A "which car" poll :)

Poll: A "which car" poll :)

Total Members Polled: 77

Waft: BMW E38 ('95-'01) 7 series: 51%
Play: MX5 (probably Mk2, 1.8): 29%
Something else - please expand below: 21%
Author
Discussion

defblade

Original Poster:

8,081 posts

244 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Giving up commuting by motorbike and therefore deserve a treat wink

The commute is about 14 miles of DC and Mway, followed by 3 miles of traffic lights and traffic (usually moving OK between the lights, but there's many sets of lights). I have to provide the family car along the way, so an MX5 can't be my only car.

I have a nice Suzuki Grand Vitara at the moment - low mileage, very FSH, actually in what I understand by the phrase "VGC" (as opposed to the dealer version wink ) that I managed by find at a reasonable price, too. I bought it as the family car, and to keep me mobile if/when snow stopped motorbike commuting. It makes less sense as my every day car though (ok, it's boring rather than "not sensible"!) and so I thought I was set to treating myself to option 1:

BMW E38 7 series. I was looking at about £3Ks worth, plus or minus. Engine size TBC but they're all capable wink I quite fancy being wafted down the Mway and then having an auto for all the lights. In this case, I would be selling the Suzuki on.
I'd probably shift the 7 on after maybe a year in favour of something more sensible (Honda Accord tourer or '07 -on Mondeo estate currently top of the list), so the dire MPG is in return for the luxury, but not forever.


But... we used to have a Mk2 MX5 and I do miss it; it's one the few cars which the idea of driving raises my pulse a bit in the same way biking really did. Option 2 comes with a few riders though:

MX5: price £1.5 - 2K. Keep the Suzuki as I won't be able to fit any useful combination of wife/daughter/dog in it. We only have a 2 car drive at the moment, so this will also mean removing a large fir tree, moving the current wall which cuts across the drive at 45' out to 90', building new wall across the end and cementing the new area to make a 3 car drive. Quite a bit of work, and that's where the extra grand in the budget goes. Downsides: more tax, insurance, servicing/MOT costs having 2 cars, the commute is never going to excite much, even with the roof down. Upsides: convertible, trackdays, having another car handy when one breaks.




I'm in plaster for another couple of weeks at the moment, so no choice has to be made quickly... but my head's spinning from all the classifieds wink


BTW, FWIW, my better half says "do what you want to - you always do anyway!"




Option 3: other - please don't bother mentioning big fast MB estates as beloved of the barge thread - already considered and rejected in favour of the 7 smile

poing

8,743 posts

231 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
I loved my MX5's but it would be dull on that type of commute. Might as well chill out in a big comfy sofa for motorway and traffic driving, voted BMW.

defblade

Original Poster:

8,081 posts

244 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Forgot to add: I keep getting drawn to Stageas, too, but the necessary £5-6k budget means it'd have to be a moderately sensible long termer and I'm not sure it could be (and I'm a bit nervous of import-only cars, to be honest, in terms of living with, servicing etc, long term).

dbdb

5,270 posts

204 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
My vote goes to 'Waft', but I would rather have a Jag than an E38.

defblade

Original Poster:

8,081 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
dbdb said:
My vote goes to 'Waft', but I would rather have a Jag than an E38.
A Jag's on the B list, but not ruled out. I'm not sure I fit in them (6'4") so I may try sometime if there's one near me and not too sure about the rear legroom/boot space either... all things that I need to have a poke around at. But I've got a feeling a 7 wins on all of them.

Howard-

4,964 posts

233 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
These cars are like chalk and cheese (obviously) - I don't know why you're asking us, as it's entirely personal preference, surely? It's like asking "Should I buy a blue car or a red car?" confused

Mike22233

822 posts

142 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
E39 530/540 an option?

forzaminardi

2,298 posts

218 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
Much as driving the MX5 in the rain and on the motorway might be a drag, when the weather's OK and you get the chance to enjoy it there's nothing better than a topless commute. Aside from some topless commuters, if you live near the Playboy Mansion.

