family car depreciation sweet spot
family car depreciation sweet spot
Author
Discussion

e8_pack

Original Poster:

1,384 posts

212 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Need to buy a family wagon, open to anything really, but an economical one would be welcome for little money.

Have a budget up to 16k, mileage about 7k/yr max, prob closer to 5k.

Is there a sweet spot on the curve? I can't go too far as reliability is high on the agenda. But because of the low miles i'm doing, I could possibly get a higher average miler that will be average by the time I sell it.

Any thoughts?


SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
3 year old Prius fresh off a lease. They seem to be holding their value ridiculously well (I bought a top spec one for £9,200 with 75k on the clock from a dealer, ran it for 18 months, sold it to we want any car for £8,800 with 95k miles and some body damage). It was an ex-EDF or eON fleet car so had lots of miles for the age but immaculate Toyota service history, and looked/drove like new.

Services are £139 (as you only need the minors!), there are no cambelts, turbos, DPFs, clutches, flywheels to go wrong. Minicab popularity means there's a lot of demand for them!

50+mpg, and a very relaxing drive.



Obviously don't buy if your daily commute is over the Stelvio pass etc.

Ian Geary

5,663 posts

223 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Do lease / hire / fleet companies still shift cars once they reach 3 years?

The budget I personally use for my family wagons would have a nought knocked off the end of your budget.

In 5 years of motoring I've only had to fork a couple of hundred on repairs (excluding service items and tyres).

Bear in mind unfashionable / ugly family cars will always be lower on the curve (C5, any Chevrolet) whereas flasher metal stays stubbornly above the curve until they reach starship mileage.

Ian

wemorgan

3,583 posts

209 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
IMHO £16k is far from any sweet spot.

For a bog standard family car £5-10K is more than ample for a reliable car with modest depreciation and running costs, possibly 5 years old.

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
e8_pack said:
Is there a sweet spot on the curve?
Not really, it's pretty much inverse exponential for most cars, at least for the first ten years or so. We tend to buy at something like 3-5 years old but there's no right or wrong age to buy.

£16k is a lot to spend on a family car if you're worried about costs. I'd be aiming to spend no more than a third of that, you can get some very nice family cars for £5k.

Pit Pony

11,532 posts

152 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Previous family Car :

Given by family member when worth £2000 (offered him £2K but he refused) in 2000. An 8 year old Cavalier.

Sold it in 2013 for £200 (was retired from family car duties in 2011, and used by wife as a local hack)

Current Family Car

£4500 2004 Honda Accord Diesel Purchased in 2011. Probably worth £2500 now, and will be hacked hard until 2018 when it will be worthless.

I see 75K (ie 2/6th of it's life used up) and 5/6 th the original price used up as the sweet spot.

Just like my mate who has a 76K CLS 3.2D Merc worth £8K - that to me is the sweet spot if you wanted a £60K car. Still got 2/3rd it's life left at 1/6th the original cost.

e8_pack

Original Poster:

1,384 posts

212 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
I compared Vauxhall Insignia to Merc C220 on the what car calc and although new the merc held more of its initial cost price, the following depreciation in percentage terms was a bigger cash value. Though im not sure how accurate the calc is.

16k is max, prefer to spend less of course. XF's are favourable so far, but then you look at the cheaper alternatives, mondeo's etc which have enough toys/space/convenience to make them excellent at what they do and hard to discount. Even hateful insignias.

UK345

441 posts

189 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
What about a lovely well cared for Rover 75 ? You can get a top specification with work carried out on it etc. The good thing about is there are loads in the scrappy so you can run it cheaply and get a continual parts supply.

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
How about a mk2 Octavia VRS TDi? You should get a good one for ~£5k. Enormously practical cars and whilst they're never going to set the world alight, they drive perfectly adequately for ferrying the family around.

The Mondeo is very good car too, if you want something that enormous. smile

gvij

365 posts

155 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
With a budget of 16k I would lease a new car. There isn't any point in messing around with used cars if you can afford it especially if its a family car. Sure tasty sporty or luxury cars can cost 35+ to buy and bigger money to lease but bogs standard golfs or seat leons are cheap as chips.
On the other hand if you want a cheap reliable family car then something without a dpf, turbo, dmf and a good reputation from around 2005 should be peanuts to buy and run ex fuel. Will probably be a petrol though to fit those needs.

dave_s13

14,032 posts

300 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
My ford galaxy seems to have lost virtually nothing in the year (nearly) we've had it so far. Cost just over half your budget and is proving to be really very good.

So, maybe look at 10k's worth of SMAX/galaxy?

If they float your boat obviously, you need to need one for practical reasons only really.

e8_pack

Original Poster:

1,384 posts

212 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
gvij said:
With a budget of 16k I would lease a new car. There isn't any point in messing around with used cars if you can afford it especially if its a family car. Sure tasty sporty or luxury cars can cost 35+ to buy and bigger money to lease but bogs standard golfs or seat leons are cheap as chips.
On the other hand if you want a cheap reliable family car then something without a dpf, turbo, dmf and a good reputation from around 2005 should be peanuts to buy and run ex fuel. Will probably be a petrol though to fit those needs.
Not really an option with the mileage/use I'd get out of it, but did cross my mind.

shake n bake

2,221 posts

238 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Qashqai or ix35 all day long. Not many cars hold there value as well as those two do.