Your Perfect 3-Car Driveway for c.£50k
Your Perfect 3-Car Driveway for c.£50k
Author
Discussion

Fiisch

Original Poster:

278 posts

159 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
TL;DR - THE RULES

Can you build a driveway more interesting than middle-England for the price of a mid-range German SUV?

  • Car 1 (mandatory) - The Family car. Reliable, well-equipped, something that the wife would be happy driving and that you'd be happy to undertake long journeys in with a full load; 30+mpg;
  • Car 2 (mandatory) - The Commuter. Bulletproof reliability, fun, 40+mpg;
  • Car 3 (optional) - The Toy. No limits on the car, but the cost to buy it cannot exceed either the Family Car nor the Commuter. You can forego Car 3 if you think one of the other cars will scratch the middle-aged-man-re-living-his-youth itch.
Budget = £50k
Spouse Mood = Somewhat irked. They've grown tired of your silly purchases, they've lived through the MOT failures, the breakdowns, the brake fluid spilled all over the driveway, so the 175k mile, Cat S write-off Audi RS4 for the family car is firmly off the table.

Each car in isolation has to at least hint that the fact it's owned by a petrolhead and offer an element of driving enjoyment.

BACKGROUND - A MIDDLE AGED RAMBLE

I have become utterly obsessed in recent months with owning different cars to perform different functions, and I wonder if this is the pre-cursor every man experiences on their way to a mid-life crisis that ultimately leads them to buy a classic car of some description. I've followed the typical petrolhead path - progressively more expensive and more powerful cars since I passed my test as funds/insurance premiums would allow, subsequently curtailed by mortgages, children and other detritus that gets in the way of me owning a supercar... (God, I hope my wife never reads this).

I've also become increasingly cynical about how I spend my hard-earned cash - I lust after the latest M3 and the Audi RS6 as perfect do-it-all, family car daily drivers, and yet I don't think I could ever stomach the monthlies a new one would attract, even if my boss were to offer me a triple promotion on Monday, and even if he did, I worry about how I would react the first time one of my daughters left a muddy footprint on the back of one of the Recaros.

I have endured a driveway crisis over the last 2 years since daughter #2 was born - I've finally landed on what I think is a reasonable formula and compromise, and our German SUV was sent off to We Buy Any Car last week. I've decided that the car that satiates my petrolhead passion simply can't be the one I put my kids in, or the one I use regularly, because I'm simply too precious about car park dings and the like.

Interested to see what the hive PH mind would buy in these circumstances, if powerfully-built director bonuses were off the table smile



Edited by Fiisch on Saturday 26th February 22:46


Edited by Fiisch on Saturday 26th February 22:46


Edited by Fiisch on Saturday 26th February 22:47


Edited by Fiisch on Sunday 27th February 12:12

Royal Jelly

3,985 posts

229 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Given the age constraints there, I can’t think of any combo that wouldn’t bore me to tears.

Remove those and it gets interesting..

Oh twaddy

287 posts

220 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Royal Jelly said:
Given the age constraints there, I can’t think of any combo that wouldn’t bore me to tears.
^ that precisely!

Genuinely interested to see therefore what suggestions come up because not suggesting it can’t be done but suspect the two mandatory cars won’t float my particular boat at any rate.

Watches intently…

Dynion Araf Uchaf

5,202 posts

254 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Hyundai i20N
Nissan Xtrail
Ford Ka.

Magnum 475

4,199 posts

163 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Our current driveway almost fits, except for the age restrictions.

Mrs Magnum: BMW 220i Active Tourer, now 6 years old, bought 2 years old. We’ll keep this until it’s more cost effective to change.

My commuting wagon: BMW 330i (F30), now just past 5 years old. Again, will be kept until it’s more cost effective to replace it than to keep it.

Toy: 987S 3.2. This one is a problem. It only has two seats, and we have 2 young kids. May get changed simply to prevent endless arguments about whose turn it is to go in daddy’s car! Thinking 997.2S if / when the crazy prices come back down to a more normal level.

shirt

25,564 posts

232 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Royal Jelly said:
Given the age constraints there, I can’t think of any combo that wouldn’t bore me to tears.

Remove those and it gets interesting..
This.

Gad-Westy

16,666 posts

244 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Interesting challenge!

Skoda superb 280 estate £20k (might be tricky)
VW Up GTi £15k
S1/2 Elise £15k




Smallblock1

28 posts

123 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
On a very similar theme my present garage:
21 plate S Max Diesel, un PC but an excellent family motor for the wife
15 plate Gen 2 Mini JCW Convertible black line, my daily, I love it and don’t care what anyone thinks
Toy, 94 C4 Corvette 23k on the clock and mint, V8 flavoured Marmite.

Detest SUV’s, was forced to take a Sportage hire car last week what tediously dull machine felt huge but far smaller inside than you’d think, high load lip so poor access. What people see in this rubbish is beyond me.

The spinner of plates

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
shirt said:
Royal Jelly said:
Given the age constraints there, I can’t think of any combo that wouldn’t bore me to tears.

Remove those and it gets interesting..
This.
Agree again.

