Am i being unreasonable?
Am i being unreasonable?
Author
Discussion

Harding91

Original Poster:

430 posts

200 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
So on Monday i was driven into the back of at a Junction.

Basically, the guy in front of me pulled out onto the main road, i then moved forward to the edge of the junction, there was a gap, but i didnt think it big enough, i drive an old slow car i try not jump out into gaps without being sure i can pull out safely, The guy behind me 'thought i was pulling out' and drove straight into the back of me, not at a big speed but enough to bend my bumper up in and do damage.

We both pulled over, he said sorry and i took his details. Turns out he works on the same industrial estate as me as a mechanic and is friendly with the bodyshop opposite him, i popped the car up there during my lunch and him and his mate at the bodyshop took a look at it, said he'd be happy to put it right, I'm happy to let him do this because i think if i go through insurance they will write the car off.

The car in question is a 1988 Volvo 340, 33K Miles from new 1 previous owner, almost in mint condition

(My readers car thread here) : http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

I just want the car back to how it was frown


He said he could get it sorted and booked in next Wednesday, i sourced a second hand bumper from ebay that he could buy if he wanted and they could spray and fit that, if it was easier than repairing my current one. He has now sent me a text asking if i can contribute towards the Bill... I told him i dont have the money, which is true and in my opinion if i went through insurance id be of no blame and wouldnt cost me anything, in my opinion it was his mistake, dont get me wrong, it happens and he seems like a genuinely nice bloke but it was just an error that caused a bump.

Now im confused what to do.. I can let him and his bodyshop mate have a go at it, but what if im not happy with the result? The bumpers going to have to be resprayed, rear bar straightened a bit and paint put on it and maybe the exhausted aligned a bit as it has dropped slightly, i obviously have no doubt he's capable of doing all of this, he has a nice workshop with some nice cars and seems to know his stuff.

I can go through insurance.. which i dont think they'll repair it, and i dont want it written off, i like the car a lot and want to keep it.


First time ive been in this situation, any advice or input welcome. Thanks.

The Turbonator

2,792 posts

182 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Even if the insurance did right it off, you could still buy it back and get it repaired with the money left over from whatever they valued it at.

Just for example, if they value it at £1000 and you buy it back for £300, you'd still get £700 in a cheque.

It's his fault so your no claims wouldn't be affected but you would have to declare it as a non-fault accident come renewal time, which can raise your premiums.

bearman68

4,942 posts

163 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Tricky. I would be tempted to say to the guy that you want a decent job etc etc, and you are not intending to pay for it - (but nicely of course). If he's decent he will sort it, and do it right. But it does depend on your view of him as an individual.
I had a similar situation, in that I reversed into the side door of a van one day. My fault, but didn't want to use the insurance, and nor did the 'victim'. I sorted it out, and he is now a customer. I have had much more off him than the job cost me.
Just a thought.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
If the repair is going to cost more than the write off value of your car, it doesn't seem unreasonable that the other drivers liability is limited to that for the repair which you prefer.

Harding91

Original Poster:

430 posts

200 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
The Turbonator said:
Even if the insurance did right it off, you could still buy it back and get it repaired with the money left over from whatever they valued it at.

Just for example, if they value it at £1000 and you buy it back for £300, you'd still get £700 in a cheque.

It's his fault so your no claims wouldn't be affected but you would have to declare it as a non-fault accident come renewal time, which can raise your premiums.
I have to prove the market value? And finding other Volvo 340's in that condition.. is well close to impossible. It's a one owner with every optional extra from factory, heated leather, the lot.

And if im honest, even if that was the case, i dont want it to be a cat c or whichever it becomes frown

Harding91

Original Poster:

430 posts

200 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for the feedback.

I said to him without being rude i dont feel like i should pay, and i only sourced the bumper as in my opinion it would be an easier option to do a proper repair, he is going to talk to the ebay member selling it, get it ordered and get my car sorted, so working out well hopefully.

He did seem a genuinely nice bloke and it was an easy mistake to make on a morning drive to work, but hoping it all gets sorted and the car is back to how it should be.

I just really didnt want the car written off.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
You have acted perfectly reasonably. Just a shame it's not more widespread.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Harding91 said:
I have to prove the market value?
And this, children, is exactly what agreed value insurance is for.

Harding91

Original Poster:

430 posts

200 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
And this, children, is exactly what agreed value insurance is for.
Fair point, but at 23 finding a company worth insuring with agreed value is hard, i did look and found classic policys with it that wanted limited mileage, i didnt want limited mileage due to me using it every day, maybe that was my mistake.

But regardless, no matter how much they would offer me, i dont want the car written off, feels like such a shame for a small bump

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Harding91 said:
But regardless, no matter how much they would offer me, i dont want the car written off, feels like such a shame for a small bump
"Written off" doesn't mean dead. It's purely and simply an administrative stamp.

Cat D - the damage wouldn't even have cost more than the value to fix, but it was written off anyway, possibly to restrict loan car costs or for parts delays.
Cat C - the damage was more than the car's value.

