Insurance refusing to pay out as car is already a CAT C
Insurance refusing to pay out as car is already a CAT C
Author
Discussion

eltax91

Original Poster:

10,796 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Hi guys

Interesting situation here. Sat with a colleague in the airport, he runs a weekend toy, which he acquired as a CAT C

write-off, around 3 years ago. He fixed the minor bodywork damage and took the car through a VIC, and an MOT and has

had it road legal (tax, mot and ins) ever since. The car itself isn't worth a great deal (sub £1k), but it has some

serious mods that cost him several thousand pounds to buy and fit. An estimated value given to the insurer 3 years ago

was around £5k of mods (supercharger, injectors, exhaust, wheels, uprated breaks, coilovers, etc)

He has a policy through a very well known broker (may even advertise here a lot!), which is a specialist modified car

policy, this policy has EVERY mod declared to the insurer, right down to the type of wheels and the "quickshift" kit

that's fitted. It very specifically states on the paperwork that the car was the subject of a CAT C write off and was

repaired and VIC checked. The policy has come at a not-inconsiderable cost over the last 3 years.

My colleague has the original scanned declaration of all the mods and the insurer has not changed since inception 3

years ago, he's renewed with the same insurer every time.

Anyway, over the bank holiday weekend, the car was at a local specialist having some tuning work done and he received a

call yesterday from the owner, saying unfortunately several scrotes had broken into the garage, smashed the key storage

box off the wall and taken a number of vehicles, his included.

Today, he has heard from the broker that he is not covered for the theft of his vehicle. The justification from the

agent on the phone is that the insurer has NO RECORD of the CAT status of the vehicle. Despite my colleague having a

scanned copy of the documents he returned via email to the broker 3 years ago. The broker says they are not at fault as

they simply hold documents for the insurer, they have confirmed they have the copy of his documents and that they can

see the CAT status declared, however, there is some ambiguity over whether the insurers online system that the broker

uses to input policy details has a "free form" field for filling in extra details, i.e. it doesn't match the form

identically, or at least has changed in that 3 years.

So, is my mate up for a long fight via the ombudsman? Who shells out here? The people who Doc Brown's capacitor is

named after, or the insurer themselves?

The current suggestion from the broker at the minute is to approach the MIB and ask them to cover him since he's

essentially a victim of a mistake within the industry! I don't think livid quite sums up his attitude at the moment!!

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Interesting to see how Flux deal with this one, receiving some bad press on here lately.

Evanivitch

26,534 posts

153 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Not that I can help the issue in hand, but can I ask if the garage insurance would be expected to pay out?

C. Grimsley

1,381 posts

226 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Hope you get it all sorted, or should that be your friend, I personnaly have lost faith in the insurance system but if it's a case like yours I would be taking it to the courts, I had to do it and I won but it took 18 months and was a massive stress.

Good luck, Carl

gtidreamer

176 posts

146 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
Not that I can help the issue in hand, but can I ask if the garage insurance would be expected to pay out?
This has to be the right answer... The cars security was the responsibility of the garage who had it, they should have insurance to cover this eventuality.

eltax91

Original Poster:

10,796 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
C. Grimsley said:
Hope you get it all sorted, or should that be your friend, I personnaly have lost faith in the insurance system but if it's a case like yours I would be taking it to the courts, I had to do it and I won but it took 18 months and was a massive stress.

Good luck, Carl
I followed the thread, beginning to end. This happened in our area, the car was at a specialist in a Leicester suburb!

I know you are a garage owner, interesting point put forward by others about the garage insurance. Would you have cover to pay out in such circumstances??

Sheepshanks

41,393 posts

150 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
He has a policy through a very well known broker...
It very specifically states on the paperwork that the car was the subject of a CAT C write off and was repaired and VIC checked.
......

The justification from the agent on the phone is that the insurer has NO RECORD of the CAT status of the vehicle.
I appreciate the story is second-hand, but I don't understand the contradiction above - he's got a policy that notes the Cat C status bit the insurer doesn't know anything about it?

How can it possibly be anything other than the broker's problem?

Re the MIB - I don't think this is the sort of thing they pay out on. Indeed they don't generally pay out themselves anyway, they lean on insurers to do it.

eltax91

Original Poster:

10,796 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
eltax91 said:
He has a policy through a very well known broker...
It very specifically states on the paperwork that the car was the subject of a CAT C write off and was repaired and VIC checked.
......

