Anyone who genuinely knows about car insurance: excess!?
Anyone who genuinely knows about car insurance: excess!?
Author
Discussion

TinselTown

Original Poster:

8 posts

59 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
I am using my brother's account to post this (he posted a while ago about the incident).

I was the middle car in a 3-car shunt, I had just stopped behind someone who'd pulled out in front of me and the car behind was going too fast for the conditions (although not speeding) and crashed into me, pushing me into car in front. I'm not interested at the moment in discussing liability, because this post is assuming the rearmost car is found liable (I had dashcam footage etc and nothing ambiguous happened - one collision).

Car is fixed but I'm being charged an excess. I've been given contradictory information from my insurers about this, hence I'd appreciate anyone who knows their stuff advising me!
My insurers are making noises that they won't refund my excess (£400) even if it's a no-fault claim. They are pursuing their costs only from the 3rd-party. I'd assumed all costs would be covered by the 3rd party, so I am confused why my excess isn't included in that (if they hadn't crashed into me I wouldn't be claiming). However it's hard to hear them on the phone and a different person giving different info each time - originally they said the opposite, that it'd be covered.

Just wondering what the normal process is and what I can expect. Do I have to also pursue the 3rd-party insurers separately to cover this, and how likely is it I'll see it? Why can't my insurers just include it in what they're claiming?

Basically I thought that this was essentially a claim on the 3rd party's insurers, via mine, so not technically 'me claiming on my insurance' but obviously I could be wrong.


Panamax

10,134 posts

65 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
NCD isn't "no fault" discount it's "no claims" discount. Essentially a "no incidents" discount. You've been involved in an incident and are making a claim so it's going to be on your insurance record.

Your excess will be recovered from the party at fault by your insurers. Absolutely definitely if you have legal expenses cover included.

Fastdruid

9,417 posts

183 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
You shouldn't have to pay it but often if there is a question over liability they will charge it first then refund.

Every time I've had a claim on my policy that wasn't my fault they've immediately waived charging the excess as they've all been cars drive into mine while it was parked!



TinselTown

Original Poster:

8 posts

59 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Panamax said:
NCD isn't "no fault" discount it's "no claims" discount. Essentially a "no incidents" discount. You've been involved in an incident and are making a claim so it's going to be on your insurance record.

Your excess will be recovered from the party at fault by your insurers. Absolutely definitely if you have legal expenses cover included.
I've not mentioned NCD at all, I'm not looking for a discount on my premium (gritting my teeth to see what they are next though, as it's my first incident since I started driving!!)

Just want to know what the normal procedure is about paying the excess. A friend had a car drive into hers, write it off, and she wasn't asked for any excess at all.

TinselTown

Original Poster:

8 posts

59 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Fastdruid said:
You shouldn't have to pay it but often if there is a question over liability they will charge it first then refund.

Every time I've had a claim on my policy that wasn't my fault they've immediately waived charging the excess as they've all been cars drive into mine while it was parked!
Thanks, that's helpful, and what I assumed would happen!
No idea of timescale but it's been 2 months (over Christmas) and they haven't got liability admitted by the other driver yet. I guess they present a case to their insurers with their costs and it all gets hashed out. Possibly having another person involves makes it more protracted. (Shouldn't though, really).

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
TinselTown said:
Basically I thought that this was essentially a claim on the 3rd party's insurers, via mine, so not technically 'me claiming on my insurance' but obviously I could be wrong.
The system is arcane but effectively this is where you're going wrong.

If you make a claim on your insurance, then your insurance company pays. As part of that, you pay your excess (or "uninsured loss").

Now if they can identify the third party, and they think the third party is liable, they will separately pursue them for their costs and for your uninsured loss. After some time (and it can be months if not more for complex or contentious claims) they will come to an agreement and recover some, all, or none of their outlay. If they are successful in getting the third party to agree liability, then and only then will you get your excess back.

This is one of the reasons why it's always worth speaking to the third party's insurers first, as if they immediately admit liability then all of this goes away.

