RE: Audi RS3 vs Mercedes-AMG A45 S | PH Video
RE: Audi RS3 vs Mercedes-AMG A45 S | PH Video
Thursday 23rd December 2021

Audi RS3 vs Mercedes-AMG A45 S | PH Video

There isn't much to separate the current crop of super-hatches. Maybe seeing and hearing will help...


 

Sometimes it's hard to pick a winner. Not because you're sitting on the fence, but because two things can be equally as good in different ways. Is a Swedish massage better than a sports massage? That just depends on whether you're looking for relaxing or restorative, but both are great. Skiing versus the sea? Bond verses Bourne? Yes please, to all. And so it is with the Audi RS3 and the Mercedes-AMG A45 S. When it comes to super-hatches, these two prove there are two ways to skin the kitty. Each one has the same objective qualities: power, speed, handling, all-wheel drive, and, of course, the prerequisite lift-up tailgate to shove the shopping through. And for both, you'll need to fork out in excess of £50,000.

The RS3 is the less ostentatious. Rather like the well-dressed muscle of SO14, the Royal Protection Squad, it doesn't shout (too much) but you can tell from the bulges in its suit it's been working out. And then there's the muscle in its nose. That five-cylinder turbo might sound delectable and debonair but it's a deadly force: 400hp and 369 lb ft of shove deals out 0-62mph in 3.8 seconds, and, depending on the options you add, it won't stop accelerating until you reach 180mph. Yet it can also be calm, quiet and soft, with the every-day amiability of a top-flight butler. Boring? No, because it has learned new tricks that make it the most entertaining RS3 yet.


As entertaining as the A45 S, then? Well, that's the burning question. While the A45 S isn't as shouty as something like the old Honda Civic Type R, with more aero addendum than its rival it's not as discrete. It's like the tattooed ex-squaddie who's seen too much action and now works the nightclub doors. Pull up alongside the A45 S at a set of lights and the message is clear: don't mess with me, or else. It's such a different proposition to drive, too. There's nothing smooth or sophisticated about it. The ride is tauter and the road surface is amplified far more through the steering wheel and cabin, like it's part-touring car. The engine, too, is snarling and it's animated by the rat-a-tat-tat of gunfire every time you lift off or between each shift. And those shifts can be punchy, bordering on brutal. So different but still brilliant - and objectively very similar: 421hp, 369 lb ft of torque, 3.9 seconds to 62mph and just shy of 170mph.

The only way to split them is with the heart, not the head. That's why you need to watch this video, which gives you the sights and sounds to go with the facts. Only then can you be expected to make up your mind.


Author
Discussion

drpep

Original Poster:

1,761 posts

199 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
At prices approaching £70k you have to consider what else is available for the same money. Great though both of these are, you'd have to really love a super hot-hatch to justify it - PCP or not.

A quick look at Audi's site shows it starting around £56k so a bit more palatable but still.

Prices aside, looks and sounds like a pretty special bit of kit, though both are maybe a bit try-hard with the styling.

redroadster

1,886 posts

263 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
With extra spec comes a collasal price, as hatches are so practical I suppose you could argue it covers most bases but I would not be able to justify the expense ad I could get my kicks from say a type r Honda and park it up if it snows for a day or 2.

GreatScott2016

2,600 posts

119 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
Clearly both very capable rides. Never been a fan of the A45 but to be honest, I think that’s a brand issue for me rather than this particular model. Great to hear that Audi has “fixed” the negative facets that plagued previous generation models. Prices appear steep, especially after options, but if you throw in performance and practicality, dare I say both are a “bargain”? For me though, I’m waiting for the incoming M2 although BMW have a tough job on their hands to tempt me away from my current M2 biggrin

cerb4.5lee

45,352 posts

211 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
I prefer the engine in the Audi, but if I was in the market for either of these I'd go in the direction of the Mercedes I reckon.