The justification from the agent on the phone is that the insurer has NO RECORD of the CAT status of the vehicle.
I appreciate the story is second-hand, but I don't understand the contradiction above - he's got a policy that notes the Cat C status bit the insurer doesn't know anything about it?

How can it possibly be anything other than the broker's problem?

Re the MIB - I don't think this is the sort of thing they pay out on. Indeed they don't generally pay out themselves anyway, they lean on insurers to do it.
My thoughts exactly! As far as I see it, he has the paperwork to prove he notified the broker. The broker in this case is saying that the insurers system doesn't allow for a free form box to notify them of the CAT status, and since they don't specifically ask for the CAT status of the vehicle, the broker says the insurer is responsible. However, the insurer says "you didn't tell us, we are not paying", so he's stuck between broker and insurer and getting fobbed off by both!

jonah35

3,940 posts

188 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
The garages insurance should pay out

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
gtidreamer said:
This has to be the right answer... The cars security was the responsibility of the garage who had it, they should have insurance to cover this eventuality.
If the garage had been negligent they would probably be liable, if they had taken reasonable steps to prevent a theft then it's fairly unlikely they would be deemed liable

C. Grimsley

1,381 posts

226 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all

eltax91 said:
C. Grimsley said:
Hope you get it all sorted, or should that be your friend, I personnaly have lost faith in the insurance system but if it's a case like yours I would be taking it to the courts, I had to do it and I won but it took 18 months and was a massive stress.

Good luck, Carl
I followed the thread, beginning to end. This happened in our area, the car was at a specialist in a Leicester suburb!

I know you are a garage owner, interesting point put forward by others about the garage insurance. Would you have cover to pay out in such circumstances??
Yes my garage insurance would cover the car, I would think the owner of the garage is trying his luck to get him to claim on his own insurance?

If it's a small outfit, there may not be a policy in use and the only insurnace they had would be to road test the cars (road risk?)

Carl

Carl


Edited by C. Grimsley on Wednesday 8th April 22:19

jonah35

3,940 posts

188 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
dacouch said:
gtidreamer said:
This has to be the right answer... The cars security was the responsibility of the garage who had it, they should have insurance to cover this eventuality.
If the garage had been negligent they would probably be liable, if they had taken reasonable steps to prevent a theft then it's fairly unlikely they would be deemed liable
I think the garage would be liable. Let's say you left it at a main dealer and it got stolen or a ramp fell on it then it's the dealers problem.

Insurance is based on good faith regardless so you will be ok.

Gareth79

9,177 posts

277 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
He needs to ask the broker where to go from here, if they have hit the end of what they want to do they should invite him to start the complaints procedure.

His paperwork should have the procedure, and they *should* offer him the details again and also send an FCA booklet with his rights.

As with all complaints of this nature, stick to the pure facts and keep the waffle to a minimum.

The garage's insurer might be liable, but his broker/underwriter would have rejected it if they didn't think they were liable because it was at a garage, that would have been a much simpler reason!



andymc

7,628 posts

238 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
I think the insurer's HPI the car on policy start up

eltax91

Original Poster:

10,796 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
C. Grimsley said:
Yes my garage insurance would cover the car, I would think the owner of the garage is trying his luck to get him to claim on his own insurance?

Carl
He hadn't gone down the claim with the garage route. The garage owner lost one of his personal cars and also most of his expensive equipment. He has gone uncommunicative at the moment though, presumably this is because he's a bit busy trying to rescue his livelihood.

From that point of view I'm wondering what he would have to gain by reducing the size of his claim? He's got several cars and a whole load of tools to claim for, so presumably he has to pay his excess anyway.

I wonder if he has insurance. I had not thought about the garage angle so I didn't mention it to my pal, so no idea if he's had that chat with the guy, but sounds like he hadn't.

juansolo

3,012 posts

309 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Flux have been nothing but ste with me the last 3 years I was with them. First they didn't update the system one renewal time causing me to get a rather strongly worded letter from the DLVA informing me about my impending prosecution for being uninsured for 6 months (news to me). I get all that sorted out and have a breakdown, call up the company on the card they supplied and they'd never heard of me. Finally after a few hours of ringing backwards and forwards I got them to accept I had breakdown cover and I had to cancel the call out because the garage I needed recovering to had now closed (yes it took that long). To which they wanted to charge me call out I assume for wasting their time...

