Golf 5 1.9 tdi strange power
Golf 5 1.9 tdi strange power
Author
Discussion

vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Dear friends, hello, I am a new user here hopefully we will have a nice discussion.
I just bought a golf 5 1.9 tdi and i did a remap, however the first time the golf was on dyno made 120bhp and after the remap it made 155 as you can see from the graph.
The golf was from a previous owner and it has 170k kilometars. So how can this golf 6 speed 1.9 tdi make 120bhp standard. I think it is standard or what would be the mod so that it will make the golf 120bhp.
thank you and if this topic is not in the right section please move it. The guy said that the nozzles might have been changed can that be?









SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Pretty sure you could buy Golf Mk5 with the 130PS 1.9TDi PD engine, which I expect yours is.

Yours probably lost 10 hp during its 170,000 km life, which isn't too bad really!

8Ace

2,836 posts

229 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperPav said:
Pretty sure you could buy Golf Mk5 with the 130PS 1.9TDi PD engine, which I expect yours is.

Yours probably lost 10 hp during its 170,000 km life, which isn't too bad really!
Yep, this.

vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperPav said:
Pretty sure you could buy Golf Mk5 with the 130PS 1.9TDi PD engine, which I expect yours is.

Yours probably lost 10 hp during its 170,000 km life, which isn't too bad really!
OK so what is a PD engine, does it come standard from the Factory or you have to mod it, this is a golf 5, mk 5, 1.9 tdi 6 speed, arent they all 105bhp?
I drive a gsxr 750 so i understand what mods would require to make mu gsxr 750 have more bhp but i do not know much about cars.
Thanks.

andburg

8,787 posts

200 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
I'd suggest both figures are rather optimistic.

Can't say I'm aware of a 105bhp 1.9tdi gold with a remap alone making anywhere near 155bhp.

135bhp Is probably to be expected from figures quoted around the web so around 13% optimistic.
13% reduction in 12 will give you around 105bhp.


thats my thoughts anyway

stavers

319 posts

177 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
vlavot said:
So how can this golf 6 speed 1.9 tdi make 120bhp standard. I think it is standard or what would be the mod so that it will make the golf 120bhp.
Are you 100% sure that it is a 1.9? If it's a 6 speed gearbox I think it's highly unlikely to be a 1.9 as the 1.9 was sold almost exclusively with a 5 speed box.
It wasn't until the 2.0 (with 140PS as standard) that the 6 speed became a standard gearbox.

Also, from what I can find, the Golf only came with the 1.9 a maximum of 103PS.

So either the car isn't a 1.9 or someone has already done some work on the car but if that's the case then I would be surprised that a simple remap would raise the car another 35bhp.

8Ace

2,836 posts

229 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
stavers said:
Are you 100% sure that it is a 1.9? If it's a 6 speed gearbox I think it's highly unlikely to be a 1.9 as the 1.9 was sold almost exclusively with a 5 speed box.
It wasn't until the 2.0 (with 140PS as standard) that the 6 speed became a standard gearbox.

Also, from what I can find, the Golf only came with the 1.9 a maximum of 103PS.

So either the car isn't a 1.9 or someone has already done some work on the car but if that's the case then I would be surprised that a simple remap would raise the car another 35bhp.
Lady Ace's 03 plate Sharan has a 6 speed box and the 130bhp PD.

stavers

319 posts

177 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
8Ace said:
stavers said:
Are you 100% sure that it is a 1.9? If it's a 6 speed gearbox I think it's highly unlikely to be a 1.9 as the 1.9 was sold almost exclusively with a 5 speed box.
It wasn't until the 2.0 (with 140PS as standard) that the 6 speed became a standard gearbox.

Also, from what I can find, the Golf only came with the 1.9 a maximum of 103PS.

So either the car isn't a 1.9 or someone has already done some work on the car but if that's the case then I would be surprised that a simple remap would raise the car another 35bhp.
Lady Ace's 03 plate Sharan has a 6 speed box and the 130bhp PD.
Yeah - the bigger cars had a 1.9 130 but the Golf, as far as I am aware, never did. Some Golf's did have a 6 speed but, again from what I can find, only 1 trim level.
That's not to say that someone hasn't uprated the car to the 130PS spec and then there is this tune on top of that...

vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Well yes it is a 1.9 tdi, it has webasto aux heating can that be the reason for mpre hp, and looks like it is standard and nothing has been done to it, all factory looks like. And can the dyno reading be 15bhp off. The car works fine, sounds nice pulls like an animal no vibrations everything nice. And will this 155 bhp lower my engine life and increase fuel comsumption.

