BMW M5 (E60) | The Brave Pill
Ten cylinders, eight owners, how many excuses not to?

Last week's Pill pairing of a brace of Rover 800s received a far warmer critical reception than office cynics expected them to. This week we're returning to more familiar ground with a Pill combining the carrot of 500hp, rear-wheel drive and a savage, rev-happy V10 engine with the stick of proven potential to deliver more bills than a William convention. Yep, it's an E60 BMW M5 and, to the surprise of the database rodents, it is the first Pill has featured.
We're about two minutes to midnight on the combustion engine clock, yet even with the end in sight it is surprising that no major engine cylinder configuration has yet become extinct. True, there are no straight eights any more, and some other oddball pre-war offerings have never been replaced. But the world still contains such compelling oddballs as the V10. But it won't for much longer: the Audi R8 and Lamborghini Huracan are both on the slide to retirement.
Yet if only one V10-powered car was to be placed into a future Museum of Environmental Hatecrime you could make an excellent case for picking the E60 M5 in place of the more glamourous supercars; this really was about as mad as the early 21st century car industry got. In the noughties V10s seemed to be cropping up almost everywhere, with Audi using them for the more senior S and RS models and Volkswagen even jumping the shark with its V10 TDI. So it wasn't surprising that when BMW replaced the sublime V8-powered E39 M5 it did so with a new car featuring two more cylinders and a substantial power upgrade.

But this couldn't come from forced induction. BMW's M Division wrote its own rules in those days, with the biggest ones pretty much carved in stone: no turbochargers, no automatic gearboxes, only rear-wheel drive. (Hindsight plays a sad trombone at this point.) The 5.0-litre V10 that was developed was a technical masterpiece, but it was also a deeply unlikely powerplant for a large saloon, making its peak torque at 6,100rpm and delivering maximum power just 500rpm shy of its 8,250rpm limiter. That's because, to the M Division of that era, driveability was less important than outright performance.
To prove this point BMW laid on a runway on the original press launch, letting journalists perform a full launch control start and giving them strict instructions not to lift until the 'brake here' boards at the far end. By the time these flashed pat the car was sitting on its limiter at an indicated 165mph and there was a distinct lack of tarmac remaining. Media events were different in those days.
The E60's transmission choice was similarly performance focussed. The E39 M5's six-speed manual had been a bar to sales in those parts of the world too dumb to operate clutch pedals, and the E60 was shifted to an automated single clutch gearbox (a manual was later offered too, but never in the UK.) The SMT was certainly better than many of its rat trap rivals, offering varying degrees of shift severity, but even in the gentlest of these it was still abrupt and lurch-prone compared to a torque converter, or a more modern double-clutch transmission. Yes, you quickly get used to it. But when I drove BMW's own immaculately preserved E60 M5 a couple of years ago, the first I'd experienced since the car was on sale, it was the area in which it felt most dated.

Yet, gearbox aside, contemporary press reviews glowed with radioactive intensity. The E60's chassis was brilliant - firmer than the E39, but not uncomfortably so, and with a precision that made its predecessor feel a little lardy. The steering was outstanding, too - sniper accurate and rich in feedback, giving the confidence in the front end required to exploit the ability to radically adjust the rear axle's cornering attitude using the power. It was good enough to earn a pass for some pretty obvious flaws, like the V10's diesel-like clatter when cold and frequently abysmal fuel economy. Also the fact that, like every other E60, the interior featured more black plastic than a low-rent S&M convention.
These were niggles, but a multitude of more serious problems emerged as the M5 grew older. The biggest - grab a clove of garlic here - the infamous risk of rod bearing failure. The tightness of the highly strung engine's tolerances meant the conrod bearings could wear excessively if the motor was revved hard before it had fully warmed through. Something which could lead to sudden, catastrophic failure of both V10 and - shortly afterwards - savings accounts. The SMG can create some substantial invoices, too - with the common failure of the hydraulic pump that powers it alongside high clutch consumption.
But the E60 M5's biggest issue was probably the same one that had dogged its predecessors: acute depreciation that dropped values to the point where optimists were soon trying to run them on tight budgets. Something that would often lead to a cycle of break-and-bodge as owners patched up their cars at the lowest cost and passed them on like fizzing grenades.

Yet as numbers have thinned out, the outlook has changed. Even with its mechanical issues priced in, the E60 M5 still looks like a highlight of its overpowered era, and values have started to rise to the extent that fresher and nicer examples are frequently being offered for more than the faster, but less charismatic, turbocharged F10 version. Which is why this one stood out - the cheapest E60 M5 currently in the classifieds - a £14,695 price tag making it barely half as much as some of the nicer, pricier examples.
That valuation is likely due to having covered 123,000 miles in the care of eight owners, with the odometer score borne out by some obviously worn trim; the soft-touch coating BMW used in this era seems particularly prone to wearing off. But it has what seems like a full set of options, including the roll-fighting adaptive seat bolsters and head-up display. The advert makes no mention of service history, but the MOT record is reassuringly green with a succession of clean passes, the most recent in January. The last advisory was worn tyres in 2015, the last failure a wobbly track-rod end back in 2011. It also seems to be being sold with one of the 'M5' private registrations that seemed almost compulsory when the car was new, so if your initials are GUC that's a bonus.
E60 M5s have been cheaper, but it seems unlikely that values will fall back too far given the obvious limitation on supply as demand rises. Our Pill will never be worth as much as a minty low mileage example, but neither should its next owner be afraid to add some more miles to its already impressive tally, and to exploit its ability to turn fuel into noise, G-forces and single digit MPG scores.

