A Car's Perceived Beauty
A Car's Perceived Beauty
Author
Discussion

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,628 posts

271 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
After reading more "ugly BMW" comments, I was wondering - when people are saying they think a car is beautiful or ugly (or anywhere in between), what are they actually saying about it in a real world situation? Don't they want to look at it when one drives past? Wouldn't they want to be seen in one?

When one drives by, it's not your taste that's being questioned. If you are driving one, you can't actually see it anyway.

HelldogBE

285 posts

74 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
So you wouldn't mind driving a Fiat Multipla or a SsangYong Rodius then?

Surely you're confronted everytime you get in or out, wash it or look at it on the drive. If the ugly car was half the cost to purchase and run it, I'd contemplate it over a car whose aesthetics please me. But there's people spending loads on ugly (or bad) cars, maybe beauty is in the eye of the beholder or they appreciate having a rare and unique car over a beautiful one?

RobXjcoupe

3,392 posts

122 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
Nothing worse in my eye is seeing a 4 door hatch made to look sporty. I’m old skool now but my eye prefers just a single door each side of a car. A suv is a big car, not a raised suspension regular car with black plastic bits stuck on to resemble a wheel arch. I like lowered cars also. Not this air ride stuff that drops so low it can’t be driven, but it looks good in a picture?! If it’s low it has to be able to be driven on regular roads give or take a nasty speed hump.
All the different models and manufacturers around is what each can afford to buy and run I suppose but I wouldn’t buy a brand new cheap car just because it’s brand new. I would rather have something older that’s a bit more special in my eye. So no to a new Ford kuga but yes to a 2 door Range Rover. I see beauty in subtle classic styling. Again just my opinion.

Olivergt

2,293 posts

112 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
When you get out of your car and walk off, do you:

A) Take a quick look back at it.
B) Just keep walking.

For example:

When I get out of our 2006 Santa Fe, it get's locked and I walk off... = B, not beautiful

When I get out of our 1988 7 series, it get's locked, walk off a little, take a look back just to check it's still looking good. Maybe have a chat with a complete stranger about how nice it is... = A, beautiful.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
If it's costing me money, it needs to bring me joy.

Part of that is liking how my car looks, and enjoying looking at it. If I think a car would look better after hitting a tree trunk at 40mph, then it's probably something I'm really going to struggle to want to own.

clockworks

7,818 posts

176 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
HelldogBE said:
So you wouldn't mind driving a Fiat Multipla or a SsangYong Rodius then?

Surely you're confronted everytime you get in or out, wash it or look at it on the drive. If the ugly car was half the cost to purchase and run it, I'd contemplate it over a car whose aesthetics please me. But there's people spending loads on ugly (or bad) cars, maybe beauty is in the eye of the beholder or they appreciate having a rare and unique car over a beautiful one?
If they still made the original Multipla, I'd have one. It's quirky and practical in my eyes, not exactly ugly. As it is, I'm making do with a C3 Picasso - another practical car that won't win any beauty contests.

Cars like the Rodius are ugly because some elements of the design are jarring. Same goes for the front ends of many current BMW models. Overstyled, like the designers didn't know when to put their pencils down.

Weird and quirky cars can be appealing. Same goes for women.
Ugly is just Ugly .

Chubbyross

5,019 posts

116 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
A big part of the ownership of a car for me is how it looks. It has to be unusual, aggressive, quirky or beautiful - or all of those things. I just have to enjoy looking at it, to feel something when I see it. Most of the new hypercars these days are aggressive but I feel nothing when I see them. When I look at a Miura, however, it makes me happy that I’ve seen it. My day just gets that little bit better. Similarly, when I see something like a 911 I don’t think it’s a beautiful car but I find it satisfying to look at.

andyA700

3,452 posts

68 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
I would replace "beauty" with "aesthetic", because I cannot remember the last time I saw a really beautiful car, but lots which are aesthetically pleasing or pretty. I have an Alfa GT which I think is pretty. I once owned a BMW 2002 which I thought was a really good looking car in a pale silvery green metallic. I also had a 1982 BMW E28 528i in a similar colour which looked very good.

I think these are beautiful cars.

http://www.1001moteurs.com/performance/view-BMW-28...

Also the Ferrari Dino.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GyEpXsxwiP0

ingenieur

4,653 posts

212 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
clockworks said:
HelldogBE said:
So you wouldn't mind driving a Fiat Multipla or a SsangYong Rodius then?

Surely you're confronted everytime you get in or out, wash it or look at it on the drive. If the ugly car was half the cost to purchase and run it, I'd contemplate it over a car whose aesthetics please me. But there's people spending loads on ugly (or bad) cars, maybe beauty is in the eye of the beholder or they appreciate having a rare and unique car over a beautiful one?
If they still made the original Multipla, I'd have one. It's quirky and practical in my eyes, not exactly ugly. As it is, I'm making do with a C3 Picasso - another practical car that won't win any beauty contests.

Cars like the Rodius are ugly because some elements of the design are jarring. Same goes for the front ends of many current BMW models. Overstyled, like the designers didn't know when to put their pencils down.

Weird and quirky cars can be appealing. Same goes for women.
Ugly is just Ugly .
The designer of the Mclaren F1 (and a couple of newer models) commented that he didn't believe there had been a conversation where all the designers met to contemplate the overall design of the complete car. To him it looked as though many of the parts had been designed in isolation and then brought together much too late and forced to fit producing an overall incoherent design. Have to say I agree... and I like BMWs.

CrippsCorner

3,395 posts

212 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
I think it's about desirability as well. If I see something I like the look of, it's makes me want to own it, so i can look at it more often!

cobra kid

Original Poster:

5,628 posts

271 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
Good replies.

I guess it boils down to;

To look at the car, or to be looked at whilst driving it.

ingenieur

4,653 posts

212 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
To answer your question philosophically man regards beauty much like (or precisely like) a value similar to goodness or truth. So when we see something which should be beautiful but isn't we get a bit upset.

andyA700

3,452 posts

68 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
ingenieur said:
To answer your question philosophically man regards beauty much like (or precisely like) a value similar to goodness or truth. So when we see something which should be beautiful but isn't we get a bit upset.
The Aston Martin Lagonda?

ingenieur

4,653 posts

212 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all
andyA700 said:
ingenieur said:
To answer your question philosophically man regards beauty much like (or precisely like) a value similar to goodness or truth. So when we see something which should be beautiful but isn't we get a bit upset.
The Aston Martin Lagonda?
That particular example is more of an ugly child though isn't it. Adorable despite a certain asymmetrical sort of appearance.

samoht

7,325 posts

177 months

Friday 25th February 2022
quotequote all

For me, it's most often when I finish paying another £100 for a tank of super unleaded, walk out of the shop and back across the filling station forecourt to my RX-7, sat under the harsh lights of the canopy. As soon as I'm walking back towards the car, seeing it small, lithe and purposeful in front of me, the cost of the fuel just evaporates from my mind.