Both those can be put back on the road. Cat C gets a tag on the V5C, and you need a vehicle identity check in order to get a new V5C issued and tax reminders again.

It's only past that point where a death sentence gets issued.

Cat B - severe structural damage, can't be put back on the road, but can be broken for parts by an authorised dismantler.
Cat A - must be crushed whole. Usually fire damage, severe flood damage, or a fatality.

In your case, I suspect Cat D - not least because they won't be able to get a price for a new bumper from the local Ovlov dealer. The car's worth buttons - it's not even in the price guides. It's literally not worth their while attempting to figure it out. Go in there prepared, ideally with a nice professional quote or three and some comparatives to prove the price, and you may well be lucky. You're going to be in a much stronger position talking straight to his insurer, if he's admitted liability.

bluesmoke2stroke

96 posts

139 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Tell them you've been reasonable so far but if this is the way things are going to be you'll report it to the insurance company.
You are the injured party here and the 3rd party responsible for all this should be more responsible in sorting this than you!!
In reality it may be worth the money in buying the bumper upfront to get the issue dealt with promptly.
I take it whiplash hasn't come on since the bump?!
Good luck

Harding91

Original Poster:

430 posts

200 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
"Written off" doesn't mean dead. It's purely and simply an administrative stamp.

Cat D - the damage wouldn't even have cost more than the value to fix, but it was written off anyway, possibly to restrict loan car costs or for parts delays.
Cat C - the damage was more than the car's value.

Both those can be put back on the road. Cat C gets a tag on the V5C, and you need a vehicle identity check in order to get a new V5C issued and tax reminders again.

It's only past that point where a death sentence gets issued.

Cat B - severe structural damage, can't be put back on the road, but can be broken for parts by an authorised dismantler.
Cat A - must be crushed whole. Usually fire damage, severe flood damage, or a fatality.

In your case, I suspect Cat D - not least because they won't be able to get a price for a new bumper from the local Ovlov dealer. The car's worth buttons - it's not even in the price guides. It's literally not worth their while attempting to figure it out. Go in there prepared, ideally with a nice professional quote or three and some comparatives to prove the price, and you may well be lucky. You're going to be in a much stronger position talking straight to his insurer, if he's admitted liability.
I'm aware of what it means, and it may seem silly but i just really dont want the stamp on the cars history, it's such a nice example i feel it'd be a shame. Regardless of what happens the car needs to be repaired, im not out to make profit from this so getting a cheque off of insurance and only spending x amount to fix it doesnt appeal, all i want is the car as it was before the bump, no more no less. I feel providing he covers the costs and they do a good job repairing it im more than happy to let him do that, i get what i want and im assuming it benefits him in the long run insurance wise.

bluesmoke2stroke said:
Tell them you've been reasonable so far but if this is the way things are going to be you'll report it to the insurance company.
You are the injured party here and the 3rd party responsible for all this should be more responsible in sorting this than you!!
In reality it may be worth the money in buying the bumper upfront to get the issue dealt with promptly.
I take it whiplash hasn't come on since the bump?!
Good luck
No whiplash hasn't come on, it was a crawl speed bump and im not a .


But yeah, after speaking to him it looks like he'll be ordering the bumper from ebay and ill be dropping the car at the Bodyshop next Wednesday so fingers crossed it gets sorted properly and im happy with the repair.

Like i said originally, i feel like he's a genuinely nice guy and im happy to give him a chance to rectify it, if it goes tits up then im stupid and i made a mistake in trusting him, im hoping that is not the case.




I guess i'll make an updated thread when i get the car back after next week, hopefully all goes well. regardless thanks for the info/input from everyone.

4737Carlin

1,195 posts

266 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all

Hold on, I was under the impression that the other guy's insurance company cannot write off your car if you don't agree to it. Is that not the case?

I believe that if they won't offer a settlement that is agreeable to you, you can insist that they repair the vehicle to its pre-accident condition.
Feel free to correct me if you know better.


OP, somebody damaged my rear bumper while I was stationary in traffic, in 2008.
The accident was found to be 100% the other guy's fault, but as mentioned by somebody above, I still had to declare it on my insurance for the next five years. My annual premium went up considerably for the next five years. The first year following the minor accident my premium was getting on for 70% more expensive.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
4737Carlin said:
Hold on, I was under the impression that the other guy's insurance company cannot write off your car if you don't agree to it. Is that not the case?

I believe that if they won't offer a settlement that is agreeable to you, you can insist that they repair the vehicle to its pre-accident condition.
Feel free to correct me if you know better.
No, I don't believe that is correct.

The third party insurer cannot force you to give up your vehicle as a write off, but neither can you force the insurer to undertake an uneconomic repair because you love your vehicle so much.

What appears to happen is the insurer writes off and pays out but the owner buys is back from them and undertakes the repair at their cost.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
4737Carlin said:
Hold on, I was under the impression that the other guy's insurance company cannot write off your car if you don't agree to it. Is that not the case?
So if this...

