Total loss pay out from third parties insurance, questions..
Total loss pay out from third parties insurance, questions..
Author
Discussion

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,663 posts

303 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
I'm after some advice regarding what I should expect regarding the pay out following a non fault incident which may result in the car being written off, in anticipation of a conversation I expect to have with them tomorrow morning which will likely draw this to a conclusion.

A few weeks ago, I was involved in an incident where an object came off the back of a tractor travelling in the opposite direction, and collided with my car. The tractor did not stop, however I was able to turn around and catch up, and get his details.

The company who the driver was employed by has admitted liability and they started the claim with their insurance company.

My car was insured on a full value policy via A-Plan, but they advised me I'd be best to go through their insurance company as they admitted liability.

Last week the car was taken to the repairer, and until now I've not heard anything back - crap service so far, but I won't go into that.

Today I got a phone call saying they've finally had the report from the repairer. The insurance company need to look into it properly, and they say they'll call me back with their conclusions tomorrow. He did end the conversation by stating he thought the car would most likely be a write off, in his experience.

With the scenario in mind, I'm now wondering what to expect, and how the conversation should / will pan out...

  • I bought the car from a respected Boxster dealer/specialist 2004, 80K miles, FSH, back in August 2021, for £10,495
  • I spent £672 on refreshing the top mounts, coffin arms, and laser alignment following a specialist examination
  • Car was in otherwise immaculate. Definitely A+ condition
Now, if this was through my own insurance company, then I'd not be particularly concerned about getting at least £10k which would have been my declared valuation, if not the original amount.

However, as I'm going through the guilty parties insurance, I imagine they are likely to try and low ball an offer. In fact I imagine they'll go on Autotrader or eBay and find one for £6k, and declare that's what its worth. Such a car would never be anything like as good as the car I had.

If that happens, where do I stand with that? I don't feel its fair that I should lose thousands for an incident that was not my fault.

What about recovering the large amount of money I spent recently refreshing components? I imagine I'll be lucky to get that back, but if I had to take the hit on that, I will.

The other less likely scenario, is the car will be repaired. However, will it then be Cat C/D/N ? This will affect its resale value, which was a large part of buying a car like that - albeit I appreciate I paid more for a pristine example, but still, I'd not expect to lose the amount I will inevitably lose in depreciation if I decided to sell up in 6 - 12 months as a result of it being declared accident damaged/repaired, so in this event, would I be compensated the loss?

Any insights from anyone who has been through a similar situation would be welcome. I've not been in this situation before so want to go in with my eyes open. Thanks

JeffreyD

6,155 posts

71 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
If you aren't happy with their offer then claim on your own insurance, if you think you will get more

Your insurer will then claim the money back.



TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,663 posts

303 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
JeffreyD said:
If you aren't happy with their offer then claim on your own insurance, if you think you will get more

Your insurer will then claim the money back.
Well, that was a lot easier than I thought laugh

Thanks for your input smile

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
I had quite a similar situation with my old RX8. Drunk driver drove into when it was parked outside my house.

It was mint, had a recent engine rebuild with all the right bits before I got it and I'd just spent a fortune replacing all the bushes in the suspension.

First offer was, presumably, based on the cheapest one they could find on auto trader and was barely enough to buy a st heap with hot start problems. I told them to bugger off and provided a massive file of what I'd spent, condition etc. I got back basically the purchase price in the end.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,663 posts

303 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
hairykrishna said:
I had quite a similar situation with my old RX8. Drunk driver drove into when it was parked outside my house.

It was mint, had a recent engine rebuild with all the right bits before I got it and I'd just spent a fortune replacing all the bushes in the suspension.

First offer was, presumably, based on the cheapest one they could find on auto trader and was barely enough to buy a st heap with hot start problems. I told them to bugger off and provided a massive file of what I'd spent, condition etc. I got back basically the purchase price in the end.
Thanks! I have all of the evidence and receipts from when I purchased it and the work that was done, so I should be good smile

JeffreyD

6,155 posts

71 months

Tuesday 22nd February 2022
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Well, that was a lot easier than I thought laugh

Thanks for your input smile
It will be of your insurer values the car the same as you do!

Hope it works out

Mr Tidy

31,927 posts

158 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
JeffreyD said:
If you aren't happy with their offer then claim on your own insurance, if you think you will get more

Your insurer will then claim the money back.
Personally I'd still claim from the third party insurer because they won't expect you to fund an excess before reclaiming it, and may be more amenable to getting a quick settlement to minimise/avoid car hire costs.

Jamescrs

6,552 posts

96 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Just adding in if the insurers do repair the car it won't have any Cat markers on it. That only happens if they write it off and pay out and it is later repaired by you or another and put back on the road.

Chubbyross

5,019 posts

116 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
OP, I’m sorry to hear about the Boxster. I seem to remember seeing photos somewhere. Did you post on PCGB?

As long as you have the car well documented I’d just keep rejecting the (inevitable) low-ball offers they’ll make until you’re satisfied. Good luck! You must have been gutted.

Drawweight

3,619 posts

147 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all

When someone wrote my motorbike off the first offer was just a stupid low one.

I emailed the assessor back with Autotrader adverts (luckily there weren’t many of that type) showing the present day values. I’d only had it 6 weeks so they were still pretty current and showed the price range that I’d bought it for.

I got offered 300 quid less than I bought it for so I accepted that.

They should offer you enough to replace the car with a similar model. What you paid for it is immaterial. You need back up adverts from dealers for similar cars.

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Thanks! I have all of the evidence and receipts from when I purchased it and the work that was done, so I should be good smile
You may well not get the money for the top mounts, coffin arms etc back directly. It does help build up the picture that it was in top condition though.

Mine took a fair bit of persistence to get a decent amount back. It's difficult because valuing a 'like for like' replacement when you know the car was one of the best available at the time you bought it is not easy.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,663 posts

303 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Thanks for the posts in support. The car has now been written off. I got pretty damn close to what I hoped, within a couple of hundred quid so the outcome is about as good as I could have expected.

Obviously gutted about the car but at least I'm still here to tell the tale and not really out of pocket.

eltax91

10,796 posts

237 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
TameRacingDriver said:
Thanks for the posts in support. The car has now been written off. I got pretty damn close to what I hoped, within a couple of hundred quid so the outcome is about as good as I could have expected.

Obviously gutted about the car but at least I'm still here to tell the tale and not really out of pocket.
Was there a low-ball offer? Or were they focussed on other costs like hire charges etc and wanted it done quickly?

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,663 posts

303 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
Was there a low-ball offer? Or were they focussed on other costs like hire charges etc and wanted it done quickly?
The low ball offer was only a grand less than I was after but I talked them up fairly easily.

hairykrishna

14,539 posts

234 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
Was there a low-ball offer? Or were they focussed on other costs like hire charges etc and wanted it done quickly?
It's what I found odd about my claim. They spaffed about 7k on hire car costs while arguing with me about valuations.