Resistance against EVs
Author
Discussion

HC1999

Original Poster:

6 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Hi everyone,

My name is Harris and I am a student Journalist in my Hons year at University. I am currently creating a website all about the future of motoring. For a specific feature I am writing on the adoption of electric vehicles among car enthusaists, I am interested in getting the perspectives of traditional internal combustion engined car enthusiasts on electric cars.

In particular I want to explore the reasons behind many car enthusiasts being resistant to the change, including:

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?

Thanks for taking the time to read my request and I would be so grateful if a few of you were able to chime in and share your views and opinions.

Kind regards
Harris

Hoofy

80,180 posts

313 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
The sound. I was overtaken by a Taycan the other day. Looked fantastic. Really shifted. Sounded like a milk float on steroids or possibly a Scalextric. Bit naff really.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
Amazing, on paper at least.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
Range, ability to charge them in more places, standardisation of charging. Sounds like a massive faff at the moment. I can just drive any ICE car into any garage and providing I don't look at the price, I can fill up. And in 5 minutes. I occasionally forget to charge my phone and leave the house with 30% so I grab a battery pack. You're buggered if you forget to charge your car overnight and need to get to work in the morning! I'm more interested in hybrids because of this.

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
Cringeworthy. biggrin We'll just have to suck it up once we're not allowed ICE cars.

Dynion Araf Uchaf

5,202 posts

254 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?

Its the lack of a gearbox on an EV I don't really like. The noise and convenience of an ICE car is also better

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?

Great cars, but very very expensive. range is still an issue as is charging capability. Although TESLA appears to be owned by a loon. And we shouldnt be going anywhere near autonomous drive.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
A EV SUV which can tow 1500kgs for 300 miles without needing a recharge

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
Pointless.

Zilla

74 posts

134 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Funny enough, I was having a discussion about this at work today.

The conclusion we came to is:
EV is great for day to day, family car.
Petrol is required for supercars/sports cars. Supercars are all about theatre. The sounds, smell, exhaust flames, is about making it a visceral experience.
Deisel for heavy goods. Batteries cannot complete due to the additional weight required which would take away from the amnount of capactiy a lorry can carry.

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
Sounds, smell, the visceral experience.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
Most are one trick ponies, great in a straight line wink They are getting there though and the Taycan Turbo is excellent, aprat from the name Turbo, and the lack of sound.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
Sub 5 minute charging from a wide networkj of charges with standard interfaces

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
Just no.

andy43

13,322 posts

285 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Go on then, I'll give it a go.

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one? Emotion, noise, feeling of being at one with a mechanical machine, plus you can fiddle with it properly and do 'stuff' instead of just polishing it, dominating the internet and sticking pointless chinese crap on it.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc? Great. Why not? Although if they can lower the weight by about a third it'd help.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one? Already have but charging and range is the problem. We've had EVs since 2015, Tesla since 2020, and every non-Tesla charging experience bar one 50kw charger has been rubbish. That's the one sticking point for long distance travel in the UK at the moment and I can't see it being sorted anytime soon. EVs are currently city cars full stop, ideal as second cars but for single-car households they're still stressful and not fit for purpose for those occasional long trips.

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines? BMW have been doing it for ages. Blast it out of external speakers too - it'd make low speed EV driving much safer around pedestrians.

HC1999

Original Poster:

6 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Dynion Araf Uchaf said:
What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?

Its the lack of a gearbox on an EV I don't really like. The noise and convenience of an ICE car is also better

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?

Great cars, but very very expensive. range is still an issue as is charging capability. Although TESLA appears to be owned by a loon. And we shouldnt be going anywhere near autonomous drive.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
A EV SUV which can tow 1500kgs for 300 miles without needing a recharge

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
Pointless.
Thanks very much for your response. On your gearbox point, I know that Toyota have recently filed a patent for a simulated manual gearbox for electric cars, what are your thoughts on that? A bit pointless or providing a bit more of an old fashioned connection to the car?

_Mja_

2,572 posts

206 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Hi,

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?

For me it's the noise, atmosphere, sense of occassion in something tuned for it. In normal cars it gives mechanical engagement and the ability to take satisfaction at employing mechanical sympathy whilst driving. The manual gearbox and the sense of handling the car and making the perfect gear change. The power delivery of various engines - there is a reason why CVT boxes, although much more efficient than manual or convential automatic gears never catches on - we like the imperfect perfection caused by rowing through the gears; the sense or torque and power through the rev range. Then there is the ability to tinker and perfect engines - change a cam, increase the bore, re-tune it. Keeps it interesting.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?

