Golf R vs. Golf GTE
Author
Discussion

Gatsods

Original Poster:

395 posts

199 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
Afternoon all,

Does anyone have experience with both of these cars? I'm looking to take an R out in the morning but GTEs seem to be like hen's teeth currently.

I'm also curious as to the real world economy/electric only range of the GTE. The claimed 31 miles is, I'm sure, only possible when descending a mountain with a tailwind, but as for the true figure people have said anything from about 15 to 25 is possible...

Also, what real-world fuel economy are all of you Golf R owners getting out there? I have a GT86 currently which is doing a stellar job at around 37-38mpg on my A/B road 60mile round trip daily commute, and was wondering if this would be much worse with the Golf or about the same.

Other than that, costs of ownership, driving experience, good points bad points - interested to hear your thoughts!

Gatsods

lee_fr200

5,664 posts

221 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
While I can't speak for the R long term, my gti pp is averaging over the last year 28mpg on its long term! And I drive normal and don't batter it anywhere rly! On a run I can get 44mpg out of it driving at 55-60mph on cruise!

The gte is actually lovely as you can cruise doing good mpg on the motorway then when you come off into urban driving and use electric only your great mpg isn't affected! Do the town run then back on the motorway at a cruise! I love the gte!

I borrowed an R for a day and apart from launching from the lights it didn't do much for me and got me a lot less mpg than my gti (17mpg over the day around town and 24 general) so I didn't bother changing as I preferred my car

Gatsods

Original Poster:

395 posts

199 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
Wow - that's pretty appalling! I thought it would be able to achieve far better than that...

If 17-24mpg is the consensus then I think it'll be a no go - still very interested to see the achievements from a GTE owner also, but finding one might be difficult if the classifieds are anything to go by.

lee_fr200

5,664 posts

221 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
It was brand new though! But yeah they're not the best inthink on a run most ppl get 32-38mpg out the R it's abit better with the new 7spd box but not much better only a couple of mpg difference

Gatsods

Original Poster:

395 posts

199 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for the info guys. Time to get the man-maths calculator out... 15,000 miles pa unfortunately so one of the otherwise lovely PCPs even will be dreadful so I'm looking at a pre-owned example, which would be the 6spd DSG.

Was it a good steer with the manual? Somehow it seems like the sort of car where an auto with paddles would suit it better.

onemorelap

694 posts

262 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
I have a GTE and on the whole its a great car.

MPG really depends on your driving profile.

Real world range on electric only is about 20 miles, when its a cold day maybe 15 miles.

I typically do 60 miles a day and manage 35 - 40 miles on electric only by charging at work.
If i take it really steady i can see anywhere between 100 mpg to 150mpg as a combined average for the day using EV / HYbrid but its usually somewhere between 70mpg to 90mpg mixing EV with GTE mode.

On a long motorway run i usually see mid to late 40's in hybrid mode.

In GTE mode it's decent enough but you do notice the extra weight if you push it. This is the only area i have been slightly disappointed.

I think they are quite rare as they are deemed expensive compared to a 330E or 350E.




TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
GTE's also a lot less likely to be nicked...

darren f

988 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
I've been running a GTE as a company car for almost 6 months now and overall I'm pretty pleased- although much of that is related to the low CC tax and relative good value against the other (derv fuelled) options on our CC list.

Real world range on a full charge is 20-24 miles (the dash says 31 to start with... no chance!). I would suggest to get the best out of it your daily commute needs to be less than 50-60 miles total. Mine is about 40 miles total, a fair proportion of which is 40mph busy A-road crawl which really suits helps the range, by making sure I fully charge every night I can get 700 miles on a fill up, effectively 80+ mpg on petrol usage. Using just EL on short trips at weekends I can get the 'holy grail' of 100mpg! Obviously you need to factor in the EL cost (about £1.25 a charge on our full rate tariff) but you are still running it at 8 or 9p/mile for fuel which is pretty good.

A bit of a strange dilemma with the GTE vs R choice though. To get the best out of the GTE you do need to be a bit 'driving Miss Daisy' e.g. using 'lift and coast' to make use of no engine braking and the energy regeneration capabilities. If a maximum-attack driving style (the stuff the R excels at) is your thing you are going to be negating much of the point of the GTE. It can do that stuff but to get the performance of the thing you need both petrol and the hybrid boost of the EL motor and the range will disappear PDQ. Plus you are hauling the extra weight of the batteries, which does blunt both performance and handling.

Edit- in summary exactly as onemorelap has already said- I must learn to type quicker!

Edited by darren f on Friday 2nd June 20:09

Bungleaio

6,596 posts

233 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
I had a GTE for a courtesy car once and covered about 100 miles in it. I found it was very nose heavy compared to my GTI PP and it wasn't all that more efficient either.

My GTI is coming up on 30k now and has loosened up a lot from new, I'm averaging 34mpg over the past 2000 miles. I've been taking it really easy on the current tank and I'm getting 39mpg so it can be reasonable when you try.

