2nd car advice
Author
Discussion

QuiteQuietCerb

Original Poster:

995 posts

247 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
Hi since selling my jag, I am looking for a 2nd car to the cerb. choices are Mercedes slk mk1, audi tt mk1 or e46 330 bmw. I know what some people think about the first two, but they have grown on me recently. anyone has experience of any of those please let me know. interested in ease of ownership mainly. driving experience comes second as I have the cerb for that

QBee

22,189 posts

168 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
General comment, as I don't know if you are looking for a daily driver, or work in London.
Of those three I would choose the BMW, and have it as an estate version.
It's just so handy having a car that can shift stuff. And carry passengers.
I have even kept a battered 15 year old Merc ML, resale value nil, as an extra car for it's flexibility - dirty dog carrying, load lugging and 3.5 tonne towing capabilities.
I am collecting a 68kg garage tent next week - the estate car would have no problem, but any saloon car would struggle.

https://www.machinemart.co.uk/shop/product/details...

ESDavey

713 posts

243 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
I currently own a Griffith, TT mk2 & A6 Avant. I would never be without an estate as stated above. How about a A4 Avant ?
TT is great but not very relaxing.

JezF

331 posts

252 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
The Beemer is likely to be the most rewarding to drive out of those three.

I've gone the practical route though, diesel Octavia hatch, cavernous boot and decent miles per gallon - helps fund the Cerbera!


phazed

22,457 posts

228 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
a ove, running a £999 vRS Octavia, superb all rounder!

JezF

331 posts

252 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
phazed said:
a ove, running a £999 vRS Octavia, superb all rounder!
mk1 I assume? Bit of a bargain nowadays,

Jhonno

6,430 posts

165 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
330i Touring... I'd love one. Smoke about in a 320d Touring instead though.

QuiteQuietCerb

Original Poster:

995 posts

247 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
thanks for the comments, guys, i own a ml430 7 seater that the wife drives (had to be a v8 after the e430 estate!) and have had an octavia 1.8t 4x4 in the past which was great. just want something to commute 2/3 times a week that is comfortable, looks good, wont break the bank, and goes ok as well. not bothered with practicality etc

Vee8ight

734 posts

163 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
£400 Volvo 240 of 1989 vintage is my choice

2 sMoKiN bArReLs

31,857 posts

259 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
TT gets a load of bad press...but I really loved mine



Comfortable, reasonable turn of pace, really nicely appointed, pretty, good in the snow etc

phazed

22,457 posts

228 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
JezF said:
phazed said:
a ove, running a £999 vRS Octavia, superb all rounder!
mk1 I assume? Bit of a bargain nowadays,
Yes a mark one, complete with Wolf race Prolite wheels, good tyres, Billies and lowered springs and Eibach ARBs.

QuiteQuietCerb

Original Poster:

995 posts

247 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all
yes the audi is nice, what are the main things to look out for? any experiences with the slk or 330?

NuddyRap

220 posts

127 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all
I commute in the latest type Celica and I can't recommend it highly enough.

Indestructible engine, stonkingly reliable everything else, looks good, fun to chuck about, squeezes in tight spaces, comfortable and enough power to be entertaining. Fuel economy is listed as 46mpg max, but I get 75-80mpg because of the fact I waited for one that had an LPG conversion fitted. Even with that benefit, 2 years ago it only cost me £1500 and I've done 90,000 miles in it, only having to change the brake pads and a (very cheap) clutch which had covered 180,000 miles, so I can forgive it that.

If you are interested, go for a 190bhp vvtli version and avoid pre-2003 140vvti versions.


lostkiwi

4,585 posts

148 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all
The problem with the SLK will be tin worm. If you can find one without they're nice cars and quicker than many think - especially the 320s. Hardtop is a benefit in winter too.
TT is terminally dull in my experience. Very capable but as exciting as a screwdriver to use.
I'd probably plumb for a Z4 in either 2.5 or 3.0 guise or hang on for that immaculate SLK320 thats out there somewhere.

Mr Cerbera

5,148 posts

254 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all

Incognegro

1,560 posts

157 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all
I'd say get a Range Rover Evoque (5dr with 4x4 in auto)...

madbadger

11,734 posts

268 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all
TVR, MX5 and 93 Aero Estate.

There is getting to be a recurring theme in here. smile

QBee

22,189 posts

168 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all
madbadger said:
TVR, MX5 and 93 Aero Estate.

There is getting to be a recurring theme in here. smile
TVR, ML, 9-5 Aero Estate.
You're right.

daveinhampshire

531 posts

150 months

Tuesday 27th October 2015
quotequote all
Two people with the 330 petrol have had nothing but problems and awful fuel consumption. Both have since flogged them at a loss. I'm sure other people have more direct experience smile

QuiteQuietCerb

Original Poster:

995 posts

247 months

Wednesday 28th October 2015
quotequote all
strange, I have had a few 328 e36 and e39 with no issues whatsoever, I was thinking the bmw would be the more reliable of the 3