...and you wonder why I didn't renew with them this time. If this is what they're like when you don't have to make a claim...

I really wish you all the luck in the world. But none of this surprises me.

Everything you've posted looks like you've gone the extra mile to make sure you're insured (as you have to given the fkers will try anything to wiggle out of not paying), now they're saying essentially he isn't. As Flux has taken your money for the last 3 years and not provided you with insurance (which is the function of a broker). Maybe you can claim against them... or at least 3 years insurance costs they failed to deliver. Essentially that's theft isn't it? You paid for a service that they've failed to provide.

Edited by juansolo on Wednesday 8th April 22:36

LoonR1

26,988 posts

208 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Well a load of bizarre info on here that has no grounding in reality.

The garage may well be liable, but only if negligent. If they did everything reasonable to prevent the thefts then there will be no negligence on their part.

As for the broker trying to renege on the policy, I doubt this very much indeed. There is no way that a highly modified vehicle on a bespoke policy like this would not have something as blatant as the Cat C status missed. If it is missed then it's simple that the broker has cocked up amd will have to cover the cost themselves.

Stuff like this is easily resolved

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
jonah35 said:
I think the garage would be liable. Let's say you left it at a main dealer and it got stolen or a ramp fell on it then it's the dealers problem.

Insurance is based on good faith regardless so you will be ok.
That's not how it works.

Insurance being based upon (Utmost) Good Faith is between you and your own Insurer, the OP is a third party to the Garage's Insurance.

The OP's claim against the garage would be using civil law where you would generally need to prove the garage had been negligent eg had not taken reasonable steps.

If the garage had not taken reasonable steps eg had not locked the gate, had previous recent break in attempts and taken no action etc etc then they may well be liable.

You could leave your car with a garage and the garage catch fire due to no fault of the motortrader and the garage would probably not be liable.

Having said that, in a lot of cases of the motor trade insurer will pay the claim without query

eltax91

Original Poster:

10,796 posts

237 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
LoonR1 said:
Well a load of bizarre info on here that has no grounding in reality.

The garage may well be liable, but only if negligent. If they did everything reasonable to prevent the thefts then there will be no negligence on their part.

As for the broker trying to renege on the policy, I doubt this very much indeed. There is no way that a highly modified vehicle on a bespoke policy like this would not have something as blatant as the Cat C status missed. If it is missed then it's simple that the broker has cocked up amd will have to cover the cost themselves.

Stuff like this is easily resolved
Yeh. I think he's going to call the broker tomorrow and ask to speak to someone more senior. If he can't then he will open an official complaint with them. Not sure what cover the garage does or doesn't have, but I'd say they took reasonable precautions to protect the keys.

The key point is all the cars taken were parked outside the premises, the two cars inside on ramps both were incapable of running without work. They evidently forced a steel security door some how, got in, setting the alarm off, took a lump hammer to the security box full of keys, opened the shutters, loaded up all the expensive looking diag hear and we're off. Owner reported to my mate that it was 3 minutes between alarm registering an intruder to cctv on the industrial estate catching the cars leaving.

Seems they gained access over some local fields and through a half decent sized stream to get to the property without being seen!

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
Yeh. I think he's going to call the broker tomorrow and ask to speak to someone more senior. If he can't then he will open an official complaint with them. Not sure what cover the garage does or doesn't have, but I'd say they took reasonable precautions to protect the keys.

The key point is all the cars taken were parked outside the premises, the two cars inside on ramps both were incapable of running without work. They evidently forced a steel security door some how, got in, setting the alarm off, took a lump hammer to the security box full of keys, opened the shutters, loaded up all the expensive looking diag hear and we're off. Owner reported to my mate that it was 3 minutes between alarm registering an intruder to cctv on the industrial estate catching the cars leaving.

Seems they gained access over some local fields and through a half decent sized stream to get to the property without being seen!
Without knowing the full situation it sounds like he's taken reasonable precautions so would not be liable but it would depend on the full details.

Incidently the security box full of keys is most likely a key cabinet attached to a wall which most Insurer stipulate motortraders do to reduce the risk of a thief (Or sneak thief) stealing cars