FWD at all, it's jsut that was what my two main contenders happened to be biggrin
Will take a look at the ZT, but my preconceptions will need some work biggrin
I can't stomach the thought of an S Type - my other half worked with JLR's aftermarket division so is all too aware of what an S Type can bring biggrin

I must admit I'd thought about a FF 182, but they aren't that much quieter in my limited experience.

My stupid brain is now encouraging me to go back to my roots(had a DC2, best car we've ever had) and look at an Accord Type R, a car that fulfills basically none of my requirements...

Regarding using the E46 - we have days where one of us picks up the little guy and the other drops him off, so unfortunately a compromise isn't suitable (we tried it before with the MX5 we previously had, the Clio was its' practical replacement...) End of the day his happiness comes before my want to arse about in a car. I've got a fun car for the weekends if I need that smile
Also, my wife has some issues which mean driving the auto BMW is often more comfortable for her.

Edited by FD3Si on Wednesday 8th April 09:24

TWPC

911 posts

192 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Hope I'm not barking up the wrong tree here, but how about these?

Ford Mondeo ST220 (2003)
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/f...

Audi A6 Quattro (2000)
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/a...

Mercedes S350 (2002)
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/j...

Not sure if your concerns about the the S-Type extend to the XJ, but if not...
Jaguar XJ6 3.2 (X300) (1995)
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/j...

Jayho

2,442 posts

201 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Alfa Romeo V6 in some carnation which is applicable? Should be nice and refined while at the same time you can roll the windows down and listen to the soundtrack?

BritishRacinGrin

26,714 posts

191 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Jayho said:
Alfa Romeo V6 in some carnation which is applicable? Should be nice and refined while at the same time you can roll the windows down and listen to the soundtrack?
A great engine but I'm not sure how putting it in some extended life canned dairy product would make it better?

y2blade

56,325 posts

246 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Volvo T5...you choose the body style

SirSquidalot

4,067 posts

196 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Accord type r?

DJP

1,201 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
FD3Si said:
...I guess I'll try an auto Saab (but I've ruled it out on the S60 for reliability reasons)
Which is ironic because it's the same gearbox in both cars.

The whole Volvo gearbox thing is overstated. It arose because Volvo don't specify changing the gearbox fluid, whereas other manufacturers using this gearbox do.

Just find a Volvo where the gearbox is still working properly and get the fluid changed. Then it'll stay working.

I did and mine was fine with over 120k on it (and a colleague at work has one with over 150k on it which is still perfect).

MOTK

347 posts

165 months