RE: BMW M5 (E28) | High Mile Club
RE: BMW M5 (E28) | High Mile Club
Sunday 10th January 2021

BMW M5 (E28) | High Mile Club

100,000 miles too measly? Good - let's talk about doubling it...



Later this month BMW will reveal its new M5 CS to the world, and a mighty thing it promises to be as well. The current F90 is the best M5 in years, and the CS upgrades have created some fantastic M cars thus far: M2, M3 and M4 have all been great. If rather expensive.  

No doubt the big BM will elevate expectations of fast saloons again - it has already lapped the Lausitzring as fast as a GT3 - and everyone who does a big skid in it will love the CS. Perhaps the opposition might try to compete with the more focused M5, though it seems unlikely. The next big step change for the supersaloons will probably be when they adopt downsized, hybridised powertrains. Gulp. 


Still, any excuse to talk about the original M5. As we’re all patently aware by now, there really hasn’t been a gamechanger for fast four doors quite like that E28. The performance it offered simply hadn’t been seen in family saloon cars before 1986; while gains were inevitably made over the years, the redefinition of expectations that everyone experienced when the M5 came along hasn’t happened since.

Consequently, they’ve become collectible. Again, that’s not really news, the clamouring for early M5s probably first starting with the old F10 generation. For some it was too digital, too aloof and too ordinary to feel like a great M5 - the original was cheap back then and blessed with a sensational engine. Values went up. And up. And then up some more… 

Which leads us to this point. Though you’d never guess it, this M5 is showing 191,000 miles on its odometer, making it one of the highest mileage cars on PH full stop. As might be expected, the miles were accrued before values climbed up - it was showing 189,000 miles when it went into storage a decade ago, and 185,000 back in 2006. Good on those owners, too - this was probably a joy in which to cover tens of thousands of miles in, particularly with that M88 straight six up front.


Even back then, though, the E28 will have been a rare car. It’s hard to believe now when there seems to be an M5 on every other street, but just 187 right-hand drive M5s made it to the UK. Given that was more than 30 years ago now, you can be certain that quite a lot fewer than 187 now survive - remember these were sub-£10k cars not all that long ago. As a 1988 car, this Alpine White M5 with the M Technic styling kit - BMW selling M car buyers iffy extras isn’t new - is number 172, right towards the end of the production run. And isn’t it stunning? Every single bit, from seats to seals and arches to exhaust, looks far fresher than it has any right to at almost 200k, a testament surely to the attention that’s been lavished on it.  

For the privilege of owning an original M5 like this, a buyer will be asked to part with £54,995. Not the most expensive E28 out there - see here for that, and sit down first - if still a lot of cash for a 33-year-old 5 Series. The advert implies further appreciation might be possible given what happened with E30 M3 values; that seems a long shot given this particular car’s mileage and the lack of motorsport kudos that so obviously helped the smaller car. What’s far easier to guarantee, though, is that this M5 will be a joy to drive through 200,000, brimming with all the performance and swagger that made it so desirable in the first place. It won’t be as fast as a CS - it won’t be as fast as a lot of things nowadays - but you might just like it more. Whether that joy is worth more than £50,000 is up to you. 


See the original advert here






Author
Discussion

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

44,558 posts

209 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
That seems a little bit toppy for me for the mileage. A legendary car though for sure. cool

Billy_Whizzzz

2,621 posts

172 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Nicer without the optional (unlike the M535i) body kit

2 GKC

2,307 posts

134 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Crap colour, dodgy body kit, galactic mileage and a cringe worthy advert. £55k is daft.

TR4man

5,527 posts

203 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Despite the price, it does look a lovely example though. Problem is you’ve got to really want one to spend that much and there are so many other cars I’d want before this for my £50k.

howardhughes

1,407 posts

233 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
I've always loved the E28 M5 and equally the M535 too, but I'd take the M5 without the body kit. A bit to Zender for me.
As for the asking price. Not a chance. I'm out.

Edited by howardhughes on Sunday 10th January 08:33

Twinair

1,028 posts

171 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
On the price, I don’t know really. Try & buy anything at the premium & rare end of the range from this time period. I expect - to the right person the price is not out there. The panels do look straight, hard to tell from pictures of course - so if it is straight - and not been crashed, then the parts & body shell etc have quite a value. Here you do get your ‘whole own’ working car?

