What is your breaking point on fuel price
What is your breaking point on fuel price
Author
Discussion

Numpty with honours

Original Poster:

218 posts

114 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
At what price per litre, or what event do you regard it sufficient to abandon ICE car and switch to EV or indeed abandon car ownership altogether

I think it is difficult because as it rises there is an acceptance of the figure and the incremental increase is probably never enough to make you explode in rage and make the change

When I see evidence that high-end cars are being disposed of because of the cost of fuel. Or high-end new cars having to be heavily discounted because of fuel costs would be my tipping point - because then depreciation will be wild and that is by far the biggest cost of car ownership.

Whilst we may wince at the cost per litre and see perhaps yearly expenditure on petrol rise from say £2,250 ( 12,000 miles per annum at 30 MPG @ £1.25 per litre with 4.5 litres to a gallon) to £3,600 ( 12,000 miles per annum at 30 MPG @ £2 per litre with 4.5 litres to a gallon) that increase of £1,350 is dwarfed by depreciation especially if a new model is introduced.

To answer my question, I think it when depreciation starts to increase from around 20% year on year to 35% year on year

WonkeyDonkey

2,592 posts

134 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
Honestly I'll probably end up being taken hostage by prices. I still need to get to work and can't afford an electric car. The ones I could afford (old leaf or zoe) would induce severe range anxiety on the commute home!

Coupled with the fact that if fuel prices got ridiculous then I can only imagine any 2nd hand electric car will be commanding a pretty premium.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
I work from home and looking at my last MOT I am averaging about 400 miles a month. I drive a car that does an easy 55MPG so that works out at around 7.3 gallons or 33 litres.

I think about £3 a litre is the point where I start get annoyed, but honestly if it was £5 a litre I would still drive as there is little alternative.

2gins

2,861 posts

193 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
It depends entirely on how much my salary is going up by.

brillomaster

1,912 posts

201 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
The cheapest car is the one you have. I might baulk if diesel was £3 a litre, but even then its still way cheaper to spend £150 a month filling up compared to several thousand pounds swapping to an ev.

But if diesel prices go up, id expect electricity prices to go up too, so savings from an ev will likely be negated anyways.

What is more likely to happen is me working another day from home each week, only going in 2 days a week, and save another 20% of time spent commuting.

Already sadly suspect my next car will be a boring 2 litre diesel rather than the 3 litre diesel i drive now 😕

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
People are stupid and beyond very basic counting and arithmetic all but innumerate, so they are usually far more sensitive to day to day costs than longer term costs like depreciation.

The obsession with fuel economy and to a lesser extend RFL has always been foolish; unless you're buying your car for buttons and nursing it along via DIY by far and away the biggest cost of any new or new-ish car is depreciation and it always has been, you just don't see it until it's time tochange cars.

To answer the question petrol and diesel could quadruple in price and it'd still be cheaper to drive than use public transport, and that's without taking into account the time and other benefits of personal transport.

Unfortunately more expensive fuel is already encouraging the ditherers and dodderers to drive even more slowly than before, my fear is that even if this does go back to normal it'll be the same as the fuel strikes when everyone started crawling around overnight and never went back to driving properly when the "crisis" was over.

DodgyGeezer

49,394 posts

221 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
our car's mpgs go

high 20's (Challenger - 3,000ish miles p/a)
mid 30's (SLC - 8,000ish miles p/a)
low 40's (Superb - 2,000ish miles p/a)

so really (IMO) not a whole lot of point in replacing purely on fuel costs

GetCarter

31,332 posts

310 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
I logged how many miles I did per day for a month, and in 26 of the days I did +/- 30

(I work from home)

So I bought a PHEV which gives me 33 miles in EV, but lets me use ICE when I need it.

EV charger being installed this week (£600 in grants), car arrives next month.

We'll see. Maths says I'll not spend £3k a year in petrol at todays prices... goodness knows what it'll be in 6 months.

Meanwhile, looking fwd to 640 Nm torque!


Edited by GetCarter on Tuesday 8th March 15:09

kambites

71,709 posts

252 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
I reckon it would be somewhere around £3 per litre before we'd sell (or more likely scrap) the family car for an EV. Much higher for the Elise.

Edited by kambites on Tuesday 8th March 15:26

Canon_Fodder

1,775 posts

94 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
Had an email from EDF today saying my elecy bill will be going up 54% from April 1st. weeping


r1ch

2,956 posts

227 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
It would have to go quite high, maybe £4-5. I have an economical ICE car and my commute is very short. I could car share if needed too so I'm lucky I suppose in that with my current circumstances it doesn't really effect me. Of course things can always change for the worse, you never know.