This is on my shortlist for my next interesting car buy, because V10 mainly (and despite bland interior and dated gearbox), but this particular one doesn’t have me tempted!
Good to see that the SMG didn't get a kicking in the article, you do get used to it very quickly and it does the job of being interesting and fast shifting at high rpm. Just don't leave it in auto...
As for the brave element.... These will cost money to run. No hiding from that, but to be honest, so will any aging 5 series. iDrive or DSC issues are not M5 specific and they can mount up
worn suspension, corroded brake lines etc etc happens to all cars and may be addressed already. Rod bearings should be changed and then forgotten about (as long as the car is used properly), but beyond that much of the broken bits will be sorted by now or just be routine maintenance. Having one that isn't pristine but mechanically sound does have an appeal too. Buy one that has been cared for.
The biggest problem will be fuel consumption. It is phenomenal how quickly you can drain a tank. You can eke out 30mpg on a very long run (apparently), but honestly, life is far too short for that misery. Expect high teens day to day and a range of 150 miles, or 225 if driving further. 7mpg is as low as the read out goes, if that helps.
The other thing to remember with these is that they are not the fastest off the line. They are very quick if you commit and really launch it, but day to day driving you will notice less low down thrust than you might expect from a 5.0 engine. It is never slow, so ignore what others say about a lack of torque, that is nonsense, but this thing makes power at the top end. The kick you get above 6krpm is addictive, especially with the sound track you get, so if driving one remember that. What you basically have is a quick car that becomes a monster at high rpm. In summary, use a lower gear and enjoy it.
I bought an M6 rather than an M5 as it makes more sense, it's a high revving supercar engine and a practical saloon shape didn't really gel for me, as that would suit a lazy torque focussed engine (in my mind). It should be more of a weekend car or a toy that will do the day to day thing perfectly well, but at a cost. In my little mind it felt more 'right' as a coupe. However, given that the ultra rare touring is the one everyone loves, I totally get that it might just be me.
Values of these things are going up, as all older M cars do, especially as the really grotty ones die out. If you like amazing engines and understand how to look after one, try one (properly) before the chance is gone.
Sorry, not quite one of these: an alpina. That's why there was no speed limiter when he test drove it!
He's got more BMW with v10 and v12 than lesser engine it seems.
I'll try to add a link. Any question about me or this post, let's just say covid forced idle time has forced some unusual suggestions in my YouTube feed...
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBcFoVFuPCfi7Ph...
Sorry, not quite one of these: an alpina. That's why there was no speed limiter when he test drove it!
He's got more BMW with v10 and v12 than lesser engine it seems.
I'll try to add a link. Any question about me or this post, let's just say covid forced idle time has forced some unusual suggestions in my YouTube feed...
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBcFoVFuPCfi7Ph...
That is the Alpina B7, but he also imported a manual M5 from the US and did a load of work on this. His is delimited and he does do 200+mph on the autobahn with it. Really good to watch him work on his cars, which also include a manual 850i.
Like most M5s I love how subtle they are, and if you didn't know cars you'd never know that this has a 5.0 V10 engine under its bonnet. They are almost Q car like I reckon.
I do like these an awful lot but I’m not brave enough to run one mainly for the fear of what others have cut corners on. The noise they make is epic and I love the absurdity of that engine in a far my plain looking saloon.
Sorry, not quite one of these: an alpina. That's why there was no speed limiter when he test drove it!
He's got more BMW with v10 and v12 than lesser engine it seems.
I'll try to add a link. Any question about me or this post, let's just say covid forced idle time has forced some unusual suggestions in my YouTube feed...
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLBcFoVFuPCfi7Ph...

If anyone wants a full owner experience thread and hasn't yet seen it, then check out https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...
I've experienced most of the bigger ticket items.
- no torque at all compared to the luscious V8 in the E39
- needed revving to hell to get any performance out of it
- sounded like a hairdryer compared to the V8 burble in the E39
- 12 mpg average !!
.. and then there was the Stupid Mother****ing Gearbox (SMG).. I went through THREE of these under warranty.. all of them failed completely during long distance family trips.. an absolute disgrace that put me off M cars for life. A blessing is disguise, however, as I was introduced to Alpina and never looked back.
Here's an example of the hell I endured with this vehicle..
https://www.m5board.com/threads/now-im-furious-the...
- no torque at all compared to the luscious V8 in the E39
- needed revving to hell to get any performance out of it
- sounded like a hairdryer compared to the V8 burble in the E39
- 12 mpg average !!
.. and then there was the Stupid Mother****ing Gearbox (SMG).. I went through THREE of these under warranty.. all of them failed completely during long distance family trips.. an absolute disgrace that put me off M cars for life. A blessing is disguise, however, as I was introduced to Alpina and never looked back.
Here's an example of the hell I endured with this vehicle..
https://www.m5board.com/threads/now-im-furious-the...
High revving and the sound are reasons why you should buy one, but only if you like that. Sounded like a test drive before you bought one would have stopped you?
The E39 and the E60 are really quite different in nature.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



