What lack of servicing horrors have you seen?
What lack of servicing horrors have you seen?
Author
Discussion

Pastor Of Muppets

Original Poster:

3,876 posts

93 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
This one dropped my jaw a bit, in all my years I've rarely seen something as dumbfounding as this one. Young girl brings her car to the garage
and tells me her brake pedal is sinking to the floor and there is a bad noise coming from the front passenger side, I tell her to leave it with
me and I will have a look over it, she hands me the key and heads away with her dad who had followed her down. She told me the handbrake
was fine because that's what she used to get it to me rotate .

Anyway a bit later on I start on it, remove the wheel, unbolt the caliper and then the expletives start to fly!.

So what has happened is the pad has worn away all the friction material leaving metal to metal contact, eventually the disc and the pad backing
plate become so worn down that the pad backing plate falls through the gap between the disc and carrier and does a bunk, this then leaves the
piston in direct contact with the disc, both of them then wear down to the point where the piston pops out of the caliper and loses all the brake
fluid, pedal sinks to the floor and that then becomes the stage where she realises something is up.

This has had to have been ongoing for a considerable length of time and mileage to get to this condition, how on earth she didn't suspect
something was wrong long before this is just astonishing. Words fail me. rolleyes

Look at the difference in thickness between the two faces of the disc. The piston had lost about 5mm, past the ring where the dust cover sits.
[pic][/pic]


Rich Boy Spanner

1,895 posts

161 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
It's astonishing how many cars have grinding brakes. It's why I am against the idea of moving the MOT to 2 year intervals. People are fkwits.

EdmondDantes

356 posts

172 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
She wins the Darwin Award!

Trevor555

5,553 posts

115 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
Wow...

Just wow...

finlo

4,453 posts

234 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
Plenty of meat left on the other pad though!

Skyrocket21

789 posts

73 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
The fact there is still material left on the outer pad suggests a severely seized piston, the noise must have been horrendous, I guess it hasn't had a recent mot, or they should be in trouble for not catching that one.

h0b0

9,093 posts

227 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
Just rolled in on YouTube is worth a watch. Some make you afraid to go out on the roads.

Harrison Bergeron

5,444 posts

253 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
h0b0 said:
Just rolled in on YouTube is worth a watch. Some make you afraid to go out on the roads.
it's just stealing content from r/justrolledintotheshop

h0b0

9,093 posts

227 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
Harrison Bergeron said:
h0b0 said:
Just rolled in on YouTube is worth a watch. Some make you afraid to go out on the roads.
it's just stealing content from r/justrolledintotheshop
Stealing is a little harsh as he uses videos with permission and provides their details.

Brooksay

1,291 posts

101 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
EdmondDantes said:
She wins the Darwin Award!
Nah, you have to actually die to win..

Pastor Of Muppets

Original Poster:

3,876 posts

93 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
Skyrocket21 said:
The fact there is still material left on the outer pad suggests a severely seized piston, the noise must have been horrendous, I guess it hasn't had a recent mot, or they should be in trouble for not catching that one.
No the piston has been operating freely, the outer pad still has meat on it because the sliders and the pad were seized solid, the only thing
moving when she's been braking was the piston.

MOT was away back last september so it's been through a winter, still no excuse.

Edited by Pastor Of Muppets on Saturday 30th July 20:53

Sheepshanks

41,293 posts

150 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
I noticed my daughter's Jazz making a noise from the rear brakes - car was still under warranty and service contract so I told he to take it to the dealer. They said it was fine and sent her on her way, so she was happy that the car didn't have an issue.

I spoke to the service manager and he agreed to look again. One of the rear calipers had siezed and one pad had worn right down - the noise was the acoustic wear indicator, lucky it was a pad had that had one fitted.

P675

900 posts

63 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
Sister has a 2003 mini, says oil light keeps coming on. She's just bought it so I think maybe it's the sensor. Keep having to put off looking at it for a few weeks until I drain the oil to change it plus sensor. Only got about a coke can worth of oil, how the car kept going all that time I dont know. She had it for about a year before crashing it too, no other problems.

Baldchap

9,635 posts

123 months

Saturday 30th July 2022
quotequote all
To be fair my RS4 makes horrendous brake noises. The same car in a coupe (RS5) that my wife had was the same.

"They all do that sir"... They actually do unless you hammer the brakes. It just means you need to check the pads when you do the tyres, but how many do?

DKS

1,923 posts

215 months

Sunday 31st July 2022
quotequote all
TO BE FAIR I've seen 2 or 3 cars where one pad has worn down to the metal due to seized components and made no obvious noises. But I can't believe that didn't make a racket!

otolith

69,535 posts

235 months

Sunday 31st July 2022
quotequote all
Brooksay said:
Nah, you have to actually die to win..
Non-fatally blowing your balls off also counts

Brooksay

1,291 posts

101 months

Sunday 31st July 2022
quotequote all
otolith said:
Brooksay said:
Nah, you have to actually die to win..
Non-fatally blowing your balls off also counts
It does indeed. But that's a bit difficult for a girl as per the op.

KungFuPanda

4,645 posts

201 months

Sunday 31st July 2022
quotequote all
I recently bought a 2002 Mondeo as a runaround. Owned by an old couple and serviced religiously by the local Ford Main Dealer with the most recent service being in January 2022.

Despite this, I still bought a service kit and serviced it myself. The oil was clean enough but the pollen filter was in a terrible state and the air filter has May 2012 hand written on it.



Bobupndown

3,002 posts

74 months

Sunday 31st July 2022
quotequote all
Pastor Of Muppets said:
This one dropped my jaw a bit, in all my years I've rarely seen something as dumbfounding as this one. Young girl brings her car to the garage
and tells me her brake pedal is sinking to the floor and there is a bad noise coming from the front passenger side, I tell her to leave it with
me and I will have a look over it, she hands me the key and heads away with her dad who had followed her down. She told me the handbrake
was fine because that's what she used to get it to me rotate .

Anyway a bit later on I start on it, remove the wheel, unbolt the caliper and then the expletives start to fly!.

So what has happened is the pad has worn away all the friction material leaving metal to metal contact, eventually the disc and the pad backing
plate become so worn down that the pad backing plate falls through the gap between the disc and carrier and does a bunk, this then leaves the
piston in direct contact with the disc, both of them then wear down to the point where the piston pops out of the caliper and loses all the brake
fluid, pedal sinks to the floor and that then becomes the stage where she realises something is up.

This has had to have been ongoing for a considerable length of time and mileage to get to this condition, how on earth she didn't suspect
something was wrong long before this is just astonishing. Words fail me. rolleyes

Look at the difference in thickness between the two faces of the disc. The piston had lost about 5mm, past the ring where the dust cover sits.
'/>
Pah! Plenty left on that disc.

Court_S

14,813 posts

208 months

Sunday 31st July 2022
quotequote all
That’s a good effort OP.

It’s scary to think we’re sharing roads with other cars in a similar state.

A friend of mine has an MOT business and he’s often posting up horrors that people haven’t noticed.