RE: You can buy a Tesla for £10k - would you?
RE: You can buy a Tesla for £10k - would you?
Yesterday

You can buy a Tesla for £10k - would you?

Everyone's favourite EV cliche-maker is back in the headlines - but that needn't stop you buying one


Tesla, though it may have become a carmaker seemingly disinterested in the business of launching new models - or doing much of anything in a timely fashion - is never, ever far from the spotlight. Earlier this month, there was much discussion of its faltering sales in the UK (mostly blamed on the strength of new Chinese competition, but also surely a result of its ageing lineup), with no variant selling well enough to threaten the nation’s top ten. Then last week it confirmed an all-new Tesla would launch in Europe soon - but that turned out to be the much-delayed Semi, an all-electric 1,088hp HGV. 

For those of us who prefer cars, we’ve learned this week that the firm does have something else up its sleeve - but not something for us to actually drive: on September 3rd it will introduce the new Cybercab at a dedicated event, a two-passenger, self-driving car expected to do without a steering wheel. Which is food for thought when you consider that China has today issued a recall for up to four million Teslas based on the suspicion that EVs without proper door handles might not be the ideal thing to have in an emergency. 

Tesla isn’t the only company to be affected by that recall, and nor is it the only firm building autonomous taxis or electric HGVs - but it is the first among equals when it comes to headline writing. A victim of its own success, in part (and perhaps attributable to the outspoken behaviour of its founder and figurehead), but Tesla’s position as both lightning rod and bellwether isn’t rivalled by any other manufacturer of EVs - even those apparently doing a far better job of actually selling electric cars. 

It helps, of course, that Tesla was there first. Or among the first to think big, at any rate, and not just about producing usable, upmarket electric cars on a truly global scale, but also to conceive of how they might be recharged in public, too. Short-lived Roadser aside, the Model S was the primary carrier for all this game-changing DNA - and change the world it did. For a time, it was the biggest-selling EV in the world, even if it was the cheaper Model 3 that became the first to shift a million units. 

Its success, not to mention the sheer amount of time it was on sale, has led to a surfeit of options for the secondhand buyer. That a high-mile Model S can prove cheap to buy is hardly a revelation in 2026 - concerns about battery life and warranty limitations are certainly not exclusive to Tesla - though the prospect of acquiring a one-owner 2017 Dual Motor 75D, said to be capable of beyond 300 miles range when new, and endowed with more than 500hp, for less than £10k seems eye-opening even now. When we featured a 100k-old Model S in Brave Pill five years ago, it was £28k. Even a similarly leggy Model 3 spotted last year was £11,475. 

Granted, we don’t know very much about this one save for its steady accumulation of miles and an MOT history that speaks mostly of worn-out consumables. The vendor suggests there is a service history, though whether that includes a changing of the battery or drive unit in that time isn’t clear. The degradation of the former depends upon several variables, though even with a 70 per cent charge capacity, it should still be (technically) capable of getting you around 200 miles. Paying to have Tesla change it yourself would likely prove prohibitively expensive, so you’d definitely want to see evidence of a Battery Health Test. But if you could live with the result - and the running costs thereafter - the Model S surely fits the lot-of-car-for-the-money cliche as well as any cut-price EV.


See the original advert

Author
Discussion

nismo48

Original Poster:

6,869 posts

235 months

Yesterday (19:31)
quotequote all
Looks smart in that livery

lost in espace

6,564 posts

235 months

Yesterday (19:40)
quotequote all
These are very big cars, and I would expect to have maintenance of around £1500 a year ongoing. If the battery does not fail, but this is the 75 and supposed to be robust. Constant alignment issues and tyre wear is common. Styling is nice though.

Get a 3, I bought my 2020 M3P for £12k with 72k on it a few months ago. Much less chance, but not none, of big bills.

StuntmanMike

14,810 posts

179 months

Yesterday (19:43)
quotequote all
Yes, I will probably have a second hand one next.

biggbn

32,369 posts

248 months

Yesterday (20:02)
quotequote all
I like these Tesla...only ones I'd have

Mr-B

4,930 posts

222 months

Yesterday (20:07)
quotequote all
When they first came out I thought they looked like a big Mondeo. That's not really a criticism as the Mondeo was and still is a fairly inoffensive design, a bit bland maybe just not having a wow factor considering the price at the time.

Saw a Jonny Smith video of a taxi firm that runs a couple of these for airport runs that have amassed 300/400K miles each and he charges them on superchargers all the time as it is free leccy, saved him 10's of thousands in fuel costs.

andy43

13,080 posts

282 months

Yesterday (20:08)
quotequote all
Our P100D did eleven grands worth of warranty claims in two years. Driveshafts, AC pump, suspension bits etc.
I d still have another, they re getting embarrassingly cheap now - 20 grand gets a very nice 100 now, and the whole Tesla infrastructure is still the best bar none.
Eg this one https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202607304... with only 27k miles on it.

