De facto MX 5 or am I being a knob?
De facto MX 5 or am I being a knob?
Author
Discussion

Colon

Original Poster:

27 posts

161 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Good evening PH'ers.
As you guys have influenced my last two car purchases with input, opinions being totally correct as to what would happen your views please.
With a budget of £1500 max a convertible summer fun run around with a view to a possible European Jaunt September ish, ( Roscof, St Naziere, Bordeaux, Pyrenees, South France to visit relatives, then back up through the Alps on a route to be determined) is required.
Looking at a throwaway type of car for the journey, (your last influence was a major shedding success) has to last 6/7 months without giving a huge bill that I am unable to fix/bodge, ( rules out an Alfa that was the first and rather painful influence) the choice is obviously the MX5, then while was perusing the small ads looking at alternative stuff like Saab Convertibles, BMW's etc, I came accross the SLK 230, why are they so cheap? When I looked at Fuelly it was only a few mpg worse than the 5..... Is this right or would I be a knob for considering one?

Cheers in advance.
Colon the Old fart on a mid life writing this from a £14 Hostel in Chiang Mai.

SirSquidalot

4,067 posts

196 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
The answer is always MX5 i'm afraid wink

Axionknight

8,505 posts

166 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
They're cheap because when they break it's generally pants down time unless you are a good DIY mechanic or have an excellent, well priced specialist indy near by.

TwistingMyMelon

6,519 posts

236 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Mx5 sounds spot on for that . Owned one for a few years and loved in it

If they do go wrong cheap and simple to fix , what you see is what you get .

Wouldn't fancy a slk , better on motorway but auto would be no fun on twisties

Sells are pricey and complex to fix with supercharges , auto box and electric roofs

xRIEx

8,180 posts

179 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
A Z3 is just about doable in that budget, no idea how ropy it would be at that price. I'd still probably go MX-5 though.

Or MG F/TF?

James19181

270 posts

143 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
My boss asked me look over an mk1 (R170?) SLK320 with him. It was a clean example, but even so it felt like the steering wheel wasn't connected to the front wheels, it just seemed so vague and unfeeling. Manual 'box was crap too. Engine in the 320 sounded pretty good mind. He bought it though and loves it because he just cruises in it, and I'm sure it's fine for that.

The OH had an mx5 (mk1) and for driving involvement and enjoyment it's just worlds apart. On a tour like you're planning, for the sake of comfort my head (and arse) would probably go for the SLK... but I'd be kicking myself every time the road got twisty.

paulwirral

3,836 posts

166 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
I've just bought a slk 230 for much the same reason as yourself , looked at £1500 mx5s , and as good as they are I bought the slk for 2k , ive had both before years ago when they were almost new .
They are no where near as bad a drive as people say , change the gearbox oil and leave it 300ml low and the shift is much better , easy to fix and euro car parts and the like supply parts at banger prices , just done a service including pads , discs and belts myself with basic tools .
They are a much better place to be than an mx5 on a long journey , granted no where near as good round a track but I'll do a few laps of the ring this year just for a laugh , the trade off is a comfortable car to do a 1400 mile round trip in on motorways .

CCM604e

110 posts

141 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Researching this exact thing right now - for a trip to St Nazair and down the coast funnily enough.

MX-5 is my choice right now but also considering SLK and Z3.

Be careful of the rust issues on the MX-5, this is what's putting me off. I suppose if it won't see another MOT then it's not such an issue?

em177

3,150 posts

195 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Axionknight said:
They're cheap because when they break it's generally pants down time unless you are a good DIY mechanic or have an excellent, well priced specialist indy near by.
Erm...

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
em177 said:
Axionknight said:
They're cheap because when they break it's generally pants down time unless you are a good DIY mechanic or have an excellent, well priced specialist indy near by.
Erm...
I think he means the SLK?

andburg

8,787 posts

200 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Given the mileage to be done and the alps involved if you go MX5 make sure its a 1.8

For all the duller roads however I'd probably be looking at something a little bigger with a bit more waft than fizz and a 6th gear as the MX5 can be a little tiring on motorways.

Renault Megane CC 2.0 VVT manual, that bit more comfort, a metal roof. Should have no problem with reliability and if you're in mainland europe parts are probably easier to come by if anything does go wrong.

If it were me I'd probably ignore sense and take an alfa spider!

Poopipe

619 posts

175 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Long trips at 70-80 mph are not an mx5s forte. Wind noise and 3500-4000 rpm get pretty tiring after a couple of hundred miles.

I find them quite a comfortable car when it comes down to contact points and seats so being in one for long periods isnt a problem for your body, its just the noise that gets to you.

if you're content to cruise at 50-60 things are a lot more civilised.