JeffreyD

6,155 posts

71 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Your excess is your loss so you need to pursue it.

If you have a legal expenses policy they will do it for you, otherwise you will have to contact the third party insurer and chase them yourself.
You will get it back eventually.

Panamax

10,134 posts

65 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
TinselTown said:
Panamax said:
Your excess will be recovered from the party at fault by your insurers. Absolutely definitely if you have legal expenses cover included.
Just want to know what the normal procedure is about paying the excess. A friend had a car drive into hers, write it off, and she wasn't asked for any excess at all.
I thought I'd made that clear.

rllmuk

145 posts

188 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
The only time I've had a claim the other party admitted liability but I'd put the claim through my insurer before his got in contact with me. As such, I paid my insurer the excess and then wrote to the other parties insurer and asked for my excess back which the promptly sent via cheque.

Note this was a few years back, so am sure emails replace letters to an extent, but the process is largely the same. Claims management companies get a bad name, and I'd agree with that for a number of reasons, but they do tend to handle this crap for you.

Sheepshanks

41,390 posts

150 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Both times we've claimed through our own insurance (LV=) for non-fault accidents they've waived the excess.

I guess a "lesser" company will leave it to the customer to sort out for themselves.

If you go direct to the 3rd party insurer for the whole claim, which some people recommend but hasn't worked for us, they will settle in full.

TinselTown

Original Poster:

8 posts

59 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Both times we've claimed through our own insurance (LV=) for non-fault accidents they've waived the excess.

I guess a "lesser" company will leave it to the customer to sort out for themselves.

If you go direct to the 3rd party insurer for the whole claim, which some people recommend but hasn't worked for us, they will settle in full.
Thanks - yeah I was wondering if I'd gone wrong and should've gone straight to the 3rd party insurer!
Maybe I'll wait and see and if they keep refusing to recover this cost for me I'll go to the 3rd party one. I just assumed this would be a fairly common procedure. I've felt really down about the whole stupid incident (although thankful no-one was hurt) so this dragging it out and costing hundreds isn't helping.

TinselTown

Original Poster:

8 posts

59 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
JeffreyD said:
Your excess is your loss so you need to pursue it.

If you have a legal expenses policy they will do it for you, otherwise you will have to contact the third party insurer and chase them yourself.
You will get it back eventually.
Thanks! and thanks all.

Sheepshanks

41,390 posts

150 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
TinselTown said:
Thanks - yeah I was wondering if I'd gone wrong and should've gone straight to the 3rd party insurer!
First time I tried I was give the run-around although they did seem to get themselves together a couple of days later but by then it ws too late. Second time (an Argos van rear-ended daughter's car) got completely stone-walled. Turned out our insurer did too and had to threaten to go legal on them.

I also saw comments that as you have no legal relationship with each other and you're not paying the repairer if you aren't happy with repairs you can be left in no-mans land.

ashenfie

3,446 posts

77 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Its simple really an voluntary+compulsory access is the amount you agree to pay regardless of fault towards any accident. So no there is not a refund option when claim on your own policy. Now on the basis of what you have said the person at the rear of the shunt is responsible for you un-insured losses. Simply send his insurance company an invoice and they should pay you.

It's most likely a bit late now but the last time someone drove into me, I went directly to the other parties insurance company and they arrange for my car to be fixed which avoids all hassle. I simply notified my insurance company of the accident.

vikingaero

13,606 posts

200 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
Others have more or less got it.

The excess is normally paid to the repairer when you collect your car from being repaired regardless of whose fault it is. If you didn't take your car for repairs, but the claim goes ahead there is no excess to pay.

Some decent Insurers will waive the excess if the fault has been established between parties.

You or your legal expenses recover your excess from the 3rd party and your No Claims will be reinstated.

c_henry

61 posts

101 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
vikingaero said:
The excess is normally paid to the repairer when you collect your car from being repaired regardless of whose fault it is.
Something tangentially related that point, some insurers charge an extra excess if you don't take the car to their approved repairers, I got charged an additional £100 on mine.