RE: Range Rover 4.6 Vogue (P38) | High Mile Club
RE: Range Rover 4.6 Vogue (P38) | High Mile Club
Monday 21st February 2022

Range Rover 4.6 Vogue (P38) | High Mile Club

If the 1990s are back in fashion, this must be the coolest SUV around



As someone as far removed from the latest fashions as it's possible to be, it's interesting to watch the cyclical nature of trends. What was desperately uncool becomes in vogue again, only to fall out of favour immediately afterwards. Nowadays, for example, it seems a new car can't launch without a rear light bar (and even a front one, in some cases), but how long before that is unfashionable again? And how on earth can a car be designed now that won't go into production for years? It could look terrible by that point.

Discussions of style, class and fashion are never far away when talking about Range Rovers. Somebody will call it 'timeless', another 'effortless' and so on and so on - then the P38 will be mentioned. For so long the unwanted child of the Range Rover family, it finally feels like time has decided to be kind to the 90s' flagship. It likely won't ever be as revered as the original, and didn't represent the same enormous leap forward as its own L322 successor did, but as the years progress so the P38 slowly moves from old fashioned to modern classic.

The keen amongst you will note this isn't the first time this generation has featured as a High Mile Club car, which might say something for this Range Rover's durability given their infamous reputation. However, this one is a little different to the CVC; it's a much later model, with the larger 4.6 and automatic, plus it's an order of magnitude cheaper - just £5k, in fact, rather than more than £40,000.



Of course, there are differences. This P38 isn't one of the collectible pre-production cars, it hasn't been restored, and its odo reading is higher - now a smidge over 160k. But while we've all seen our fair share of temptingly cheap, shoddily presented Range Rovers, this doesn't seem to be one of them: the advert suggests one previous owner, with both paint and upholstery pointing to a life lived considerately. Yes, there's a towbar, and, yes, there's clearly some wear, but there have been plenty of lower mileage cars looking a lot worse than this.

Apparently, the doting owner has spent a fair amount in the past few miles, including new tyres, air suspension pump, diff bearings, exhaust silencer and more. Which means a few less things for the next owner to worry about; nice example or otherwise, no Range Rover is going to be entirely free from drama. Or cheap to run...

But such is the Range Rover appeal that plenty have taken the risk over the years, and surely will continue doing so in the future. At £5,000 it's difficult to imagine good P38s getting any cheaper, not least with a new Range Rover invariably drawing attention to the old stuff. The MOT history is distinctly unscary by the standards of these cars, the colour combination is always going to be popular, and its top-of-the-range status makes this Range an easier sell, surely, than a lowlier diesel. Once upon a time the late Classics were seen as dated, old hat and undesirable - and were cheap as a result. It would be amazing if something similar didn't happen with these P38s, so don't say you weren't told. Next stop 200,000 miles, right?







Author
Discussion

jerrytlr

Original Poster:

433 posts

244 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
Love the P38, and agree that it's time will arrive - probably quite soon!

I bought a LHD one in the UK when living in France, a lowly 2.5D, cloth seats... with a view to selling it in France for a small profit. Liked it so much, I ended up keeping it for over 2 years (replaced by an L322, far more sophisticated but never quite had the robust feel of the P38). I still managed to make a few euros profit.

The things that struck me most about the P38:

- super capable at just about anything you did with it
- Air suspension is brilliant - it will need fixing at some point, but that is cheap and easy to do (DIY is certainly feasible)
- BMW engine the least reliable part of the car, but still great with amazing refinement
- no rust!! they seem very well rust proofed compared with most other vehicles of that era


Would happily have another!




Orangutangerine

865 posts

211 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
IMO the best looking Range Rover. Like a Morris Ital estate on steroids. Epic.

The Wookie

14,209 posts

259 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
My parents had two of these back in the day.

The first was an 96 N reg 4.6, absolutely the worst car they ever owned, air suspension failed dramatically on the motorway in the first few weeks, constant issues with the HVAC, electric windows and roof, slipped liners and engine failure at 70,000 miles, plus various random electronic gremlins. The usual favourite was the key going out of sync, almost always at a petrol station, then spending the next half an hour with people looking at you like you were an idiot with the alarm blaring while you tried to tap out the obscure sequence with the key in the door lock to disarm it.

The next was a 2000 W reg one. Absolutely the best car they ever owned. Nothing went wrong with it in 100,000 miles, it was lovely to drive and it still looked like brand new when it was traded in for an L322 in about 2004. Wish we'd kept it.

McRors

470 posts

87 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
The Wookie said:
My parents had two of these back in the day.

The first was an 96 N reg 4.6, absolutely the worst car they ever owned, air suspension failed dramatically on the motorway in the first few weeks, constant issues with the HVAC, electric windows and roof, slipped liners and engine failure at 70,000 miles, plus various random electronic gremlins. The usual favourite was the key going out of sync, almost always at a petrol station, then spending the next half an hour with people looking at you like you were an idiot with the alarm blaring while you tried to tap out the obscure sequence with the key in the door lock to disarm it.

