Knock in low gears when lift off throttle
Knock in low gears when lift off throttle
Author
Discussion

CallorFold

Original Poster:

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Car in question is an RS Clio (2008)

Seem to have a strange issue whenever I change between 1st/2nd and 2nd/3rd gear at low RPM.

I can't quite work out if the knock is because I lift off the throttle, or press the clutch, or a combination of the two.

If I wait until 3K RPM or higher, or keep the accelerator very very slightly pressed the knock doesn't seem to occur.

The gearbox seems ok, as does the clutch - no slipping, no crunches on gear shifts etc.

After much Googling, I'm wondering if it could be the engine mounts? Lifting off the throttle adds some engine vibration which is causing the knock? The car does sort of "jump" when it happens and there's a sort of "bang/knock". It doesn't seem to make too much difference if the car is warmed up or run from cold, and it doesn't happen every time, it's more "intermittent".

Any ideas? Anything I can check/look for?

RobinBanks

17,551 posts

210 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Is it nothing to do with rev matching? Ie you lift off the accelerator and the revs drop and it's mismatched.

Or have I misunderstood?

CallorFold

Original Poster:

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
RobinBanks said:
Is it nothing to do with rev matching? Ie you lift off the accelerator and the revs drop and it's mismatched.

Or have I misunderstood?
Think slight misunderstanding, it's on up-shifts so no rev-matching.

So for example car in 1st, start rolling, accelerate up to 2.5K RPM, lift off accelerator/press clutch [KNOCK OCCURS], clutch out to engage 2nd, accelerate again.

The movement's are pretty much all-in-one fluid motion in the space of about 1 second.

996TT02

3,342 posts

171 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Engine mounts most likely culprit on a FWD car.

You may even be able to rock the engine by push-pulling on it.

Otherwise failed suspension bushes allowing one or both of the struts to move.

CallorFold

Original Poster:

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
996TT02 said:
Engine mounts most likely culprit on a FWD car.

You may even be able to rock the engine by push-pulling on it.

Otherwise failed suspension bushes allowing one or both of the struts to move.
I tried giving the engine a good shove, it moved a little, but nothing that I'd call "excessive".

joe1145

198 posts

152 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
By the sounds of it I'd say engine mounts. Although unlikely it's possible the engine is hitting something when it's rocking from the lift off.

Studio117

4,250 posts

222 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
996TT02 said:
Engine mounts most likely culprit on a FWD car.

You may even be able to rock the engine by push-pulling on it.

Otherwise failed suspension bushes allowing one or both of the struts to move.
This. normally the rear one from engine > subframe.

CallorFold

Original Poster:

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
It's not the best pic, but this is the top engine mount - looks to be in fairly good condition - no real wear etc. visible.



And from the otherside;


J4CKO

47,113 posts

231 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
I had a similar thing in a Montego (was a while ago in my defence !), was ok under load, come off the gas and clunk, bag on the gas, clunk.

Got progressively worse until I hoofed it out of a junction and the contents of the diff exited through the bottom of the car at high speed, I coasted to outside our house leaving a trail of cogs, chunks of casing and gearbox oil.

It was the centre pin in the diff that had worn, so the clunk was the slack being taken up and released, the pin was over half the diameter it should be and booting it stressed it enough that the whole thing failed in a most spectacular manner.

So, if there is no play in anything else, it may be something like that

Studio117

4,250 posts

222 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Studio117 said:
This. normally the rear one from engine > subframe.

CallorFold

Original Poster:

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
If it is the engine mounts, is there some sort of explanation why it only happens in lower gears and at low RPM? I'd expect there to be more engine vibration at higher revs/higher gears? Rather than the other way round.

J4CKO

47,113 posts

231 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
CallorFold said:
If it is the engine mounts, is there some sort of explanation why it only happens in lower gears and at low RPM? I'd expect there to be more engine vibration at higher revs/higher gears? Rather than the other way round.
It isn't engine vibration that is the problem, it is the leverage the torque is putting through the mounts which is greater during acceleration in the lower gears, at lower speed as the engine is working harder to shift the mass of the car and it has more leverage due to being in a lower gear.


LukeSi

5,780 posts

192 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Dog bone mount imo

CallorFold

Original Poster:

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
LukeSi said:
Dog bone mount imo
Is there any easy way to check this? Presumably I need to jack the front of the car up - is the dog bone mount visible? Or hidden under the bottom cover/tray?

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
CallorFold said:
996TT02 said:
Engine mounts most likely culprit on a FWD car.

You may even be able to rock the engine by push-pulling on it.

Otherwise failed suspension bushes allowing one or both of the struts to move.
I tried giving the engine a good shove, it moved a little, but nothing that I'd call "excessive".
To be fair though, the forces even a small car engine generates can make humans seem a bit puny.

If you can rock it a little, it can generate enough torque to rock itself more.

CallorFold

Original Poster:

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
There's a thread running on the Clio forum currently where someone seem's to have a similar/identical issue -

They been recommended getting the upper stabiliser and the lower torque link replaced. (Upper stabiliser is the part in the pictures above), and I believe the lower torque link is the "dog bone mount"?

So I think I'll have a look at replacing those first.

Edited by CallorFold on Wednesday 15th April 12:58