BMW diesels and timing chains
BMW diesels and timing chains
Author
Discussion

downstairs

Original Poster:

3,558 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
I had a look at a nice little BMW yesterday, five years old, low miles. The 143bhp version of the two litre diesel, badged as 18d. I really liked it.

But a quick bit of background internet research after looking would have me believe that all these two litre BMW diesel engines will explode inevitably into a clattering pile of components when the chain breaks due to a fundamental design oops. All of them, whatever tune and whether they're fitted to BMWs or MINIs. Honest John is littered with reports of such failures, and I daren't even venture onto specialist forums to read up now. It's almost enough to have changed my mind on the car completely.

But:

Really? The internet teems with horror stories about every possible subject: every car has chocolate engine internals and "known gearbox issues" if you look. If you feel ill the last thing you should do is Google your symptoms, so is that what I've done with this engine? BMW must have shifted thousands - even tens of thousands - of installations of this engine in the last five years or so. Is a few dozen exploding examples actually cause for concern?

Can I quickly canvass the views and experience of everybody on this please? I would happily buy the car I saw yesterday, but not if everybody in the world except me knows I'm doomed to throw my money down the toilet.

alangtt

279 posts

193 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
I was in your boat.
I was dead set on a 320d touring (m sport obvs) but couldn't get past what I was reading on the Internet and forums.
It seems like it could happen to any age or mileage n47 engine and I figured that it just wasn't worth it. Constantly on edge about new noises etc.
I had a quote for an aftermarket warrenty, it was about £600 although I didn't read the small print to see if this issue would be covered. Maybe a thought.
Good luck with your decision. smile

downstairs

Original Poster:

3,558 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
So you didn't go ahead with it after all? The car I looked at was from a franchise, so 12 months warranty - but that's slim comfort if I'm standing ruefully over a pile of components two years down the line.

e: it's an M Sport too, obvs!

AlmostUseful

3,319 posts

231 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
The E90 series of 3 series overtook the mondeo as the most popular reps car, and there must be hundreds of thousands about the place as a result. I'm sure what you've read has happened to a tiny fraction of cars sold, so it wouldn't be putting me off.
My old boss had a 320D on a 07 plate and did about 130k miles in 3 years with no bother, I'm sure the chances are yours will e fine too if you buy it.

mike9009

11,024 posts

274 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
Hi

It is always difficult to judge these things. I have a 2007 Mini Clubman S, which has impending doom written all over it according to the world wide web. I took a punt and four year later it is fine....
Would anyone risk a K series engine now? On anecdotal evidence, I probably would not..... (three friend have had head gaskets go....)

It would be useful to get a true scale of the failure rate data from the manufacturers. Unfortunately this would never happen (probably, as BMW, Audi and VW would look ste against their far eastern counter parts!). So if you want to buy a financially risk free motor that is 38 months old, buy a Kia.


Mike

PS my boss had a 2008 320D which went pop at 120k miles...

alangtt

279 posts

193 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
No. Didn't go ahead with it.
Understood the comments about outselling the mondeo but... If something was to go wrong (it would with my luck) It's a lot of money down the drain or to fix it. About 2000£ if I remember right.
Ideally if someone knew figure. 1 in 10 , 1 in 50

Slobberchops

3,641 posts

232 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
My old one had the engine out twice at least, due timing chain issues.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
Yet more reason to buy the BiG D 3ltr engines plenty of power and a sweet I6 motor.

The Big G

1,004 posts

199 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
AlmostUseful said:
My old boss had a 320D on a 07 plate and did about 130k miles in 3 years with no bother, I'm sure the chances are yours will e fine too if you buy it.
A 07 E90 would probably have the earlier m47 diesel lump. It's the later N47 engines that have the timing chain issues. The M47 has a down turned exhaust instead of chrome tips and when looking under the bonnet the engine cover is a square instead of a horse shoe shape of the latter. Engines changed earlier than the LCI facelift.

The earlier engine is slightly less efficient but generally more reliable. The Mitsubishi turbo is a known weak spot with no upgraded hybrid turbos available to improve on the bearings. As said, If you look hard enough most cars seem plagued with faults and you'd never buy anything!


Edited by The Big G on Sunday 12th April 09:06

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
I'm in a similar position, currently looking at either a 320d or 520d.

