Petrol grade for business mileage
Discussion
I admit, put this in the First World problems league, but I have a potential issue in the very near future regarding business mileage.
I'm currently field based, working for a major food retailer which also has its own petrol stations. I claim my fuel costs at a set rate per mile, as I use my own private vehicle for my travel which is approx 12k per year business mileage. Up until now they have accepted any VAT fuel receipt with my claim, which I get back as cash in hand.
After a draconian, knee jerk review of expenses it now seems they may only accept mileage claims if their own brand petrol is purchased, which does make business sense on the one hand, as it increases revenue at the pumps if all the field team do this.
The issue is my car is the 180bhp VAG 1.4TSI engine which is 98ron recommended, and I have only ever used super unleaded in it. Admittedly it is 95ron minimum, but have heard many reports of rough running, reduced MPG and general potential for engine unhealthiness, probably exarcebated as it probably won't be the greatest of 95ron petrols being a supermarket offering.
There's every chance this won't be enforced strongly, but if it is I'm wondering where I stand. I'm a bit precious about my cars and keeping them running well, especially now it's out of warranty and there's some seriously complex tech in this motor which would be astronomically high to fix. If they do enforce it and refuse to pay out unless offered an own brand fuel receipt, where do I stand? Perhaps an official manufacturer document stating the use of 98ron fuel? Play it sly and submit other receipts from family members filling up at the own brand pumps? Just stick 95ron in and have a crap running car?
I'm currently field based, working for a major food retailer which also has its own petrol stations. I claim my fuel costs at a set rate per mile, as I use my own private vehicle for my travel which is approx 12k per year business mileage. Up until now they have accepted any VAT fuel receipt with my claim, which I get back as cash in hand.
After a draconian, knee jerk review of expenses it now seems they may only accept mileage claims if their own brand petrol is purchased, which does make business sense on the one hand, as it increases revenue at the pumps if all the field team do this.
The issue is my car is the 180bhp VAG 1.4TSI engine which is 98ron recommended, and I have only ever used super unleaded in it. Admittedly it is 95ron minimum, but have heard many reports of rough running, reduced MPG and general potential for engine unhealthiness, probably exarcebated as it probably won't be the greatest of 95ron petrols being a supermarket offering.
There's every chance this won't be enforced strongly, but if it is I'm wondering where I stand. I'm a bit precious about my cars and keeping them running well, especially now it's out of warranty and there's some seriously complex tech in this motor which would be astronomically high to fix. If they do enforce it and refuse to pay out unless offered an own brand fuel receipt, where do I stand? Perhaps an official manufacturer document stating the use of 98ron fuel? Play it sly and submit other receipts from family members filling up at the own brand pumps? Just stick 95ron in and have a crap running car?
Personal experience - I put over 30k miles on a Fabia vRS, almost always on regular 95 RON supermarket fuel and it was absolutely fine. There are precious souls on briskoda though who claim to "feel" differences even between brands of super though.
The 95/98 markings on the fuel filler mean that to make the "book" power figures it should be running on 98. It might be a fraction slower on 95 as the ECU compensates. It has been the case for about as long as VAG turbo petrol engines have existed. No chance of any damage. No chance of getting a letter from Skoda saying it absolutely must be run on super at all times. It's quite capable of drinking oil and failing regardless of what type of fuel you use.
The 95/98 markings on the fuel filler mean that to make the "book" power figures it should be running on 98. It might be a fraction slower on 95 as the ECU compensates. It has been the case for about as long as VAG turbo petrol engines have existed. No chance of any damage. No chance of getting a letter from Skoda saying it absolutely must be run on super at all times. It's quite capable of drinking oil and failing regardless of what type of fuel you use.
Just run it on 95RON.
Seriously, unless you're towing trailers in 30deg +, it shouldn't make any difference on the road.
OEM's tune their engines to run on 95RON. 98+ just offers some extra margin before you have to slightly adjust the ignition as a result of detonation.
So you shouldn't ever see any rough running. You may lose a few HP at the top end in very high load/temp situations, but certainly not in daily driving.
Seriously, unless you're towing trailers in 30deg +, it shouldn't make any difference on the road.
OEM's tune their engines to run on 95RON. 98+ just offers some extra margin before you have to slightly adjust the ignition as a result of detonation.
So you shouldn't ever see any rough running. You may lose a few HP at the top end in very high load/temp situations, but certainly not in daily driving.
Roo said:
If you're claiming expenses at pence per mile you don't even need to give them receipts. Just a detailed log of business mileage.
Our policy states not to pay out without receipts for at least 50% of the miles claimed.SJG and Superpav - Fair point, I don't drive it hard on business use anyway and I'm more than aware there are far more serious potential issues with the engine than a bit of slightly reduced performance from "normal" petrol! Touch wood, so far it hasn't been a major oil drinker compared to many.
Roo said:
If you're claiming expenses at pence per mile you don't even need to give them receipts. Just a detailed log of business mileage.
If they want to reclaim VAT on the fuel element of the mileage (which they probably do), they need VAT receipts for which the total VAT meets or exceeds the amount reclaimed. This changed some years back.OP: pay yourself for some octane booster and consider it part of the cost of running a car of your choice?
dogzilla said:
Running on 95 ron is not going to cause any damage to your engine. The vast majority of the world does not run on 98 ron and VW sell these cars world wide.
Spot on.Where I am at the moment premium fuel just does not exist and neither does a choice of fuel, and come to think of it, nor even a knowledge of what's actually going into the tank, which might be different today from what it was yesterday, and frequently is. It's always basically "cheapest tendered" grade as long as it hits the minimum EU mandated standards of course.
It's just "petrol". Or "diesel", but the difference between these two is at least indicated.
Plenty of VWs around. And Mercs. And BMWs. And Porsches. And Ferraris. And no-one ever gives any consideration about fuel grade, nor ever complains about fuel causing any problems. Except in the switchover to low sulphur diesel some years ago when probably 30% of all diesel engines started leaking, but that's not what this thread is about.
I'm similarly OTT when it comes to which fuel and also which garage to use so this would really p*ss me off.
If you're forced into using own brand value stuff, then as above either every now and again fill the car with a higher grade elsewhere at your own cost or use the octane booster. If you're cheeky, you could always claim the booster on expenses
The manufacturer has recommended the grade of fuel for a reason, it'll run that little bit happier but I doubt anything catastrophic would happen otherwise. I myself have found that a previous car felt better with one garages fuel than the other (all in my head probably) but also that the super duper diesel gave me better economy than the regular stuff all at the same garage (another car).
Either way, good luck
If you're forced into using own brand value stuff, then as above either every now and again fill the car with a higher grade elsewhere at your own cost or use the octane booster. If you're cheeky, you could always claim the booster on expenses

The manufacturer has recommended the grade of fuel for a reason, it'll run that little bit happier but I doubt anything catastrophic would happen otherwise. I myself have found that a previous car felt better with one garages fuel than the other (all in my head probably) but also that the super duper diesel gave me better economy than the regular stuff all at the same garage (another car).
Either way, good luck

Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