I've got the DSG box and it's not as efficient as the manual, it robs 2-3 mpg but it's a price worth paying I think.

mjlloyd500

246 posts

117 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
i always thought gte was a vauxhall atra how times change.

cuprabob

19,972 posts

245 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
mjlloyd500 said:
i always thought gte was a vauxhall atra how times change.
Not only the Astra, but also the Opel Ascona GTE and the Opel Manta GTE. It's an age thingsmile

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 2nd June 2017
quotequote all
mjlloyd500 said:
i always thought gte was a vauxhall atra how times change.
Yoof of today...

http://www.rmsothebys.com/pa17/paris/lots/1963-fer...

Gatsods

Original Poster:

395 posts

199 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
Some really great replies in here, thanks a lot. I too could charge the GTE at home and at the office so could potentially drive one way on petrol one way on electric or the equivalent thereof.. this being a private purchase though a GTE seems to go against the trend.

To the poster above saying that an R vs a GTE is an odd contest - I basically either want the economy benefit of the GTE if it's there for the taking, and if it isn't then I'd look to the R because of the sheer pace of the thing.

Any other R owners out there with some numbers to hand?

Thanks!

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
My two pence worth. I've driven both a fair few times - and the GTI. I prefer the GTE of the three. The suspension set-up is pretty different I think, or maybe it's just the extra weight but it's a very mellow, flowing drive. If you drive moderately fast and with an eye on conserving momentum, you might get 45/50 MPG out of it, if it's fully charged when you leave and don't go too far. It has an odd, unique and very grown-up character. You can hold the charge in the battery if you want by pressing a button on the centre console. I've never got more than 20 miles out of the battery of any of the ones I've driven. Despite the irrationality of it in the real world, it's car I always like driving.

f1nn

2,694 posts

223 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
I can't add anything constructive, as I've not driven the GTE, but I assume the main driver behind considering one is company car tax, which I assume, without looking into it, must be advantageous?

I'm currently running a 2014 GTD as a daily, remapped to 215-220bhp...ish, and it's averaging just under 49mpg overall. £20 per year RFL.

I can understand you not wanting a diesel...it's taking me a little getting used to I must admit, but in the real world it must take some beating I would think.


Mr Tom

691 posts

172 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
I have neither of these cars but I do have a SEAT Leon cupra 290. It has the 2.0 tsi engine with (you've guessed it) 290bhp (ps). Goes well etc, not as nice as the golf inside but averages 36 day to day with up to 48mpg on a 60mph duel carriageway. Doesn't seem to make a huge difference on what fuel either.

darren f

988 posts

244 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
No offence intended with querying the GTE v R comparison wink , it's just that they each have a different 'ethos'- the to get the most of the GTE you need a bit of an 'economy driver' mindset (as I said 'lift and coast', utilising the battery range to it's optimum), whereas the R (I would have thought) would be a 'hang the expense, I'm going to enjoy myself' type of drive. To be honest the GTE only really works as a concept if you get a full charge at least once a day, are doing sub-50 miles/day and none of this is >60mph driving. If your journey profile is beyond this the GTD would be a better choice. Whereas if driving fun is your main requirement then definitely go for the R, the other 2 will simply not give you the same level of enjoyment.

Interesting that you will be able to charge at both home and work- if your journey is <20 miles each way you will never need to put petrol in it. Plus if the charging at work is free and you can get onto a cheap overnight tariff at home you'll be running the car at sub-2p per mile fuel cost. Which, if economy is the ultimate consideration would be a 'no-brainer'.

And yes hybrids do have massive advantages as company cars- I am paying half the amount of CC tax that I would for an equivalent spec 2.0 TDi. Although it is interesting that at work we now have 3 hybrids on our CC fleet and all have been selected by guys that also run track-day cars as their hobby- make of that what you will!




JD

3,153 posts

259 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
If it's new 7 speed golf R, then its the same powertrain as the S3 I have and use for lots of work miles.

On a motorway run 45 mpg is achievable, and since the last time I reset the trip 5500 miles ago the average has been 35mpg

I think over the last 12k it has managed about 34mpg.




Jasper3.0

652 posts

231 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
I am running a GTE as a company car. It was selected purely on the BIK benefit, but has turned out to be a very good car. It is a little over a year old and had done over 27k in that time with precisely zero issues. As others have said if you live close to work and can charge at work for free then it is very low cost to run on fuel spend. On a long run it is worse than the diesel and I susupect the R and GTI. On average I get 44mpg on long runs. A spirited drive this week fro Edinburgh to home over the moors resulted in 34mpg.

spookly

4,397 posts

126 months

Saturday 3rd June 2017
quotequote all
If you are asking about fuel economy of a Golf R then you probably don't want one.
I say that because to get good mpg from it requires you to drive like a taxi driver. If you drive a Golf R hard then you're looking nearer 10mpg than 40mpg. The best I've seen people getting is mid 30's mpg, and if you're driving it gently enough to get that then just get the GTE or a GTD and save some money.
I really never understand the logic of buying a faster car to drive around at snails pace worrying about mpg.

I have an R Estate. I've only looked at the mpg once. It wasn't good. About 23 mpg. I drive mostly short journeys around a not very congested town, with 120 mile motorway roundtrips once or twice a week. I don't drive it slowly. Even when I tried the motorway at 70 in Eco mode on cruise control I'm not anywhere near the VW mpg figures, about 32mpg. But, it is a lot better than the two V8 cars that preceded it (12mpg and 15mpg).