Will a twin engined car be notably faster?
Will a twin engined car be notably faster?
Author
Discussion

xjay1337

Original Poster:

15,966 posts

149 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
Bear with me.

Let's say for example you take a car with 200bhp and put in a second engine powering the rear wheels, linked throttle/gearshift and such. So you have 2 x 200Bhp, one engine powering each axle, would that be faster than a car with 400bhp all else being equal.

Example : Audi RS4 let's say for argument sake 400bhp.
Take a Golf GTI and put a second engine in it. Meaning you have 1 x 200bhp engine powering the front wheels and 1 x 200bhp engine powering the rear wheels. Each have seperate gearboxes and shared throttles.
I am not sure if it would in effect give the car 400bhp or if it would be the same performance as the stock just with in effect 4 wheel drive.

I'm sure the insightful, polite and knowledgeable people of PH can assist in this query.



Edited by xjay1337 on Thursday 7th May 11:55

Lefty

21,610 posts

233 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
I would imagine it would be heavier and have more transmission loss.

xjay1337

Original Poster:

15,966 posts

149 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
Lefty said:
I would imagine it would be heavier and have more transmission loss.
It would be heavier but an engine is around what, 100ks maximum for a smaller displacement unit?
Each engine would have it's own transmission so no greater transmission loss.

Just was having a chat about it with some mates over the last few weeks and was genuinely interested.

SirSquidalot

4,067 posts

196 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
It will be faster as it has 200bhp extra, but it will be heavier and probably handle atrociously.

See - http://www.dubpics.co.uk/2011/10/twin-vr6-mk3-golf...

Lefty

21,610 posts

233 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
Lefty said:
I would imagine it would be heavier and have more transmission loss.
It would be heavier but an engine is around what, 100ks maximum for a smaller displacement unit?
Each engine would have it's own transmission so no greater transmission loss.

Just was having a chat about it with some mates over the last few weeks and was genuinely interested.
Two gearboxes would surely give more transmission losses than one gearbox?

I'm a bit confused OP. Are you asking if a car with two 200bhp engines (400bhp) will be faster than a car with one 400bhp engine or faster than a car with one 200bhp engine?


Edited - I see you've edited the OP, got it now!

You're better off with the rs4 than a golf gti with two engines. wink

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
Greater losses due to extra gearbox etc.
Greater weight probably - double the ancillaries.
Difficulty of synchronizing the engines.

WestyCarl

4,107 posts

156 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
A number of kit cars have run two m/c engines (ZCARS did conversions I think). YES they were blisteringly fast in a straight line.

xjay1337

Original Poster:

15,966 posts

149 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
Lefty said:
Two gearboxes would surely give more transmission losses than one gearbox?

I'm a bit confused OP. Are you asking if a car with two 200bhp engines (400bhp) will be faster than a car with one 400bhp engine or faster than a car with one 200bhp engine?


Edited - I see you've edited the OP, got it now!

You're better off with the rs4 than a golf gti with two engines. wink
Yeah sorry I edited it to hopefully be a bit clearer smile

I'm in no disagreement but just think the topic was interesting.
Let's say a car with a transfer box and 4wd suffers 20% driveline losses, and a FWD car suffers 8%, each engine would have it's own gearbox with a shared control so in effect wouldn't suffer any further losses.


SirSquidalot said:
It will be faster as it has 200bhp extra, but it will be heavier and probably handle atrociously.

See - http://www.dubpics.co.uk/2011/10/twin-vr6-mk3-golf...
Yeah but that's the question, will be in effect have 200bhp extra, because each engine is ONLY making 200bhp. So each engine can only turn the wheels at the speed of 200bhp. Hence why it would have in effect a 200bhp 4WD or would be it be as fast as a regular car with 200bhp

lukefreeman

1,502 posts

206 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
Greater transmission losses, what?

a 4wd system can be upwards of 20%, so 400bhp = 320bhp.

a 2wd sytstem can be around 10-15%, so 200bhp - 170-180, but as you've got two engines, 340-360.......

J4CKO

47,106 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
Wouldn't having an engine over each set of driven wheels be a traction advantage vs normal 4wd or would the lack of synchronization of a single drivetrain count against it ?

