Strange MOT Test, is this allowed?
Strange MOT Test, is this allowed?
Author
Discussion

lewisp8

Original Poster:

10 posts

78 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
Took my battered old Suzuki Swift shopping car in for it's MOT today, only use it as a bit of a runabout to the supermarket in town so it's not the most looked after thing in the world. Anyway, dropped it off and the tester gave me a call to tell me to pick the car up about an hour later. Got the car and it passed with no advisories (Miracle if you ask me), tester told me that one of the side lights and the rear number plate light is out but gave it a pass anyway and told me to get them changed ASAP. As much as I appreciate the guy helping me out should he have done that? Has anybody else had similar experiences?

Export56

576 posts

119 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
Yes I had a x1/9 pass the MOT but the tester told me one headlamp was misaligned and to fix it. He couldn't be bothered to retest. Its worse nowadays with it all being real time online.

Nickp82

3,999 posts

124 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
Yes I have had similar so I went and got the bits sorted ….. The End smile

colin79666

2,228 posts

144 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
Reg plate light a minor as long as it has two and the other one is working. So shouldn't have got through advisory free. Perhaps it failed right after the test as he was parking up... Not sure about the sidelight, suspect it should have been a fail if considered a position lamp.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
It isn’t legit but testers occasionally do pass vehicles with minor but fail able issues presumably on the expectation that the owner will rectify them.

One tester allowed me to adjuster the rear brake adjuster on my Landy, another adjusted the headlight correctly on my CBR. I also had a headlight bulb changed during a test on a MINI. MoTs are very strictly monitored these days time wise so testers generally don’t have the time to tinker about with customers cars during an actual test.

Geffg

1,348 posts

136 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
He’s done you a favour can’t see the issue. Minor faults.

M.F.D

956 posts

132 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
One of those things better not mentioned. He done you a favour and it isn't as if he passed it with bald tyres or something dangerous.

Thank the guy, change the bulbs and happy days.

Paynewright

659 posts

108 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
I think you’ve found a good guy. Fix the problems and go there again.

I take all our vehicles for MOT and generally know they’re in fine fettle. The day before I always check the lights and horn - easy fail but easy fix to avoid the hassle! I always wash them and hoover out so they present well.

Sheepshanks

41,403 posts

150 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
M.F.D said:
One of those things better not mentioned.
Yes, bit odd to post about it.

CoreyDog

886 posts

121 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
I'd buy him/her a beer and be on my way.

Those 2 bulbs will cost pennies and take a minute to change. Garage would have charged you probably about £10.

stevemcs

10,413 posts

124 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
CoreyDog said:
I'd buy him/her a beer and be on my way.

Those 2 bulbs will cost pennies and take a minute to change. Garage would have charged you probably about £10.
So you would buy someone a beer for a bent MOT ? Would you then complain if you purchased the car and discovered lots of faults ? I've never understood peoples fascination with a clean MOT, surely you would want to know if there were anything that needed addressing ?

Besides one number plate light out isn't a fail, its a pass and advise.

M.F.D

956 posts

132 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
stevemcs said:
So you would buy someone a beer for a bent MOT ? Would you then complain if you purchased the car and discovered lots of faults ? I've never understood peoples fascination with a clean MOT, surely you would want to know if there were anything that needed addressing ?

Besides one number plate light out isn't a fail, its a pass and advise.
I wouldn't call this a bent MOT tbh. Totally different if that car was hanging together, brakes done, tyres bald, major corrosion etc.


stevemcs

10,413 posts

124 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
M.F.D said:
stevemcs said:
So you would buy someone a beer for a bent MOT ? Would you then complain if you purchased the car and discovered lots of faults ? I've never understood peoples fascination with a clean MOT, surely you would want to know if there were anything that needed addressing ?

Besides one number plate light out isn't a fail, its a pass and advise.
I wouldn't call this a bent MOT tbh. Totally different if that car was hanging together, brakes done, tyres bald, major corrosion etc.
True, perhaps a little harsh.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
I had a tester who used to do the same - he used to sell me the minor bits to fix it, e.g. jubilee clamp for a CV boot

He also used to drag me in to point out any faults while it was on the ramp which was double helpful.

Wish I wasn't 3h away from them now!

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
Once took a Fiat 127 Sport for an MOT. Test guy said the sills were rotten on both sides and it was only the fact the door was shut that stopped the floor plan splitting. I asked if he could weld them, his reply, to what?
It still passed but he told me not to take it back again.

My dad used to take his cars to the local friendly MOT garage, they would pass with recommendations such as 'the chimey is leaking' or 'the candles are a bit low". When they introduced the exaust gas testing requirement the garage kept a micra on standby for gas samples!

Happy days.

Little Pete

1,926 posts

125 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
He probably passed it by mistake laugh
Never done myself of coursewhistle

AlexRS2782

8,539 posts

244 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
MOT testers can't win with the OP by the sounds of it - they either pass it when it should fail / be an advisory or fail it when OP thinks it should have been passed without issue.

Go back 18 months and it seems they had issues with another MOT on the same car - although the last time it was evidently a fraudulent tester failing the car, but then deleted the post.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Doesn’t take long to do a pre MOT check. Lots of check lists online to pick up obvious problems like this.

colin79666

2,228 posts

144 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
wyson said:
Doesn’t take long to do a pre MOT check. Lots of check lists online to pick up obvious problems like this.
Indeed the number of cars failing for duff wiper blades or no washer fluid is ridiculous.

edthefed

834 posts

98 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Before he moved away i had a trusted mechanic

He would service my cars regularly and come MoT time if he found anything he would give me a call - it needs X doing but i am passing it because i know you will get in done next week...now what day can you bring it in for me to do it ?

Saved him doing a free re test and he knew the work would get done.

Plus the previous years MoT still had a few days cover left on it

Practical solution by two men who trusted each other !