Remove the age restrictions and a fantastic 3 car driveway can be had for half your budget.

If you gave me a quarter of the budget and no age restrictions I’d have something more interesting to me than the OP.

Do cars over 5 years spontaneously combust?!?
<looks nervously at 22 year old sports car in the garage and 15 year old daily driver…>

Cars are machines. Maintain them. Repair them. Replace worn bits. I’m pretty sure if you do this, they sort of keep working.

Edited by The spinner of plates on Sunday 27th February 07:47

JAMSXR

1,853 posts

78 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
I was in a similar situation, looking at 2 or 3 cars, but as my business miles are low I decided to combine the latter two. With a young family and other hobbies/priorities, I don’t really have time for 3 cars.

I would maybe start with these..

Family - Kia Sportage
Commute - Golf
Fun - lotus Elise, M3, C63 6.2, Caymen, etc..

Edited by JAMSXR on Sunday 27th February 07:52

keo

3,042 posts

201 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
I only need two. Cheap diesel for work and spend the rest on the best Lotus Elise I could find.

Bill

58,931 posts

286 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Prepare for heresy...

What's the toy car for? Realistically, with two young kids and a grumpy ( wink ) wife, when are you going to use it?

So get a family estate - Octavia VRS or Golf R

Commute in something interesting that has 4 seats, life's too short to worry about MPG BTW - Mustang, XK, Suzuki Swift, convertible of some ilk depending on what you call fun. And be grateful you only have two kids...

And then get a pushbike (or n+1 bikes). It's fun, you can go fast without risking your licence and it's good for you so you can go out in your own or with mates guilt free. thumbup

griffsomething

417 posts

192 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Family wagon = Golf R estate - £22k
Commuter = MINI Cooper - £14k
Toy = BMW E46 M3 - £14k

SFTWend

1,468 posts

106 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Slightly newer versions of mine would probably meet the criteria;

Merc C class wagon. Petrol. Nice comfy drive for family and dog.

Alfa Giulietta. Petrol. Quite sporty and economical.

TVR Griffith. Fantastic fun but rarely used in winter so have been considering trading this and the Alfa for a modern and useable sports car.

JAMSXR

1,853 posts

78 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Bill said:
Prepare for heresy...

What's the toy car for? Realistically, with two young kids and a grumpy ( wink ) wife, when are you going to use it?

So get a family estate - Octavia VRS or Golf R

Commute in something interesting that has 4 seats, life's too short to worry about MPG BTW - Mustang, XK, Suzuki Swift, convertible of some ilk depending on what you call fun. And be grateful you only have two kids...

And then get a pushbike (or n+1 bikes). It's fun, you can go fast without risking your licence and it's good for you so you can go out in your own or with mates guilt free. thumbup
This is my approach (with the motorbikes gone) but now I have 4 push bikes… all acquired before the baby arrived, now I hardly have time to use 1!


Edited by JAMSXR on Sunday 27th February 08:34

Axe wound

1,188 posts

132 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
I'd use the £50k to pay for a divorce and then drive what I want.

Tickle

6,545 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Audi All-road
Up! GTI
Elise S1

Fiisch

Original Poster:

278 posts

159 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Removed the age restrictions by popular demand - I guess I was trying to avoid people opting for very expensive cars that have been hit by depreciation - e.g.: RS6 + M3 for family and commuter, which would be epic, but come with similarly epic running and maintenance costs..!

Fiisch

Original Poster:

278 posts

159 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Bill said:
Prepare for heresy...

What's the toy car for? Realistically, with two young kids and a grumpy ( wink ) wife, when are you going to use it?

So get a family estate - Octavia VRS or Golf R

Commute in something interesting that has 4 seats, life's too short to worry about MPG BTW - Mustang, XK, Suzuki Swift, convertible of some ilk depending on what you call fun. And be grateful you only have two kids...

And then get a pushbike (or n+1 bikes). It's fun, you can go fast without risking your licence and it's good for you so you can go out in your own or with mates guilt free. thumbup
Haha don't I've been grappling with this for awhile! Realistically, you're right and the toy is a total waste of money, however:

  • As a petrolhead, it's nice to fawn over something with a socket wrench and an oily rag - something that doesn't need to be left in tight car parks filled with careless parents with over-sized SUVs, can be polished to within an inch of it's life and only used on bone-dry, sunny days;
  • I'd like to buy at least one car with no compromises - I love my old JDM classics, but even I have to concede using one daily becomes a nightmare very quickly;
  • Whilst the fun family cars - Octavia VRS/Golf R - are brilliant cars, they don't really satiate the petrolhead itch. I ran an Octy vRS for 4 years and whilst it was a brilliant car, I never once got the urge to drive it just for the pleasure of driving on a perfect day such as today..!

brillomaster

1,913 posts

201 months

Monday 28th February 2022
quotequote all
£50grand for 3 cars!?! Well in that case, probably be

Bmw 330d saloon/estate for commute/ touring
Bmw 120i hatch for the wife/short journeys
Porsche boxster for weekends.

Could probably have that for £30k easily enough, so just get newer versions to spend the extra £20k.