Twinair

1,051 posts

173 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
I had the run out model of the last A45, for where I live (laden with B roads) it was very special and I super enjoyed all the 20K miles I did in it, never came across anything it couldn’t live with - especially in the wet. Would like to try the new A45s - bit worried it might be too grown up? The Audi - would love to have a go, a friend has a previous model, been chipped & akrapovich exhausted, it’s also a riot! Currently I have an M2C manual & a Cayman T PDK - both different & different to these 4WD racers. I must admit - as good as the bimmer & the 718 are, I do hanker after 4WD again - I guess in the 4WD context the new RS3 & 45s must be considered vs the GRY? I haven’t driven the GRY yet - worried I might like it and end up with 3 on the drive… 1st world problems…

LeroyLoser

695 posts

69 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
So the ingredients and characteristics are looking good for the RS3 & with it tipping the scales at 1500kg (according to motor1) its not too lardy for track work, especially as it has CC brakes as an option.

Are we likely to see 550hp fairly attainable and reliable from the 2.5?

Not looked at the TT RS tuning but i’m guessing this is the same lump…

Could be fun with cup2s (depending on how wide you can go) on it as you’re in GT3 territory but with 4wd punch out of corners, guessing a fair amount of 4wd lag mind, so at wheel hp figures might take a tumble.


Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
Great video PH & Dan.

What road was this filmed on? Anyone?

Hairymonster

1,678 posts

136 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
One of these? Or this? https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/new... new for £53k

BMW 540i xDrive M Sport Touring 3.0 5dr

Twinair

1,051 posts

173 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
Great video PH & Dan.

What road was this filmed on? Anyone?
Apart from Wales, mid-ish?

I got nothing…

Shiv_P

3,059 posts

136 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
Hairymonster said:
One of these? Or this? https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/new... new for £53k

BMW 540i xDrive M Sport Touring 3.0 5dr
The 540i is really unremarkable and TBH I'd just have a 530d. It's definitely not a M340i alternative

silvermog

83 posts

170 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
Twinair said:
Kawasicki said:
Great video PH & Dan.

What road was this filmed on? Anyone?
Apart from Wales, mid-ish?

I got nothing…
Rhigos, top end of the Rhondda valley, heading up to Penderyn and the southern edge of the Brecon Beacons … good road, but one to avoid if you've dropped any suspension travel as it has some transverse ridges which are brutal due to subsidence. Otherwise makes a great workout for something with sublime suspension/body control … wink

Motorsport3

569 posts

223 months

Thursday 23rd December 2021
quotequote all
I got a 2015 A250 4matic back in 2016 and still happy with it.
Prices and specs seem to have gone opposite directions though. Previous gen A class used to come better speccd with glass roof easy to find. You really need to pay very nearly double what I paid to get a similar car with a glass and for this reason I am not looking to upgrade any time soon.

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Friday 24th December 2021
quotequote all
silvermog said:
Rhigos, top end of the Rhondda valley, heading up to Penderyn and the southern edge of the Brecon Beacons … good road, but one to avoid if you've dropped any suspension travel as it has some transverse ridges which are brutal due to subsidence. Otherwise makes a great workout for something with sublime suspension/body control … wink
Thanks… really appreciate it.

Bright Halo

4,000 posts

266 months

Friday 24th December 2021
quotequote all
Kawasicki said:
silvermog said:
Rhigos, top end of the Rhondda valley, heading up to Penderyn and the southern edge of the Brecon Beacons … good road, but one to avoid if you've dropped any suspension travel as it has some transverse ridges which are brutal due to subsidence. Otherwise makes a great workout for something with sublime suspension/body control … wink
Thanks… really appreciate it.
Going up and over the Rhigos mountain can be a very scary prospect. Both of these cars are ideal to tackle it on a cold, wet winters day.
I did it a few times in my old E39 M5 and it was eye opening to say the least especially when you go into a tightening bend with a bit too much speed and you look down into the valley and wonder if the the foliage and fluffy sheep will cushion your impact!

as7920

782 posts

232 months

Friday 24th December 2021
quotequote all
Twinair said:
I had the run out model of the last A45, for where I live (laden with B roads) it was very special and I super enjoyed all the 20K miles I did in it, never came across anything it couldn’t live with - especially in the wet. Would like to try the new A45s - bit worried it might be too grown up? The Audi - would love to have a go, a friend has a previous model, been chipped & akrapovich exhausted, it’s also a riot! Currently I have an M2C manual & a Cayman T PDK - both different & different to these 4WD racers. I must admit - as good as the bimmer & the 718 are, I do hanker after 4WD again - I guess in the 4WD context the new RS3 & 45s must be considered vs the GRY? I haven’t driven the GRY yet - worried I might like it and end up with 3 on the drive… 1st world problems…
Last decent car was an M3 F80 DCT and before that an M2 LCI DCT.