Weight wise, I wonder how much would be in it between two gearboxes and two engines vs one bigger engine and a 4wd system, probably not that much.


Itsallicanafford

2,964 posts

190 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
The Toyota Prius (and my Auris) have 2 engines as part of the Hybrid Synergy drive...1 No. ice and 1 No. electric, sharing a common system of planetary gears.

SirSquidalot

4,067 posts

196 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
Yeah but that's the question, will be in effect have 200bhp extra, because each engine is ONLY making 200bhp. So each engine can only turn the wheels at the speed of 200bhp. Hence why it would have in effect a 200bhp 4WD or would be it be as fast as a regular car with 200bhp
It has an extra 200bhp of total output. So 200 more horses to propel the car and all its gubbins, its a 400bhp car and will go like one!

stu67

892 posts

219 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
Didn't Austin Morris test / build a couple of twin engined mini cooper's back in the day? I'm sure I saw an article in a classic car mag once. I don't think they were very much faster than the standard set up and think they always had trouble syncing the throttle responses, but if I can remember the artical they did say that it was a very balanced driving experience down to the weight distribution.

xjay1337

Original Poster:

15,966 posts

149 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
SirSquidalot said:
It has an extra 200bhp of total output. So 200 more horses to propel the car and all its gubbins, its a 400bhp car and will go like one!
OK, fair enough

But my question would be that if the front 2 wheels have 200bhp, and the rear 2 wheels have 200bhp, surely each set of wheels can only accelerate and the rate of 200bhp?

Do you see my thinking or am I talking dog nuts.

schmalex

13,616 posts

237 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
VW tried this many years ago in the Scirocco...

http://www.driversfound.com/scirocco/history/bimot...

ManFromDelmonte

2,744 posts

211 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
OK, fair enough

But my question would be that if the front 2 wheels have 200bhp, and the rear 2 wheels have 200bhp, surely each set of wheels can only accelerate and the rate of 200bhp?

Do you see my thinking or am I talking dog nuts.
Dog nuts.

Imagine pushing a car from the front door aperture with your own 1 man-power. Now get an equally sized friend to push the car from the rear (so now 2 man-power). Will this make it easier to accelerate the car or will the car only accelerate the same as when one person is pushing?

Super Slo Mo

5,374 posts

229 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
xjay1337 said:
SirSquidalot said:
It has an extra 200bhp of total output. So 200 more horses to propel the car and all its gubbins, its a 400bhp car and will go like one!
OK, fair enough

But my question would be that if the front 2 wheels have 200bhp, and the rear 2 wheels have 200bhp, surely each set of wheels can only accelerate and the rate of 200bhp?

Do you see my thinking or am I talking dog nuts.
To all intents and purposes each axle now only has half the weight to propel so you've doubled the power to weight ratio. Give or take a bit of extra transmission loss and extra weight it pretty much is that simple.

And synchronising both engines is a piece of cake wink.

angry jock

1,005 posts

230 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
schmalex said:
VW tried this many years ago in the Scirocco...

http://www.driversfound.com/scirocco/history/bimot...
Alfa Romeo tried this even longer ago with what was arguably the first Ferrari.

The 1935 Bimotore
linky

crofty1984

17,064 posts

235 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
It will accelerate faster but the top speed would be about the same.

xRIEx

8,180 posts

179 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
SirSquidalot said:
xjay1337 said:
Yeah but that's the question, will be in effect have 200bhp extra, because each engine is ONLY making 200bhp. So each engine can only turn the wheels at the speed of 200bhp. Hence why it would have in effect a 200bhp 4WD or would be it be as fast as a regular car with 200bhp
It has an extra 200bhp of total output. So 200 more horses to propel the car and all its gubbins, its a 400bhp car and will go like one!
Engine/gearbox A: 200bhp, geared for, say, 140mph (with a hard rev limiter).

Car A1 has one engine; its top speed is 140mph and accelerates fairly well.
Car A2 was two lots of engine A; its top speed is 140mph and accelerates very well.

Engine gearbox B: 400bhp and geared for 170mph.

Car B1 has one engine; its top speed is 170mph and accelerates very well.


Unless you alter the gearing (or final drive) of the twin gearboxes you'll have the same top speed, but it will get there a hell of a lot quicker.