Alex_225

7,890 posts

232 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
The cost of actually buying an EV that suits what I need vs keeping my diesel car (42mpg) for the driving I need means fuel prices would have to go even higher.

I do about 900 miles a month so not mega compared to sum but depending on the car I use it costs enough. But I do those miles roughly 240 miles at a time.

The cost of paying off the amount needed to buy a decent EV, I'm better off with diesel for a while yet.

Limpet

6,629 posts

192 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
Numpty with honours said:
At what price per litre, or what event do you regard it sufficient to abandon ICE car and switch to EV
Thing is, EV running costs are going up just like those of combustion cars, albeit from a lower base. That said, I believe they will go up quicker as adoption moves towards critical mass, and the various exemptions and tax breaks they currently enjoy become unaffordable and expire.

Electricity is a lot more expensive than it was 6 months ago, and it will be a lot more expensive in 6 months than it is now. Lots of households will be paying £300+ a month for energy, if they aren't already. And that's before they plug a car in every night.

I'm not anti EV, but viewed as an escape from the spiralling running costs of conventional cars, they are a short term fix at best. Everything's going nuts.

LosingGrip

8,919 posts

190 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
I can't use an EV. Haven't got anywhere to charge it up at home (flat and no power in the garage).

I have to continue to drive to get to work. Although I could cycle at the moment, I'll be moving offices soon and it wont be possible to cycle (well I could but it would take forever!).

UTH

12,423 posts

209 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
I have no idea what my breaking point would be. What I do know is that my excitement at getting my 'summer' Corvette out of hibernation is being very much tainted by the fact it'll no doubt cost me £150+ to fill it, and if I want to have any sort of actual fun driving it for more than 5 mins, that £150 won't last very long.

It really is depressing to have to factor in the actual fact it's £150 to enjoy the car for the day (or logic to that effect)

delta0

2,553 posts

137 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
Limpet said:
Thing is, EV running costs are going up just like those of combustion cars, albeit from a lower base. That said, I believe they will go up quicker as adoption moves towards critical mass, and the various exemptions and tax breaks they currently enjoy become unaffordable and expire.

Electricity is a lot more expensive than it was 6 months ago, and it will be a lot more expensive in 6 months than it is now. Lots of households will be paying £300+ a month for energy, if they aren't already. And that's before they plug a car in every night.

I'm not anti EV, but viewed as an escape from the spiralling running costs of conventional cars, they are a short term fix at best. Everything's going nuts.
It’s a heck of a lot cheaper than petrol though. If you are running a special EV rate like Octopus you are charging at 7.5p/kWh and a lot of chargers in supermarkets are free. If it gets prohibitively expensive then people will just put up solar panels.

Hoofy

80,183 posts

313 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
Thing is, recent events have made me think about my energy use. Not necessarily for the green aspect (I have a 20 year old diesel and a car that rarely sees over 20mpg) but because of who benefits from my money when I fill up at the petrol station.

Scottish Power claim to be 100% renewable when it comes to electricity. Windfarms, according to their website. Now, I don't know how my electricity supply changes if I jump from Scottish Power to Eon but in theory, fuelling a car that doesn't rely on Russia or Saudi Arabia is quite appealing.

And eventually with a new form of road tax (yes, yes, it's VED not road tax) when everyone is driving EVs and I'm still paying the same amount to fuel an EV as I would an ICE car, knowing that some despot can't benefit from my money is very appealing.

Joey Deacon said:
as there is little alternative.
Yep.

Brett748

977 posts

197 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
If fuel increased to £3 it would cost me an extra £3,500 ish for my 10,000 miles a year in my C63. So say £300 a month.

I own my C63 outright and depreciation is minimal (maybe fuel prices will cause depreciation, but there will always be a market for performance cars).

So I’d have a choice between buying a car I don’t like for £300 a month to be in broadly the same net position but I’d be less happy.

I think fuel prices, temporarily will be a bitter pill we have to swallow.

If fuel is £3 a litre long term unless you are a high net worth individual our living standards will drop massively because inflation would be astronomical. Even this is out of our hands so it is pointless worry about it.

Pica-Pica

16,727 posts

115 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
The point at which the annual cost for fuel begins to catch up with the (much larger) annual depreciation.

bloomen

10,282 posts

190 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
Almost all my mileage is leisure. I don't really need to go anywhere other than to buy food. So I'll just go to fewer and fewer places for fun if it becomes truly ball breaking.

I do feel for the millions who have no alternative but the car for commuting.