Credit hire court case
Author
Discussion

Linda78221

Original Poster:

9 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Long story short me and my son were rear ended my car was a Volvo XC90.

First time accident (naive) so my insurance automatically transferred me over to a credit hire (which I didn’t know) and dropped a expensive car.

I then cancelled and said I want to cheapest car possible which they resent around 200£ a day from 500£ a day (I have email proof too so tried to keep costs minimum).

Looking however at the small print it says I was classed as Impecuniosity.
I did have savings (could probably afford it but I planned to use it for my pension)or use credit -but why should I be out of pocket for something that wasnt my fault.

This is going to Court now .

If they do ask for bank statements would this be a problem if I don’t provide this ?

Would it look bad if I’m not classed as Impecuniosity however the car I hired was a lower model and cheaper one?

Otherside not accepting fault for everything

Funk

27,813 posts

240 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Linda78221 said:
Long story short me and my son were rear ended my car was a Volvo XC90.

First time accident (naive) so my insurance automatically transferred me over to a credit hire (which I didn’t know) and dropped a expensive car.

I then cancelled and said I want to cheapest car possible which they resent around 200£ a day from 500£ a day (I have email proof too so tried to keep costs minimum).

Looking however at the small print it says I was classed as Impecuniosity.
I did have savings (could probably afford it but I planned to use it for my pension)or use credit -but why should I be out of pocket for something that wasnt my fault.

This is going to Court now .

If they do ask for bank statements would this be a problem if I don’t provide this ?

Would it look bad if I’m not classed as Impecuniosity however the car I hired was a lower model and cheaper one?

Otherside not accepting fault for everything
I'm not 100% clear what it is you're saying/asking? It feels like there's a chunk of information missing.

Are you saying you've found yourself on the hook for an expensive (or less expensive in the end) hire car and the other person's insurance are refusing to pay the charges your insurers have run up by providing said hire car?

Muzzer79

13,254 posts

218 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Linda78221 said:
Long story short me and my son were rear ended my car was a Volvo XC90.

First time accident (naive) so my insurance automatically transferred me over to a credit hire (which I didn’t know) and dropped a expensive car.

I then cancelled and said I want to cheapest car possible which they resent around 200£ a day from 500£ a day (I have email proof too so tried to keep costs minimum).

Looking however at the small print it says I was classed as Impecuniosity.
I did have savings (could probably afford it but I planned to use it for my pension)or use credit -but why should I be out of pocket for something that wasnt my fault.

This is going to Court now .

If they do ask for bank statements would this be a problem if I don’t provide this ?

Would it look bad if I’m not classed as Impecuniosity however the car I hired was a lower model and cheaper one?

Otherside not accepting fault for everything
Who or what is classing you/your situation as 'Impecuniosity'?

That literally means the condition of being extremely poor, so it's an odd thing to cite.

Linda78221

Original Poster:

9 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
My side is taking at fault to court . As they Denied the fault and saying credit hire rate too high . In small print when you sign a credit hire agreement it’s you can’t pay for it yourself so classes as impecuous. Anybody with experience dealt with a credit hire claim here?

Olivergt

2,288 posts

112 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
So, to be clear.

Your Insurance company is taking the other insurance company to court?

If that is the case, then I don't see that you have anything to worry about as no one is taking you to court, so you have no case to answer.

If you got rear ended, then highly unlikely they will be able to get out of being at fault, unless there is more to this story.


cmvtec

2,188 posts

112 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
From what I can work out in your post, and personal experience, if it actually goes to court, you would be asked if you could afford to rent a car, or had another car you would be able to use whilst yours was being repaired.

I don't know many people who have the cash on the hip to pay for extended vehicle rental, as well as holding deposit etc.


Linda78221

Original Poster:

9 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
No other car to use as have to go work daily. I did have large saving tho which was planning to use to purchase a new home and put in pension. There is also a personal injury claim

Linda78221

Original Poster:

9 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Also anybody know what gta rates are?

KungFuPanda

4,655 posts

201 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
You have a continuing duty to mitigate your losses. If you had the funds to pay for spot hire rates rather than (much higher) credit hire rates, you were expected to do so and claim it back at a later stage. Ultimately, you wouldn't have been out of pocket.

You also have a duty to provide information in the pursuance of your claim for credit hire if proceedings are issued. You thereof must disclose details of your finances. If you don't you are at risk of the hire company going after you themselves for the hire charges as your actions would have prejudiced their position to make a successful recovery.

If you weren't impecunious, maybe the Court will find that you should have hired the car yourself rather than use the inflated costs of a credit hire company. Who knows?

bencollins4

1,242 posts

237 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Pretty sure your bank balance is not considered as to your eligibility for credit hire! Let them fight it out but nothing to do with you and it relates to quantum and sounds like you did what you could to keep the costs down.

Linda78221

Original Poster:

9 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
However why should we folk out the costs ? Sure I don’t want to be out of pocket even if I could afford it. Also as I wrote I chose a cheaper vehicle not like for like .

Funk

27,813 posts

240 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
I think there's also evidence to show you argued with your own insurers as to the costs of the hire car they tried to give you.

Chucklehead

2,855 posts

239 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Linda78221 said:
Also anybody know what gta rates are?
https://www.gtacredithire.com/rates/car-hire/

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
It does seem like there's information missing.