I posted a very similar question in the bmw section and got very helpful info that there is a recall on some of these engines.

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...


The user helix402 pointed me at the recall. No specific info on which cars are covered, but my research over the last week suggests that it its the 177bhp version - or at least 3 of those that I've looked into are up for the recall.

For me that is making the decision easier, I'll only consider a car which gets the chains done by BMW.

It has certainly been an issue on cars since 2007. Watchdog did a program on it.

Jonwm

2,754 posts

145 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
I ran a e90 318d for 3 years (61 plate) & 125k no issues, was even serviced and halfrauds the last few times as the lease company wouldn't pay BMW prices, had a rattle on start up from about 80k but never got worse and went after a few mins. Considered buying it for the other half when it went back as it was a steal at 6k but always had the chain in the back of my mind :-(

downstairs

Original Poster:

3,558 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
Cool, thanks. The one I was looking at is the N47 (it's a 59) so if I speak to the dealer about the recall is it likely / possible they might agree to the work up front?

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
mike9009 said:
Hi

It is always difficult to judge these things. I have a 2007 Mini Clubman S, which has impending doom written all over it according to the world wide web. I took a punt and four year later it is fine....
Would anyone risk a K series engine now? On anecdotal evidence, I probably would not..... (three friend have had head gaskets go....)
I'd much rather have a K series than the BMW junk. Provided you don't drive around with no coolant in the engine and badly overheat it, then it's cheap and easy to fix a head gasket on a K series. When a timing chain snaps on an N47, the engine is either scrap or will require very expensive work to rebuild it.

At least Rover managed to place the valve timing components where they could be changed cheaply and easily, rather than having to remove the entire engine. Another triumph of German design.

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
No harm in asking. Be interesting to hear what they say. BMW pay for it so...

V88Dicky

7,373 posts

214 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
Slightly o/t but how do the 2.0 petrol engines of similar age cope?

Do they have a timing gear similar to the N47? And what is the actual cause of these failures. is it the tensioners?

downstairs

Original Poster:

3,558 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
V88Dicky said:
And what is the actual cause of these failures. is it the tensioners?
What I've read suggests it's an oil supply issue that can be alleviated by more frequent oil/filter changes than most engines have had. ie 7,5-10,000 miles instead of 20-25,000. Of course, with a five year old used car it's more of a gamble I suppose.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
Question how much is a replacement chain fitted?
Can you opt for an upgraded chain which eliminates those issues?

If so then buy a cheaper 320d with that engine and get the work done probably cheaper than a warranty over a few years anyway!


V88Dicky

7,373 posts

214 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
20-25k oil change intervals!

What clown dreamt them up yikes

f1nn

2,694 posts

223 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
I have had experience of four 3 series:

2007 320D, ran to over 100k, needed nothing but servicing and consumables, but clutch was getting a bit slippy when it was handed back to the lease company at 3 years and 114K

2007 320D, again ran to over 100K, Turbo went the day before it was handed back at 3 years old and 105K, other than that nothing unusual.

2011 318D, needed nothing until 102k, when two injectors and the clutch and dual mass flywheel needed replacement.

2007 330D, required the EGR cooler replacing and both thermostats, but otherwise all is good.

So, from my experience, they'll give a you a few bills, mainly around 100k. For the use that mine have had, I'm satisfied. Something I would say though, that I think BMW's cope with the mileage in terms of paintwork, interior and the general feel of the car, far better than Fords and Vauxhalls I've ran, which have felt and looked very baggy (especially Vauxhall) by 100K.

Countdown

49,597 posts

227 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
downstairs said:
V88Dicky said:
And what is the actual cause of these failures. is it the tensioners?
What I've read suggests it's an oil supply issue that can be alleviated by more frequent oil/filter changes than most engines have had. ie 7,5-10,000 miles instead of 20-25,000. Of course, with a five year old used car it's more of a gamble I suppose.
FWIW that's what I've heard. IIRC the standard service interval is 18k-20k miles but that relies on genuine BMW-spec oil being used. Some people were using cheaper oil which degraded more quickly but they were still sticking to the 18000 mile service intervals resulting in timing chain problems.

Apparently cars with BMW FSH don't have problems.