Yawn fest for me. All they do that is "impressive" is go fast yet you can have more fun in a Lotus elan on a B road than you'll ever have in one of those fast electric cars. They may be quick but they are far too heavy. They are not even good for the environment when you consider where the power comes from, where the materials for the batteries come from and the fact their useful life is not even a 1/5th of many ICE vehicles. We need to invest in synthetic fuels to keep older cars going: they have an infinite life with mainteance and do not require the resources to build a new leased electric car every 24 months per relevant head of population.


What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?

The drivetrain and the weight. I would only buy one if I sold my soul and wanted a day to day car I didn't give a monkeys about (& also no longer gave a stuff about the environment).

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?

A bit like Scarlett Johansson hiding away a piece of meat and two veg - a crude as that statement is my feeling.


The biggest thing I hate about electric cars is their perceived green credentials, believed and spouted only by 3 groups of people
1) their narrow minded sheep like owners who think only as far as the next lease deal.
2) the government to stimulate the economy and generate more revenue for itself
3) car manufacturers who simply build what 2) brainwashers those in group 1) smile

Dynion Araf Uchaf

5,202 posts

254 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
HC1999 said:
Thanks very much for your response. On your gearbox point, I know that Toyota have recently filed a patent for a simulated manual gearbox for electric cars, what are your thoughts on that? A bit pointless or providing a bit more of an old fashioned connection to the car?
I don't know anything about it. But I like the idea and would hope its not too gimmicky

HC1999

Original Poster:

6 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
andy43 said:
Go on then, I'll give it a go.

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one? Emotion, noise, feeling of being at one with a mechanical machine, plus you can fiddle with it properly and do 'stuff' instead of just polishing it, dominating the internet and sticking pointless chinese crap on it.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc? Great. Why not? Although if they can lower the weight by about a third it'd help.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one? Already have but charging and range is the problem. We've had EVs since 2015, Tesla since 2020, and every non-Tesla charging experience bar one 50kw charger has been rubbish. That's the one sticking point for long distance travel in the UK at the moment and I can't see it being sorted anytime soon. EVs are currently city cars full stop, ideal as second cars but for single-car households they're still stressful and not fit for purpose for those occasional long trips.

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines? BMW have been doing it for ages. Blast it out of external speakers too - it'd make low speed EV driving much safer around pedestrians.
Thanks very much for your insight Andy. Re- the sound point you made on fake engine sounds: more than just from a practical/safety perspective, do you think these synthesised noises actually add to the driving experience/vehicle connection?

Roger Irrelevant

3,400 posts

144 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
I'm not sure if my views are going to be helpful given I'm not really resistant to the change per se, but here you go anyway:

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one? - Range, availability and standardisation of refuelling.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc? - Very much in favour of the concept, I'd love a Taycan Cross Turismo for example, but wouldn't have a Tesla.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one? - Better range and/or availability and standardisation of public chargers. Being a bit cheaper wouldn't hurt either.

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines? - Naff as fk.

Triumph Man

9,652 posts

199 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
HC1999 said:
What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
Noise and character

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
I admire their performance and in the case of the Porsche, it’s engineering.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
If I was to buy an electric car, it would likely be a daily driver and therefore would need to be cheaper, and look like a normal car- not a spaceship!!

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
Ghastly fakery

Thanks for taking the time to read my request and I would be so grateful if a few of you were able to chime in and share your views and opinions.

Kind regards
Harris

Esceptico

8,897 posts

140 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Resistance against EVs? Ohm my god. Watt we don’t need is another EV thread. I just don’t have the capacitor to deal with it.

BikeSausage

754 posts

99 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
Re your specific questions, I would say that I’m open to EVs and see none of the subjects of your four questions as barriers to me adopting one.

Engine noise and loud exhausts really don’t float my boat - so I would not want to worry about manufactured sounds within EVs.

However……the single barrier for me is charging away from home. Right now, I can pretty much guarantee that I can rock up to a filling station anywhere in Europe, the US or Asia (where I have driven) and fill up within 10 minutes without any anxiety about pump availability, blocking, queuing, debit card compatibility etc. Also, If I’m staying away in a hotel or apartment, I also don’t have to worry about whether they do or don’t have an overnight charger or whether someone else has got there first. I just fill up before arriving or in the morning. I do not worry about whether I can or can not acquire petrol or diesel.

It’s all about the charging infrastructure. The rest I can adapt to.