...was somebody else's fault, you'd expect their insurance to completely rebuild it if you said that was what you wanted...?

TwistingMyMelon

6,519 posts

236 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
OP, you sound like a nice guy, too nice, I would hate to see you get walked over, if they are already texting you for money its not looking good

If someone made a piss poor mistake of driving in the back of me when I didn't move , I'd be a bit pissedoff.com , reasonable but not too happy, I wouldn't be fart arseing about with seconhand bits on evbay and back street mates rates resprays to help them out.

If he already doesn't have enough to cover the costs, they are hardly going to do a blinding job and as you treasure the car I bet you will have high standards for the repair, where as they might just see it as an "old Volvo"

If it was me, I'd go through insurance, that's what I pay it for, plus you have a designated pathway if things don't go well.

I can see it being repaired, you not being too happy, them going, stop being fussey fck off....

As said you can do a deal to buy it back of insurance




jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
I have recently claimed directly from a 3rd party's insurer. They accepted liability (3rd party bumped my car whilst it was stationary) and asked for an estimate to repair.

We emailed them the estimate. They asked for an account number and sort code and wired us the estimate value within 2 days.

I informed my own insurer that this was going on and they recorded it as non-fault/ full recovery.

sy1664

24 posts

187 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
My mother had a similar experience many years ago, we agreed the driver at faults partner could repair the car as he worked in a local garage. When I went to collect the car, it had a replacement bumper fitted which had been painted the correct colour. However when I checked the panel gaps for alignment it was too far over to one side causing the tailgate to hit the bumper as it opened. I pointed this out, to be met with a mouthful of abuse and be told "it was like that before, you're lucky we've done what we have" I tried to explain this was not the case and that further damage behind the bumper had obviously occurred. This abuse became threats, fortunately a couple of mates had dropped me to the garage so I wasn't alone - good job I hadn't let my mum collect the car herself. I thought a hasty retreat was best, so I got in the car and left.
We explained what had happened to my mother's insurance company (she was fully comp) and they sorted everything out, took it to their repairers who fitted a complete boot floor. They said they would be claiming for these repairs from the other driver's insurance.
I was dubious about letting this guy fix the car, but thought I would let him make amends.
OP you may have a different outcome, but make it very clear to the guy repairing your car that if it is not to your standard that his insurer with be receiving the bill to put it right.

SturdyHSV

10,443 posts

198 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Hope it works out well for you OP, you seem like a reasonable and nice guy thumbup

Just in case people aren't aware, the No Claims Discount is an agreed percentage off your premium. Even if you have a non-fault claim, all that happens is your premium will rocket up, and that same NCD is applied to the new, much higher, premium, so your renewal is much higher until the non-fault accident is old enough to be 'forgotten' about.

I only bring it up as in my opinion this fact isn't well represented to the public when they advertise protected no claims discount and such.

Harding91

Original Poster:

430 posts

200 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Thank you again for everyone who replied and gave me some insight.

So from what ive read/taken from you lots input, if if does somehow go sour between us, which i hope and dont think it will, i honestly believe he's a genuinely nice guy and itll all get sorted, but if it does, i can then turn around to his insurance, explain that he offered to have it repaired, it wasnt a good repair or whatever etc etc and i still have a foot to stand on? I was for some reason under the impression once i gave him a chance to get it done i could no longer go through insurance? Dont know why i thought this but if anyone could confirm whether or not this is right id appreciate it smile

One thing i did do was visit a friends bodyshop today after work, somebody i trust and he confirmed what the other chap/his bodyshop told me, that its repairable and should not be difficult to put it back to how it was so that is reassuring, i didnt want them telling me its a doable job and finding out after that it wasn't. They're a legit bodyshop with from what i can find a good reputation

And to others, thank you for the kind words, i really hope im not being taken the piss out of or walked over, but i really have a dislike for the blame culture we have, a few years ago i was in a car when a very similar situation happened to a friend (I was a passenger) A women who saw it instantly jumped out and approached my friend saying he should take her details, he needs a witness for what the other driver had done to him etc etc, It was a minor bump, my friend then went on to claim a lot from her insurance, hire car, injury/loss of earnings etc etc when in reality it was all bullst, i told him i thought it was a bit of an ahole move taking whatever you possible could from somebodys insurance just because they made a small error where nobody was harmed, to which his reply was "It's free money" ...


Again i'll say, all i want is my car back to how it was before the bump, im not out to make any profit or gain anything from the situation, if the chap is a nice decent person like i believe him to be, he'll get it done, and in reality it'll work out cheaper for him id assume? I see no need to take anything more than that. Maybe im a fool and in all reality at some point in my life this attitude will bite me in the ass, but id rather go through life making decisions i think are correct. smile

I will make an updated thread when i get the car back! It should be going in for repair Wednesday smile

Thanks again Chaps & Chappetes.