No longer desire a sports car that can do everything
No longer desire a sports car that can do everything
Author
Discussion

xondat

Original Poster:

235 posts

81 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
TLDR: anyone swap a sports car that they used for everything to a comfortable road car + dedicated track car?

Last summer I started doing track days - really enjoyed it and something I will continue doing, however it brought a couple points to mind:
  • a car designed to drive well on both road & track is naturally a bit compromised at both
  • tracking my daily is risky from a crash perspective, and also costly in general
To me, there's three types of driving - regular, everyday driving where comfort is key; fast road driving; and track driving. I've sort of lost interest in fast road driving because I'd rather just do it on track. And I'm not sure there is a car that can perfectly do both comfort + track driving as they're opposites to me.

Puts me in the position where I'd rather just have two separate cars for the two separate tasks. Anyone that's also had this thought, what did you end up doing? Is it worth it?

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Quite a common issue - for me I'd have a 3-car fleet in an ideal world... The comfortable tow car (e.g. Range Rover), the track car which doesn't need compromise, and something that still works on the road.

South tdf

1,830 posts

226 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Had a slightly similar problem, had a daily BMW, Evoque and 488. The 488 never got used as I never wanted to leave it anywhere and could not use it for work so ended up just driving it for the sake of it.

Have now just got a company Polestar (no BIK so actually seem better off than taking the allowance) and a Macan GTS but am keeping an eye out for a cheap Boxster 981.

DonkeyApple

70,919 posts

200 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Quite a common issue - for me I'd have a 3-car fleet in an ideal world... The comfortable tow car (e.g. Range Rover), the track car which doesn't need compromise, and something that still works on the road.
Inclined to agree. I do find track days in road cars immensely dull.

Towing barge, track car and possibly a shed. All bases covered without compromise.

Cylon2007

611 posts

109 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
I'm in a similar position in that my current only car is a MX5 ND that I love but it does have issues in space etc and with the recent weather it's not as fun to drive it however I don't want to get rid. Today I've driven to work in my lad's car, a shed 55 plate Focus, as I drive it once a week to keep the battery up etc as he still hasn't passed his test.

Although it's far from perfect but then again it only cost £600, it's easier to get into and out of (I'm old with a dodgy left knee and hip) and being FWD it doesn't have the same worry about wet / slippy roundabouts on the commute.

Keep looking at i20N or possibly Yaris GR but can I forgo the convertible roof in the better weather?

Anyway having a new set of Michelin PS5 tyres fitted tomorrow so let's see if that improves the wet/cold grip a bit.

LaurasOtherHalf

21,429 posts

227 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
VW Amarok, BMW i3S, Caterham Supersprint and a race shuttle! Life is about compromises, even the Caterham is one as seeing as it's 95bhp it's more suited to road than track but some of the world's best roads are on my doorstep-it's used more on road than track anyway.

brillomaster

1,914 posts

201 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Yes. Used to daily a nissan 350z, which was great, but thirsty and not that practical. Swapped that for a flappy paddle bmw 335i, and then a full auto, 330d. Much better daily, economical, so easy to drive, and a very pleasant place to be.

At the same time bought a bmw z4 for weekends and trackdays which was awesome at that, but would have been a terrible daily. Now swapped that for a porsche boxster.

So now have two, almost polar opposite cars - one is big, comfortable, 4 seat, hardtop, diesel, automatic. And the other is small, sporty, 2 seat, convertible, petrol, manual. Whatever i want to use the car for, i have the right tool for the job.

Plus, having a back up car in case one is in the garage is always useful!

RDMcG

20,921 posts

238 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Cannot imagine a car that would do everything I enjoy doing. If I were forced to have a single car it would definitely be an SUV with proper power.

However I currently use:

- for city driving and parking; old Smart ForTwo diesel

-winter, towing, dog transport: old Porsche Cayenne V8

-Serious off-roading: old Jeep Wrangler

-long distance comfort: Panamera ST Turbo

-OH car: old Mercedes R230 SL500

-track stuff: 997.1 GT3RS and 991.1 GT3RS

The Cayenne is due for replacement as it has almost 300,000km on it with 50,000km of that towing, so new on in a couple of months. The rest will stay and there will be a 992RS which will be my absolutely final track car.Too old for the next generation.

As for EVs I willl ultimately replace the Smart with something as small as possible for city use - home charging and short distances will elminate range anxiety and no need for some kind of brilliant performance..it replaces a Smart!