What caused this damage to my car?
Discussion
Hi Pistonheads
I recently had some repairs carried out by a well know accident repair centre, specifically replacing a cracked rear bumper and a cracked rear headlight on the right.
I have since (1 week later) discovered 4 very small dents in a perfectly square formation on the rear side door. The dents are really small but also very deep, taking the paint off down to the panel. Apologies for the crap images -


I have absolutely no idea how this damage would of occurred while out and about. The dents are too fine, low and uniformed for it to be another car door while parked, and it’s not even possible that the car has been driven into something. My only thinking is it was damaged while in the workshop but some sort of trolley or lift. Would anyone have any ideas as to what could of caused these dents? I've raised the damage with the repair center but they refuse to accept any responsibility. I wish I had noticed the damage earlier!
Punching at straws here I know. My poor metallic paint :-(
I recently had some repairs carried out by a well know accident repair centre, specifically replacing a cracked rear bumper and a cracked rear headlight on the right.
I have since (1 week later) discovered 4 very small dents in a perfectly square formation on the rear side door. The dents are really small but also very deep, taking the paint off down to the panel. Apologies for the crap images -
I have absolutely no idea how this damage would of occurred while out and about. The dents are too fine, low and uniformed for it to be another car door while parked, and it’s not even possible that the car has been driven into something. My only thinking is it was damaged while in the workshop but some sort of trolley or lift. Would anyone have any ideas as to what could of caused these dents? I've raised the damage with the repair center but they refuse to accept any responsibility. I wish I had noticed the damage earlier!
Punching at straws here I know. My poor metallic paint :-(
Whatever the actual cause, you have no chance of getting the repairer to stump up.
They know, probably quite rightly, that you don’t know for sure that it wasn’t like that when you handed it over or hasn’t happened somewhere since.
It’s why I hate handing my car over to anyone for anything.
They know, probably quite rightly, that you don’t know for sure that it wasn’t like that when you handed it over or hasn’t happened somewhere since.
It’s why I hate handing my car over to anyone for anything.
swisstoni said:
Whatever the actual cause, you have no chance of getting the repairer to stump up.
They know, probably quite rightly, that you don’t know for sure that it wasn’t like that when you handed it over or hasn’t happened somewhere since.
It’s why I hate handing my car over to anyone for anything.
I know, and I'm pissed I didn't notice the damage earlier. I hate leaving mar car anywhere now other then home.They know, probably quite rightly, that you don’t know for sure that it wasn’t like that when you handed it over or hasn’t happened somewhere since.
It’s why I hate handing my car over to anyone for anything.
Mave said:
If the red did dots are indicating where the marks are then that's weird as they're on different surfaces. I wouldnt expect a rectangular section of steel to be able to make uniform marks over irregular shapes. Are there any marks on the other door?
Yep, the red dots are to highlight position of the dents - I couldn't get a decent photo. No marks on the other side of the vehicle.KTMsm said:
I can only see the reflections of your fence
I see the red dots so presume the dents are under them - a lift couldn't cause that
Yep, the red dots are the dent locations. I thought the same and mentioned a lift to the garage, but they weren't forthcoming. Its definitely in the position where a lift would be used right?I see the red dots so presume the dents are under them - a lift couldn't cause that
Would a vehicle even need to go up on a lift just for a rear bumper and headlight replacement though?
thanks
Sorry to say but if it's taken you a week to spot the dents than how do you know they weren't there before it went into the workshop?
When was the last time you can be certain that the dents weren't there?
I don't think it could be caused by a two-post ramp as somebody else suggested, and it's quite a long way away from the repair area.
When was the last time you can be certain that the dents weren't there?
I don't think it could be caused by a two-post ramp as somebody else suggested, and it's quite a long way away from the repair area.
Little dents and scratches happen. It's a car, stones fly up on the road and hit your paintwork etc all the time, the wind blows stones and sticks around and can hit your car.
I can assure you, that damage isn't from the bodywork shop. And a two post lift isn't going to even go anywhere near the doors. They lift from underneath and will be at lowest height if the car goes over them.
Furthermore, bodywork shops rarely use 2 post lifts, and use cheaper lifts that lift from the whole sill area.
A 2 post will only be used for cars if they were to do jigging work. But you only had a bumper respray.
The damage is someone being careless in a car park or one of your passengers opening the door into something. A lot of lazy halfwits leave their trolleys in the car parks and they blow around in the slightest wind and leave nasty scratches.
I can assure you, that damage isn't from the bodywork shop. And a two post lift isn't going to even go anywhere near the doors. They lift from underneath and will be at lowest height if the car goes over them.
Furthermore, bodywork shops rarely use 2 post lifts, and use cheaper lifts that lift from the whole sill area.
A 2 post will only be used for cars if they were to do jigging work. But you only had a bumper respray.
The damage is someone being careless in a car park or one of your passengers opening the door into something. A lot of lazy halfwits leave their trolleys in the car parks and they blow around in the slightest wind and leave nasty scratches.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