Leins

10,438 posts

177 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Still my favourite M5, although there were faster 5-series before it, such as the E12 B7 Turbo S. Yes it’s a high price, but I know a lot of these are in long-term ownership now

That engine, and the subsequent S38, is a thing of wonder to me. Later V8 and V10s might grab the headlines, but this is still a very special motor

Interesting fact (from Richter at the time) - this car only came into existence because there was spare capacity on the production line. They were hoping to fit the M88 in an E30 instead, but weren’t happy with the results

JD2329

511 posts

197 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
I love M5s but 50k for a near on 200k mile car seems absurd.
A V8 powered R8 and servicable E39 M5 would fit the bill though...

LeeHK

2 posts

80 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
nice looking example, but the price certainly looks high. Not sure about the comment regarding original game changer - What about Lotus Cortina or Sierra Cosworth ?

Camelot1971

2,851 posts

195 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
It's less than 6k miles a year. If you want one to use rather than just put into storage, I'd rather have a well used one rather than a garage queen that has 1/4 of the miles but has all sorts of dried out seals etc.

g3org3y

22,462 posts

220 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Camelot1971 said:
It's less than 6k miles a year. If you want one to use rather than just put into storage, I'd rather have a well used one rather than a garage queen that has 1/4 of the miles but has all sorts of dried out seals etc.
Sure, but not at 55k.

waynecyclist

14,671 posts

143 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Not keen on bodykit or colour.

Bonkers money for mileage

Leins

10,438 posts

177 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
LeeHK said:
Not sure about the comment regarding original game changer - What about Lotus Cortina or Sierra Cosworth ?
I think it’s possibly badly worded in the article, but while there were decades of fast saloons previous to the E28 M5, I’m not sure any has properly defined the “super saloon” genre better than this car, before or since

For me the use of this engine is what made the car so different. The numbers were large for the time, although there had been larger in the past, but that just doesn’t tell the full story for me as it was more about character. Also, I’ve not driven the latest M5s, so I don’t know if they still do that thing where the car almost doesn’t seem to understand that it’s a 4-door exec and seems to shrink around you, and becomes all about the driving

Greg the Fish

1,410 posts

95 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
I'm not known for my liking of BMWs.

But always liked that version of the 5. Still do (maybe not in white though). That was when they were good cars.

A friend of my folks was always into his BMs and I have a number of memories of various E28s of his including a M535i, not sue he ever made it to the full M5 though.

Turbobanana

8,370 posts

230 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Leins said:
LeeHK said:
Not sure about the comment regarding original game changer - What about Lotus Cortina or Sierra Cosworth ?
I think it’s possibly badly worded in the article, but while there were decades of fast saloons previous to the E28 M5, I’m not sure any has properly defined the “super saloon” genre better than this car, before or since
Are we counting the Mercedes 350 SEL 6.3 or 450 SEL 6.9?

Leins

10,438 posts

177 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Turbobanana said:
Leins said:
LeeHK said:
Not sure about the comment regarding original game changer - What about Lotus Cortina or Sierra Cosworth ?
I think it’s possibly badly worded in the article, but while there were decades of fast saloons previous to the E28 M5, I’m not sure any has properly defined the “super saloon” genre better than this car, before or since
Are we counting the Mercedes 350 SEL 6.3 or 450 SEL 6.9?
I wouldn’t personally, or things like Bentley Turbo Rs, S8s, Alpina B12s, etc. I think they’re all too big to be considered proper super saloons. There may not be a hard rule on this anywhere, but for me a super saloon is 5-series/E-class sized, whatever the dimensions they are at that particular time

I’m sure others will disagree with this, so as I say it’s just my personal opinion

benzinbob

750 posts

85 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Should I stay away from older cars if I don’t own a garage? My car park is surrounded by trees also

mike-v2tmf

889 posts

108 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
My experience of high mileage performance cars is when driven as intended the engine soon protests

CeramicMX5ND2

9,348 posts

102 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
You'd have to really love it to pay that - Not for me..

Pughmacher

440 posts

72 months

Sunday 10th January 2021
quotequote all
Mileage (lack of) being overly fetishised again. At this age you buy on condition and history of remedial work or preventative maintenance. I’d love an e28 but not that one. As suggested the body kit and colour are too 80s! Properly period correct mind you.

Prices asked are seemingly nuts for most things of interest! I hold a degree of frustration and ire for cars that are picked up stored and used as investments. This one could be used!