One thing they do have going for them is easy maintenance - 3 spanners and a hammer will deal with most jobs and its not hard to come by parts cos there's loads of em about.

at 1500quid i cant think of anything else without a roof that id risk a long drive in.

JQ

6,892 posts

210 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
Poopipe said:
Long trips at 70-80 mph are not an mx5s forte. Wind noise and 3500-4000 rpm get pretty tiring after a couple of hundred miles.

I find them quite a comfortable car when it comes down to contact points and seats so being in one for long periods isnt a problem for your body, its just the noise that gets to you.

if you're content to cruise at 50-60 things are a lot more civilised.

One thing they do have going for them is easy maintenance - 3 spanners and a hammer will deal with most jobs and its not hard to come by parts cos there's loads of em about.

at 1500quid i cant think of anything else without a roof that id risk a long drive in.
A very good summary, and even if you're not great with a spanner you'll always find a specialist locally who charges less than most back street garages.

danjama

5,728 posts

173 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
An MR2 T-Bar (NA probably for your needs) will be quicker and more comfortable than an MX5. And you can have full confidence in its reliability.

Poopipe

619 posts

175 months

Friday 10th April 2015
quotequote all
too kind sir tongue out

Just a thought ... the autos have longer gearing - i think they rev out at a bit over 140 rather than 120 so may be more suitable for cruising the motorways of Europe

Colon

Original Poster:

27 posts

161 months

Saturday 11th April 2015
quotequote all
Thank you everyone for your replies.

I think the MX 5 is still favourite ( the 1.8). While I am in UK all it will be used for is a short drive to the marina (I look after a RIB for the summer) the gym, (both @ 5 miles) and general pleasure able hooning.

The Europe trip is planned to be non motorway, ( well the first bit to Antibes.)

Low cost low maintenance sheddy motoring plus I am reasonable with a set of spanners, really should be a shoe in. It was only when I checked Fuelly that the SLK cropped up as the mpg figures where similar. Is this really true? A 1.8 compared to a 2.3 forced induction.

Three weeks to make the decision, (going to look at Z3's) at the moment tis heart v head, SLK v MX5, the last time I did that the heart won and the world of pain that is Alfa ownership ensued, (so that rules out the Spyder)

Once again Thanks.



Edited by Colon on Saturday 11th April 03:46

Colon

Original Poster:

27 posts

161 months

Saturday 11th April 2015
quotequote all
Thank you everyone for your replies.

I think the MX 5 is still favourite ( the 1.8). While I am in UK all it will be used for is a short drive to the marina (I look after a RIB for the summer) the gym, (both @ 5 miles) and general pleasure able hooning.

The Europe trip is planned to be non motorway, ( well the first bit to Antibes.)

Low cost low maintenance sheddy motoring plus I am reasonable with a set of spanners, really should be a shoe in. It was only when I checked Fuelly that the SLK cropped up as the mpg figures where similar. Is this really true? A 1.8 compared to a 2.3 forced induction.

Three weeks to make the decision, (going to look at Z3's) at the moment tis heart v head, SLK v MX5, the last time I did that the heart won and the world of pain that is Alfa ownership ensued, (so that rules out the Spyder)

Once again Thanks.



Edited by Colon on Saturday 11th April 04:30

daveofedinburgh

556 posts

150 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
I've owned 2 mk1 MX5s, and they actually are the answer Im afraid to say!

Yes, they'll be a little tiresome on long, high-speed runs, but most equivalent stuff will be the same.

I currently have a 2000 facelift Z3 2.0, which was bought for £1750. Not many about at this price, mine was a garage trade-in that they seemingly CBA to value properly, but they are out there.

Totally reliable over 18 months of DD ownership, 6-cylinder engine in a little convertible not easy to come by at this price point.

Maintenance won't be as cheap/ easy as an MX5, but it does offer a realistic alternative to the 'no-brainer' MX5.

Cruising/ refinement in another league to the MX5 too...

Colon

Original Poster:

27 posts

161 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
Roger That.

As usual the answer was in the question. Next thing will be finding a relatively rust free 1.8 Mx5 when I return from the backpacking Asia phase of my midlife early May.
Thank you for your input.

Colon.

PS. Although I am fairly well decided I would like to retain the right to be a knob if the right SLK or Z3 option turns up.

Regards.

nunpuncher

3,770 posts

156 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
If its going to be throwaway then don't worry about the rust and just buy an mx5 for under a grand.

I've had 4. All have been rusty and all but one were very reliable. They are great fun but I will echo that they are tiresome at constant motorway type speeds. My last one which I sold 2 weeks ago was a 10AE model with the 1.8 the mazdaspeed can and the 6 speed box. The final drive is the same as the 5 speed I believe.