Anyway, so why not go with the MX5 for the fun of it and just use the Vitara whenever you need a solid roof or a more comfortable commute?

TurboHatchback

4,240 posts

184 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
Waft for me. I'd personally pick a Mercedes W126 over an E38 but either are good.

kambites

71,729 posts

252 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
I'd have thought an MX5 would get annoying on that commute, so I'd say the wafter makes more sense.

luckystrike

536 posts

212 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
I've said MX5 but I've made assumptions doing so.

It's a short enough commute that even if some of the traffic's stop-start it won't be long and grating enough to lose the sense of occasion with the roof down on a sunny day.

Secondly, if you're currently in plaster and not commuting by motorbike any more I'm assuming the two are related. If this is driven by necessity rather than choice the sense of freedom and wind in the hair from the mx5 will go some way towards mimicking what you had with the bike. A 7 series will cosset beautifully but that might highlight what you miss. Then again it might not, I don't know smile

A 2 car combo with mx5 and vitara covers loads of bases rather well. A 7 series covers 1 base very well. Quite a lucky place to be frankly, not sure you can make a bad decision either way.

Morningside

24,147 posts

260 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
7 series. Then again I was biased. I went from TVR to a 750. Fantastic car and would have another.

TheJimi

27,798 posts

274 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
I voted waft, purely on the basis of the description of your commute.

As a previous MX5 owner (Mk2 as well!) that commute would grate on me in a '5 - they are pish motorway cars imo.

talksthetorque

10,821 posts

166 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
7 Series. What could possibly go wrong...
Just out of curiosity, why do you need a 3 car drive for 2 cars, or have I read this wrong?

Riknos

4,701 posts

235 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
For that commute I'd go with an auto E39 5 series.

Warnie

1,451 posts

230 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
this.

plus I wouldn't be comfortable spending 3k on an e38, when they can be had for a lot cheaper and then can be weighed in if it throws up a big bill.

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
never been a wafter, MX5 for me

defblade

Original Poster:

8,081 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
talksthetorque said:
7 Series. What could possibly go wrong...
Just out of curiosity, why do you need a 3 car drive for 2 cars, or have I read this wrong?
My wife has a car too, an Aygo (which I quite enjoy driving actually - it likes to rev. Just don't tell my wife wink ), which is not part of the Man Maths.


I'd probably grab a 540 touring if I found a good 'un, but they seem to be very thin on the ground. And almost certainly be very happy with it for many years. A 530 would be fine, too, but really beginning to lack the sense of a bit of a silly treat that I'm after.

The 3K 7 series budget could easily go a grand either way; I can spanner/torx/solder my way out of most breakages on older cars. God knows I kept a stheap of an E46 going for 2 years longer than I should have (and would have carried on - needed new radiator that time - if I'd not found the Vitara).

Lexus LS is also on the radar, but they do look like melted Mercs...


I would say they choices are chalk and cheese, but that doesn't mean I don't need a bit of a kick up the arse to help me see which might be nicer. Especially when all I can do at the moment is think about it!




And yes, there is a direct link between being in plaster and no longer commuting by bike. It's been a considered decision rather than forced one... The new commute (started a new job 10 days after the operation! "Hi, I'm your new manager, I can only use one arm at the moment") itself is a fair part of it - it'd be a relatively boring ride everyday, there's no sensible B road alternative, although I was looking forward to filtering through all the lights...

defblade

Original Poster:

8,081 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
luckystrike said:
Quite a lucky place to be frankly, not sure you can make a bad decision either way.
That's most of the problem!

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Thursday 9th April 2015
quotequote all
Sports cars are fine in traffic, wafters are still wafters on twisty roads.

I had a 5 series once. Loved the noise, wished it could have been in something more nimble.

MX5 or whatever car you'll most enjoy owning. I'd love an R32 Skyline GTSt, if there were any left that weren't terrible.