TameRacingDriver

20,656 posts

303 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
The sound, the vibrations, the non-linear nature of the power, the ability to change gear, the effect changing gear has on cornering, the involvement, lighter weight due to not having to carry batteries, take too long to refill (charge). EVs have very few plus sides for keen drivers outside of raw speed / acceleration.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
Tesla? Meh, fridge on wheels. Would have one if my driving was purely for utility / commuting (limited mileage) though. Quiet, refined, smooth, comfortable, easy to use. In those scenarios the EV is an easy sell.

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
As my car is purely a toy, then they'd have to come up with something that actually has some soul / character. I would definitely consider one for bog standard A-B driving.

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
If they could make an electric car look, sound and feel exactly like an ICE car with a real gearbox and the sounds to match, then I would have no objection, as long as it was realistic. However, given how artificial even ICE cars sound with synthetic engine sounds piped into the cabin, I don't hold out much hope for that.

Om

2,205 posts

109 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
HC1999 said:
What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
  • The sound mainly with 5+ cylinder engines.
  • The imperfections - the fact you need a clutch and gearbox, that you have an engine with torque and power peaks. Things that as a driver you have to compensate for/work with (character and to a certain extent a challenge).
  • Having said the above I would be more than happy with a bev that had none of those imperfections, but those are some of the nonsensical reasons I like an ice car...
What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
  • Not a great deal personally. Absolute power is pretty one dimensional (at present though I am sure over time performance bevs will have other performance facets) and for me there is much more to a performance car than the ability to accelerate quickly.
What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
  • Become cheaper, lighter, improve range. Basically this will happen over time.
What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
  • Pathetic. Applies to ice engines as much as bev.
  • A bev should sound like a bev and be proud of it.
I am more than happy to have a bev at some point when they work for my usage profile and become affordable to me. At present there are many positives I can think of that make a bev preferable - quiet, smooth, cheaper to run/charge, the ability to 'fill up' at home, and I am sure others that don't spring to mind right now. This applies both to a daily car and a weekend/fun car (though I suspect the latter will take a lot longer to happen).

HC1999

Original Poster:

6 posts

56 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
HC1999 said:
Hi everyone,

My name is Harris and I am a student Journalist in my Hons year at University. I am currently creating a website all about the future of motoring. For a specific feature I am writing on the adoption of electric vehicles among car enthusaists, I am interested in getting the perspectives of traditional internal combustion engined car enthusiasts on electric cars.

In particular I want to explore the reasons behind many car enthusiasts being resistant to the change, including:

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?

Thanks for taking the time to read my request and I would be so grateful if a few of you were able to chime in and share your views and opinions.

Kind regards
Harris
Thanks everyone for these truly excellent insights into ICE enthusiast's objections to electric cars - they are exactly what I was looking for! From what I can deduce, the recurring themes appear to be that for commuter transport, you would accept them, but the lack of soul/involvement makes them little more than appliances at this stage to petrol heads like us.

I find it interesting that everyone seems to agree that the computer generated engine noise wouldn't add anything; I too feel this way about it, just the knowledge that its made up and doesn't correspond to any mechanical process sort of ruins it!

Gary C

15,374 posts

210 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all

What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?
The noise
The smell
The torque curve
A manual gearbox
Involvement in driving.

What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?
One trick ponies

What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?
Put a petrol engine in it

What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
Pointless
Now, if they were to make them have a torque curve and a gearbox smile


Slow

6,973 posts

168 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
1) What elements of an internal combustion vehicle do you prefer over an electric one?

Filling up in 2 minutes, doing 500 miles between fills, never have to think about where/when I am going to charge it, I run older vehicles so dont fancy replacing a crazy money battery which has lost capactiy.

2) What you think about electric performance cars such as Tesla, Porsche Taycan etc?

Boring, they are fun the first few times to show your mates etc then its just dull as half of the fun of driving sporty cars is the noise/feeling.

3) What would have to change about electric cars to entice you to buy one?

Batterys weighing 20kg and can be swapped out at a petrol station type of building to make charging no longer an issue. Much longer range while towing trailers. Stnadardised batterys so any car can swap batterys at the battery station.

4) What do you think about manufacturers developing sounds which mimic combustion engines?
Pointless, dont even like it on petrol engines which fake exhaust noise through the speakers.

delta0

2,553 posts

137 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
It’s noise for me. However the Nissan GTR is no longer going to be sold in Europe due to new noise regulations so ICE cars are doomed for this as well.

Mr E

23,105 posts

290 months

Monday 21st March 2022
quotequote all
The family bus has a thumping great V8. The toy is a British lightweight with no abs or power steering.

I bought an EV 4 years ago because it was a no brainer. I’ve done ~30k miles in it. I’m waiting for another one to arrive and become the main car.