Non fault accident query.
Non fault accident query.
Author
Discussion

jmsgld

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

207 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
Non fault accident to my 2001 986S

The nearside headlamp is damaged and being replaced. The offside headlamp is 21 years old and as such rather faded.

I had hoped that they came in pairs and they would replace both, however the insurance company will only cover the damaged one, leaving the car looking a little odd.

I can entirely see their point, but seems a little harsh that I need to shell out after a non fault accident. I made my the point but the insurers weren't having any of it.

Any option other than to buy a used headlamp / pair?

Thanks



kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
Can you not polish the lens?

HasToBeV8

163 posts

119 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
I can absolutely see your point and in the same position I'd be asking exactly the same. However I can see the insurer's argument too.

Have you considered trying to restore your good lens? The 3M kit costs about £20 and a couple of hours of your time (you will need a drill too). On my 19 year old car it made quite a big difference. Not 100% brand new looking if you look closely, but a lot better than it was and from a distance they do look much smarter (and the visibility is definitely clearer/brighter at night).

Maybe something worth a try before shelling out on what is probably quite an expensive part? I'd watch the videos on youtube rather than relying on the instructions would be a tip if you do!

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0078IHJ1K/ref=cm_sw_e...

Scrump

23,948 posts

189 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
I have a 996 of similar vintage and although restoring the headlights makes a vast improvement, my experience is that they do not come back ‘as good as new’.
It is shame your other headlight wasn’t also damaged in the accident.

jmsgld

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

207 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
I did wet and dry and then mop the headlights a couple of years ago and they looked great for a while, then gradually faded again...

I guess I might need some kind of u/v protection?

I might ask the bodyshop to do it whilst they have the car

Cold

16,750 posts

121 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
Why not suggest that they replace your broken headlight with a used part? Lower cost for them, a matching pair for you. Win win. thumbup

Panamax

10,127 posts

65 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
Cold said:
Why not suggest that they replace your broken headlight with a used part? Lower cost for them, a matching pair for you. Win win. thumbup
Yup, that's the best I could think of.

blue_haddock

5,096 posts

98 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
replacing a non damaged but hazy light with a brand new one would be betterment so you have zero chance of that happening.

Like if they paint the wing and bonnet and then the rest of the paint work looks faded, they wont give it a full respray for you.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
jmsgld said:
I can entirely see their point, but seems a little harsh that I need to shell out after a non fault accident. I made my the point but the insurers weren't having any of it.
The insurance isn't going to pay for a partial restoration of your car to remove age related deterioration elsewhere. The exception would be a reasonable expectation to colour match to faded paint, but they're not going to start buying replacement parts. smile

RazerSauber

2,947 posts

91 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
You don't "have" to pay out. You're choosing to because the car looks odd. I don't think you'd be particularly happy if the insurers only paid for a headlamp that's in the same condition as your existing one. If you had a scuffed wheel and got a new one, you can hardly expect your insurer to foot the bill for a new set all round, as well as probably a set of tyres.

jmsgld

Original Poster:

1,085 posts

207 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
Yeah, when you think it through it is fair enough.

I'll get it polished / do it myself and see how it looks, if it looks too odd I'll pick up a used pair.

The list price is £900 odd + VAT for a new one from porsche, interestingly they are £480 each from Design 911, so approx 20% cheaper for the pair than the single from porsche.

I wonder if the insurance company would pay for those instead? or would they just want to buy one from them...

mmm-five

12,400 posts

315 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
If you know you can do it cheaper yourself, then why not politely ask the insurer whether they'd like to make a payment in lieu of repair?

ResQ1

99 posts

79 months

Monday 7th March 2022
quotequote all
See all the replies above,

If only one headlight was damaged in the accident then the insurer, can / will only replace one, especially if its a non fault accident as by law they (and you) have to mitigate the loss, i.e keep costs to a minimum and act as if you were not insured,

If they know that a head light is available at half the cost from one supplier than another, then if you were paying the bill yourself, you would expect them to use the cheaper supplier.