Smurfsarepeopletoo

1,022 posts

88 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Linda78221 said:
However why should we folk out the costs ? Sure I don’t want to be out of pocket even if I could afford it. Also as I wrote I chose a cheaper vehicle not like for like .
Its down to you to mitigate the costs of the claim, if you had substantial savings, then you could have hired a small vehicle for the duration of either the repairs, or until you were paid out, and then you would have been able to claim those costs back from the other drivers insurers.

Even though you asked for a smaller cheaper vehicle, that cost will still be alot higher than if you were to hire it yourself, and technically you wouldnt be out of pocket, as you can mitigate the cost of hiring your own vehicle, and therefore claim it back.



surveyor

18,707 posts

215 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Smurfsarepeopletoo said:
Linda78221 said:
However why should we folk out the costs ? Sure I don’t want to be out of pocket even if I could afford it. Also as I wrote I chose a cheaper vehicle not like for like .
Its down to you to mitigate the costs of the claim, if you had substantial savings, then you could have hired a small vehicle for the duration of either the repairs, or until you were paid out, and then you would have been able to claim those costs back from the other drivers insurers.

Even though you asked for a smaller cheaper vehicle, that cost will still be alot higher than if you were to hire it yourself, and technically you wouldnt be out of pocket, as you can mitigate the cost of hiring your own vehicle, and therefore claim it back.
I always find this argument almost fanciful.

OP has presumably been driven into, not something he invited for. And by the sounds of it injured in some way.

The OP has savings, but presumably requires a car to get to work, and may have a family etc. In any case, if someone has decided to crash into your Bentley, which you have paid or are paying a lot of money, do you really want to drive a Vauxhall Corsa around?

Equally, if you have savings, why should the innocent driver be expected to be out of the pocket for hundreds or thousands of pounds while the third-party insurer decides to reimburse them?

Obviously, there is being reasonable and then the credit hire folks who take the mick, but I understood there were agreed rates for this sort of thing nowadays.


anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
You will need to explain why you need a vehicle of similar size (not hard really), and then also explain why you couldn't spend X amount of money on purchasing another one instead of hiring it. (Your son was going to get married right? And he was planning to buy a house for which you were going to lend him the deposit right? (Something like that basically)

Smurfsarepeopletoo

1,022 posts

88 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
surveyor said:
I always find this argument almost fanciful.

OP has presumably been driven into, not something he invited for. And by the sounds of it injured in some way.

The OP has savings, but presumably requires a car to get to work, and may have a family etc. In any case, if someone has decided to crash into your Bentley, which you have paid or are paying a lot of money, do you really want to drive a Vauxhall Corsa around?

Equally, if you have savings, why should the innocent driver be expected to be out of the pocket for hundreds or thousands of pounds while the third-party insurer decides to reimburse them?

Obviously, there is being reasonable and then the credit hire folks who take the mick, but I understood there were agreed rates for this sort of thing nowadays.
Tbh its a bit of a can of worms, a Bentley would be a different scenario, and there are other questions regarding what you use the vehicle for, and stuff like that, but its all about justifying costs.

Ultimately, this situation is that the customer didnt need a Similar sized vehicle, and he has the means to hire a small vehicle for the duration, and he has said it wouldnt impact him as the money is for his pension.

So he would have been asked if he has the means to hire his own vehicle, if he said yes and the hire company still gave him one, then he has nothing to worry about, as they should have refused a hire, and sent back to the insurers to provide a courtesy car, or the customer has said he didnt have the means, and has then signed paperwork to that effect, in which case, he has lied to get a vehicle, and has not agreed to mitigate the costs.

Its a similar principle to being in an accident in central London after the last train, and then booking the penthouse at the ritz, and having a 3 course meal there, instead of booking a travelodge and eating there, its all about justifying why the other drivers insurers should pay £200 a day, instead of £40 a day, just because you dont want to pay upfront and claim it back.

I used to work in credit hire, and people also think that if they drove a 15 year old 5 series, they should be entitled to a brand new 5 series as a replacement.

catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
My understanding of the credit hire agreement from memory, is that you are declaring that you can't afford to hire a car yourself. Not wanting to, while sitting on a pile of money at the same time doesn't qualify.

The third party Insurer is entitled to say that you could have hired a car yourself for say, £50 a day, instead of expecting them to be on the hook for £200 a day. A not unreasonable point of view.

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Bit of googling does appear to support the view that if you had the funds & were able to afford to hire a suitable vehicle yourself then you should have done that & then claimed to be reimbursed instead of allowing yourself to enter a more expensive credit hire agreement.

The other party's insurers will argue that as you had the funds the credit hire charges they are being asked to pay are excessive & they are only prepared to offer a 'spot hire' rate for the period you had the hire car.

Potentially leaving you with the rest of the bill.

https://brodies.com/insights/insurance-and-risk/ro...
and
https://7hs.co.uk/pleading-impecuniosity/

Which suggests to me that someone has an accident, follows the advice of their insurers who they reasonably expect will guide them & gets their trousers pulled down as a result.
Unless you've had a lot of accidents it's unlikely you would be aware of all this.
I stand to be corrected, but if that is the reality it sucks & someone's making a lot of money out of other people's misfortune.