All that jazz

7,632 posts

177 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
stavers said:
vlavot said:
So how can this golf 6 speed 1.9 tdi make 120bhp standard. I think it is standard or what would be the mod so that it will make the golf 120bhp.
Are you 100% sure that it is a 1.9? If it's a 6 speed gearbox I think it's highly unlikely to be a 1.9 as the 1.9 was sold almost exclusively with a 5 speed box.
Don't talk rubbish please. All the (later, at least) GT TDI PD130 1.9s have the 6-speed box. I had 2 myself.

vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
All that jazz said:
Don't talk rubbish please. All the (later, at least) GT TDI PD130 1.9s have the 6-speed box. I had 2 myself.
Yes but this is mk5 they do not come wuth 130bh

Sensibleboy

1,168 posts

156 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Would they really have sold a MK5 1.9 with 130 bhp when the 138 bhp 2.0 PD was available? ??

It's definitely a MK5 is it?

Edited by Sensibleboy on Friday 10th April 12:02

greggy50

6,281 posts

222 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Most VW diesels will dyno above stock power you will find they tend to underate them slightly...

SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
The 1.9 PD 130PS was available, and was fitted to Mk4 Golfs definitely, and I *thought* was in some early Mk5's as well, but may be wrong.

Original poster, can you tell us where you're from - different markets got the 2.0TDi engine at different times.



vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
greggy50 said:
Most VW diesels will dyno above stock power you will find they tend to underate them slightly...
Yes, I am from Macedonia, europe, but the golf was imported from Germany 6 years ago, and i am pretty sure it is not 2.0, and it has the BCK engine number.

SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
vlavot said:
Yes, I am from Macedonia, europe, but the golf was imported from Germany 6 years ago, and i am pretty sure it is not 2.0, and it has the BCK engine number.
That's not a code I recognise. Are you sure it's not BKC, which would put your car as a pre-2007 1.9TDi with 105PS.

If that's the case, then as someone mentioned previously, VW's often under-rate power on some variants, or the dyno you used could be relatively "favourable" to the output.

Doubt it would have previously been modded or chipped to get 15PS out of it, since these respond really well to a chip tune.

BGarside

1,568 posts

168 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Mk5 Golf was not sold with the 130hp 1.9 TDI engine, only a 105hp version. The higher-powered versions had the 2.0 TDI, initially in PD form, with 138hp.

VW TDIs tend to put out a little more than the rated power anyway. Coupled with an 'optimistic' (i.e: flattering) dyno that would account for your 120hp I imagine.



vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperPav said:
That's not a code I recognise. Are you sure it's not BKC, which would put your car as a pre-2007 1.9TDi with 105PS.

If that's the case, then as someone mentioned previously, VW's often under-rate power on some variants, or the dyno you used could be relatively "favourable" to the output.

Doubt it would have previously been modded or chipped to get 15PS out of it, since these respond really well to a chip tune.
Ah sorry, yeah it is BKC model it is 2005, pre 2007 with 105.
Ah sorry it is BKC code, and it is 2005 model, just wondering what will the mod be so that it would add 15 bhp. Can bigger injectora make 15 bhp or that is a different story. And it is not as simple. I have read how some golfs 5 made 115 110 but never 120 on a dyno.

engine number.
So you think that non mod will make that big of a difference, plus even if it is moded it wony add another 35 bhp after the remap.

If this is true and this really is a stock golf 120 bhp than this would be a golden sample smile

vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
BGarside said:
Mk5 Golf was not sold with the 130hp 1.9 TDI engine, only a 105hp version. The higher-powered versions had the 2.0 TDI, initially in PD form, with 138hp.

VW TDIs tend to put out a little more than the rated power anyway. Coupled with an 'optimistic' (i.e: flattering) dyno that would account for your 120hp I imagine.
So might just the dyno readings be a little off

vlavot

Original Poster:

10 posts

139 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperPav said:
Pretty sure you could buy Golf Mk5 with the 130PS 1.9TDi PD engine, which I expect yours is.

Yours probably lost 10 hp during its 170,000 km life, which isn't too bad really!
OK so what is a PD engine, does it come standard from the Factory or you have to mod it, this is a golf 5, mk 5, 1.9 tdi 6 speed, arent they all 105bhp?
I drive a gsxr 750 so i understand what mods would require to make mu gsxr 750 have more bhp but i do not know much about cars.
Thanks.