The next was a 2000 W reg one. Absolutely the best car they ever owned. Nothing went wrong with it in 100,000 miles, it was lovely to drive and it still looked like brand new when it was traded in for an L322 in about 2004. Wish we'd kept it.
Your parents must have been very brave or in love with the car to buy another after such a catalogue of faults. Well done to them.

spookly

4,397 posts

126 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
I had a 4.6 P38.
Lovely when it worked. Only had one big thing go wrong, head gaskets, but it was the constant stream of minor things that got annoying after a while. Felt like I was fixing something every other week.
Sold it on with 105000 miles on it and recently rebuilt heads. Still see it about sometimes, as I sold it to a brave young local lad.

asci.white

561 posts

104 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
We had one in the family for many years that was used in its natural habitat. Probably spent 80% of its life off road and other than the few minor documented issues worked like a trooper. Was always a great way to cross a muddy field during snow to check on a lost cow..

Tayne

76 posts

168 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
Speaking as a former p38 owener, its a nice place to sit whilst you wait for the recovery truck.

Deranged Rover

4,718 posts

105 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
It's not an SUV.

And it's not cool either. Nothing that looks like the bd love child of a London taxi and a Talbot Horizon will ever be cool!

To be fair, it does look quite decent but, no, absolutely not.

Filibuster

3,407 posts

246 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
I had a lovely, very well sorted 2000 4.6 HSE in beautiful condition for a year, just before the pandemic.
On one hand I regret selling it, as it was truly "one of the good examples", but it still threw something new at me on a regular basis.
I decided that i don't want a car I don't need and that demands money thrown at it on a regular basis and sold it.

Since then I got bored and bought a 90's Mercedes SL to again have a car I don't need and that asks for money biggrin

ETA pics of my P38







Edited by Filibuster on Monday 21st February 16:39

The Wookie

14,209 posts

259 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
McRors said:
Your parents must have been very brave or in love with the car to buy another after such a catalogue of faults. Well done to them.
At the time it was their 4th Range Rover, with numbers 1 and 3 being faultless and number 2 being fine after a few teething problems. Things like Pajeros and Landcruisers were the only real alternatives that suited them at the time and I guess neither appealed to them! They had a G-wagen before the first Range Rover which they liked but I think they were probably seen as old fashioned at the time although ironically the old man actually has a 2005 G55 now too!

Range Rover number 9 arriving next month and although not all of them have been flawless, most have and none have been anywhere near as problematic as that P38!

emlynbeagler

11 posts

114 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
I sold my 1998 P38 for a song in 2009 after 2 years of trouble-plagued ownership and bought a new Subaru. Did an MOT check on the Range Rover out of idle curiosity last year and the bd thing is still running at nearly 300000 miles with barely an advisory since I had it. I guess these cars either like you and cooperate, or they don’t.

Lovely thing when it worked, though. Bodywork was beautifully built, and it was unstoppable off-road on BF Goodrich ATs. Almost fancy another one.

trevalvole

2,095 posts

64 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
I may be missing something, but doesn't PH usually have a link to the advert in these spotted-style articles?

the_hood

777 posts

225 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
Orangutangerine said:
IMO the best looking Range Rover.
For me, it's easily the worst looking.

240Cup

767 posts

221 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
The car is not a 1 owner, it is 7.


DanG355

576 posts

232 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
trevalvole said:
I may be missing something, but doesn't PH usually have a link to the advert in these spotted-style articles?
I thought the same - scanned the b*stard article three times as was sure I must of missed it…

100SRV

2,385 posts

273 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
Four-wheeler magazine "four wheeler of the year" winner in 1989, they don't mess around when testing and critiquing contenders.

aaron_2000

5,407 posts

114 months

Monday 21st February 2022
quotequote all
Never liked the P38, I'd go L322 any day of the week. Not that I'd want to run another L322 any time soon.

Cold

16,755 posts

121 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
100SRV said:
Four-wheeler magazine "four wheeler of the year" winner in 1989, they don't mess around when testing and critiquing contenders.
In 1989? That's an impressive feat for all involved.

Konan

2,723 posts

177 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
I was quite taken back only yesterday when I saw one of these moving under it's own motive power.

Walter Sobchak

5,739 posts

255 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Personally I can’t stand them and I like Range Rovers, my brother had an N reg 4.6 HSE in about 2004/2005 and 80k miles, constant faults with the suspension, like another poster mentioned it would need the key resetting and you had to do this funny safe combination like sequence in the drivers door lock with the key to sort the alarm out and get the key working again, AC worked when it felt like it and blew in what direction it chose, boot lock broke, air suspension broke, overheated, he was constantly in fear about what the next triple beep of doom would be, was slow,thirsty, unreliable and looked like a metro cab,couldn’t pay me to have one.
L322s on the other hand are lovely, the ones I’ve owned have had a few issues but nothing like that P38.
90s 4x4s?, I’d much rather an 80 Series Landcruiser, or a 200/300 TDI Disco.