People that buy a saloon over the hatchback variant
People that buy a saloon over the hatchback variant
Author
Discussion

ambuletz

Original Poster:

11,805 posts

212 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
...for example a saloon focus over the normal hatchback. What is the reasoning behind it?

For some reason I've always had this idea that the people who buy the saloon focus over a hatchback tend to be of an older generation, the types that preferred the ford orion over the escort (for example). This was further amplified by me passing someone washing their car the other day, they were quite easily 60+ and owned a mk2 focus saloon, you hardly see them. Now I can understand someone buying an A3 saloon, or jetta for a company car as it seems a little more prestiguous then a hatcback. But focus? I'm aware in other countries/cultures a saloon is seen as a more affluent thing, but in the UK? Is there anyone here that has bought a saloon focus over a hatchback? what was the reasoning?

Fleckers

2,880 posts

232 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Back in the day I had a ford Orion over a ford escort


marmitemania

1,571 posts

173 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
I have always preferred a saloon over a hatchback and I currently have a MK1 Focus saloon. As for a Jetta being a prestigious car rofl only in England.

Jonmx

2,944 posts

244 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
I much prefer the saloon shape of cars myself, I have an inexplicable loathing of hatchbacks that I've held since childhood. I will say that some saloons don't look right though, the 306 saloon for example.
The Ford Sierra is the one that sticks in my mind, the 5 door hatch looked gash wheras the saloon didn't (I'm ignoring the 3 door obviously).
I suspect I'll be very much in the minority though, and probably get laid into over the Sierras, it seems everyone loves hatchbacks!




lucido grigio

44,044 posts

194 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
My dad's first VW in 1981 was a Jetta,he bought 4 Golfs and a Polo since.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Jonmx said:
I much prefer the saloon shape of cars myself, I have an inexplicable loathing of hatchbacks that I've held since childhood. I will say that some saloons don't look right though, the 306 saloon for example.
The Ford Sierra is the one that sticks in my mind, the 5 door hatch looked gash wheras the saloon didn't (I'm ignoring the 3 door obviously).
I suspect I'll be very much in the minority though, and probably get laid into over the Sierras, it seems everyone loves hatchbacks!



Oh come on - pissy poverty spec hatchback pic versus 4 door Cosworth variant. Hardly comparing like with like.

The equivalent of that stty looking hatchback..



was this...


AmitG

3,572 posts

191 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
The saloon version of the current Mondeo looks a lot better than the hatchback version, IMHO. Probably enough to sway a few people.

Other reasons I've heard:

The boot is more secure with a saloon. If you have fixed rear seats, or rear seats that can only be folded down from the boot, then if someone breaks a window to get into your car they can't get to the boot. In a hatchback they can.

Some say that saloons are quieter because the boot area is enclosed, but I've always been a bit sceptical about that.

I think there are not many cars now that come as a choice between a saloon and a hatchback in the same market. The Mondeo is one. But it seems that these days, the saloon is made for US and Asian markets and the hatchback is made for Europe. Example: new Honda Civic.

Shifty Bloke

187 posts

193 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
I did wonder this when seeing the Mondeo saloon

Whatever, if the choice is there then fair play

Audemars

507 posts

129 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
In general hatchbacks are uglier cars (in fact most hatchbacks are ugly cars). If you don't need the practicality then you opt for the saloon equivalent. You don't buy a hatchback because you think it looks better.

Drive Blind

5,801 posts

208 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
3dr hatches are better than 5dr hatches and saloons are better than hatches so therefore the coolest car ever is the 2dr saloon silly


jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
i can give you one example which applies to my use of of my car. one of the things my car is
used for every week is to take my parents shopping. if i have a hatchback or an estate, it usually means that as i load the shopping into the rear, they are cold in the car. they are both over 80 and feel the cold. maybe only a small problem at certain times of the year

cjs racing.

2,508 posts

160 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Fleckers said:
Back in the day I had a ford Orion over a ford escort
Me too, had the Orion 1600i Ghia, instead of the XR3I.

tr7v8

7,628 posts

259 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
marmitemania said:
I have always preferred a saloon over a hatchback and I currently have a MK1 Focus saloon. As for a Jetta being a prestigious car rofl only in England.
VAG snobbery as always!
When it was Escort & Orion in 86 I had an Orion as a company car. Why? because it was chockabloc with workshop manuals for the IT systems I worked on. I paid extra (£30 a month) to get a 1.6GL over the L that I was eligible for.

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
cjs racing. said:
Me too, had the Orion 1600i Ghia, instead of the XR3I.
a few years ago a good friend of mine had one. i always thought it looked classier than the xr3.
he had to sell it as it kept being stolen.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
I bought my ST220 as a saloon as in my opinion it looks better than the hatch, plus the entire saloon production run was around 700 cars so it's a bit "different".


anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
I always wanted a MK2 Jetta 16v and Vento VR6 but could never find either that were nice enough. Personally, prefer the look of them to the Golf.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Drive Blind said:
3dr hatches are better than 5dr hatches and saloons are better than hatches so therefore the coolest car ever is the 2dr saloon silly

It looks like the woman in the background has just vomited at the sheer horror of itlaugh

JamesRR

284 posts

116 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Drive Blind said:
3dr hatches are better than 5dr hatches and saloons are better than hatches so therefore the coolest car ever is the 2dr saloon silly

Serious question, where is the distinction drawn between a 2 door saloon and a coupe?
On topic, I think some people just prefer the looks of a saloon. I personally do, and before I bought my C30 I looked at S40s as I liked the saloon shape, although ultimately went for the C30 as I liked it just as much and found the right car locally.
Also, this is my first post, so hello everyone!

Hub

7,179 posts

229 months

Friday 7th April 2017
quotequote all
Saloons just don't sell in the UK anymore - except for the BMW 3 series and Mercedes C class. Pretty much any other country though​ and they appear to outsell the hatchbacks.

I can't say I'm a fan - they are family cars that aren't practical due to the poor shape boot, and sometimes a lack of folding seats. There are some cool saloons, but in a lot of cars they look worse than the hatch. I don't see the point.

I'll give you the Sapphire Cosworth, and some others like the MG ZS for that touring car look. But mostly... no.