Love fast hatches (had an M135i auto before the M cars) and been looking at either A45S, RS3 or a Porsche 718 T/GTS PDK.

Would appreciate your thoughts on the comparison on what you have/have driven. No interest in manual for me.

Niffty951

2,401 posts

259 months

Friday 24th December 2021
quotequote all
These two have almost created their own market sector.

It's hard to think of another car you'd chose in stead of either of these. At £60-70k you're not comparing these to a Mini, Megan, Seat or Civic that compete in the hot hatch sector for a larger pool of buyers.

I also don't think you'd buy one over an RS4, M3 or C63, it's not really competing in that sector.

Im glad they exist. They definitely have appeal. However, I don't think they are what they were when they were first conceived as the top rung model of the hatch back.

The competition has pushed them out on a ledge. A bit like the Subaru Impreza VS Evo of old

BogleDog64

112 posts

88 months

Friday 24th December 2021
quotequote all
I have to hand credit to Mercedes for continuing to squeeze so much power out of road going four cylinder engines. It’s a shame though that it’s so close to the demise of fossil fuelled combustion. For me though, that’s pretty much all I can muster. To my eyes, the styling looks frumpy and the body looks under tyred. The engine sound seems to have improved although the much reviled Porsche flat four turbo sound would be preferable to my ears.
Okay, the RS3 isn’t exactly pumped on steroids either and I hoped Audi would have been brave enough to give it some UR Quattro alike flared arches, but it looks more purposeful than the Mercedes shopping car approach. I’m not a fan of the overtly bewinged Tyre R Honda but something in between for these Germans would probably be about right.
The hatches I’ve owned have largely been practical with the ability to entertain when asked. The more highly strung Mercedes doesn’t seem like an all rounder whereas the Audi does. Can be comfortable, relaxed and refined.
But the absolute winner by a clear margin is the Audi for its five pot engine. What a sound! When ICEs are no longer available, we won’t be short of power, speed and acceleration. But we will lament the passing of the throb, warble and pulse of a fossil fuelled engine with any count other than four cylinders.

GT3ZZZ

1,007 posts

201 months

Friday 24th December 2021
quotequote all
I have also driven them both and A45 every time for me, if you want a keen driver's car its head and shoulders above the Audi.

As the review says, its far sharper and much more dialled in than the comfort oriented RS. It weighs a bit more as AMG gave it a bespoke bodyshell and did a fair bit of work to stiffen up the chassis with extra bracing, whereas Audi just produced the RS3 with the same metal as the most basic A3 diesel.

The 5 pot is a peach of course but disappointing that they left it the same as last time, a lazy effort at best when AMG have pushed the envelope with the 4 pot. The AMG power plant has a lot more to give as we'll see in the C63, the 5 pot is retiring any day now.

Litchfield dyno'd my A45 stock (yes, I have one) at 438PS

Edited by GT3ZZZ on Friday 24th December 22:16

Kawasicki

14,428 posts

266 months

Saturday 25th December 2021
quotequote all
GT3ZZZ said:
I have also driven them both and A45 every time for me, if you want a keen driver's car its head and shoulders above the Audi.

As the review says, its far sharper and much more dialled in than the comfort oriented RS. It weighs a bit more as AMG gave it a bespoke bodyshell and did a fair bit of work to stiffen up the chassis with extra bracing, whereas Audi just produced the RS3 with the same metal as the most basic A3 diesel.

The 5 pot is a peach of course but disappointing that they left it the same as last time, a lazy effort at best when AMG have pushed the envelope with the 4 pot. The AMG power plant has a lot more to give as we'll see in the C63, the 5 pot is retiring any day now.

Litchfield dyno'd my A45 stock (yes, I have one) at 438PS

Edited by GT3ZZZ on Friday 24th December 22:16
The body shell on the RS3 looks/is different to the standard A3.

CDP

8,062 posts

285 months

Saturday 25th December 2021
quotequote all
Or a new Cayman and good used Octavia?

Far too fast to really push on the roads. I'd pick the Audi for the five cylinder soundtrack.

Personally unless it's a proper sports car or real offroader I wouldn't consider a new ICE, it's yesterday's technology.