Edited by andy43 on Monday 24th August 20:10

Dombilano

1,427 posts

83 months

Yesterday (20:27)
quotequote all
lost in espace said:
These are very big cars, and I would expect to have maintenance of around £1500 a year ongoing. If the battery does not fail, but this is the 75 and supposed to be robust. Constant alignment issues and tyre wear is common. Styling is nice though.

Get a 3, I bought my 2020 M3P for £12k with 72k on it a few months ago. Much less chance, but not none, of big bills.
£1.5k a year on what? Tyres every 2-3 years £800. Brake fluid every every few years £100. Air-conditioning regas £50. Suspension odds and sods £500 every few years maybe. Its not £1.5k every year.

kambites

71,379 posts

249 months

Yesterday (20:38)
quotequote all
I always liked the styling of the model-S and I think the increasing fussiness of most modern cars has only made it look better... but it's the size of some small countries and personally I don't think I could live with anything associated with Musk on my drive (since it certainly wouldn't fit in my garage!).

At that price it'll make a great car for somebody, though.

BVB

1,215 posts

181 months

Yesterday (21:00)
quotequote all
No chance.
I'd be too embarrassed to even accept a lift in a Tesla.

Dombilano

1,427 posts

83 months

Yesterday (21:28)
quotequote all
BVB said:
No chance.
I'd be too embarrassed to even accept a lift in a Tesla.
Have you been overtaken by one too many Tesla's

Dog Biscuit

2,530 posts

25 months

Yesterday (21:35)
quotequote all
Just can't stand the look of anyu of the Tesla vehicles.

There's no denying they are amazing at what they do, but I wouldn't want to marry a prostitute either

JoshSm

4,761 posts

65 months

Yesterday (21:41)
quotequote all
Dombilano said:
£1.5k a year on what? Tyres every 2-3 years £800. Brake fluid every every few years £100. Air-conditioning regas £50. Suspension odds and sods £500 every few years maybe. Its not £1.5k every year.
That's not based on reality is it? 'Every few years'?! Brake fluid is every two years for a start and more than £100 to get done, air-conditioning regas is more than £50 (and should either be infrequent or its likely more work is needed), the tyres don't last long, neither does the suspension though not quite the stshow of some of the 3s.

Drive units are far from bombproof and the risk with the battery is it won't just gracefully degrade, but one day wll just give you a terminal failure.

Plus there's the general parts availability which really doesn't help with bills.

Nice enough car from the time when they actually put the effort in but they're not perfect and they can be ruinous, just like any aging heavy 'premium' car.

Mazinbrum

1,339 posts

206 months

Yesterday (21:42)
quotequote all
andy43 said:
Our P100D did eleven grands worth of warranty claims in two years. Driveshafts, AC pump, suspension bits etc.
I d still have another, they re getting embarrassingly cheap now - 20 grand gets a very nice 100 now, and the whole Tesla infrastructure is still the best bar none.
Eg this one https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202607304... with only 27k miles on it.

Edited by andy43 on Monday 24th August 20:10
Looks to be carefully driven too.


user123987

31 posts

9 months

Yesterday (21:42)
quotequote all
Dog Biscuit said:
but I wouldn't want to marry a prostitute either
Sign me right up

AC43

13,565 posts

236 months

Yesterday (21:42)
quotequote all
That's by far my favourite-looking Tesla and the only one I've genuinely researched. Decent ride, too, because of the air suspension.

Not sure I'd want something quite as wide but otherwise a lot of car for the money.

Dombilano

1,427 posts

83 months

Yesterday (21:53)
quotequote all
JoshSm said:
Dombilano said:
£1.5k a year on what? Tyres every 2-3 years £800. Brake fluid every every few years £100. Air-conditioning regas £50. Suspension odds and sods £500 every few years maybe. Its not £1.5k every year.
That's not based on reality is it? 'Every few years'?! Brake fluid is every two years for a start and more than £100 to get done, air-conditioning regas is more than £50 (and should either be infrequent or its likely more work is needed), the tyres don't last long, neither does the suspension though not quite the stshow of some of the 3s.

Drive units are far from bombproof and the risk with the battery is it won't just gracefully degrade, but one day wll just give you a terminal failure.

Plus there's the general parts availability which really doesn't help with bills.

Nice enough car from the time when they actually put the effort in but they're not perfect and they can be ruinous, just like any aging heavy 'premium' car.
Unless you're track racing, tyres will last 20k+, drive units and battery packs are hardly a major concern. Brake fluid is £150 at tesla (i own one) or half that at Halfords. Control arms will last 50k+. So no, £1500 a year is make believe

stevemcs

10,237 posts

121 months

Yesterday (22:01)
quotequote all
Nope, horrid things.

underwhelmist

2,036 posts

162 months

Yesterday (22:16)
quotequote all
Musk wasn't the founder of Tesla. Don't be taken in by his BS.

MikeM6

5,996 posts

130 months

Yesterday (22:25)
quotequote all
BVB said:
No chance.
I'd be too embarrassed to even accept a lift in a Tesla.
Well you are a bit silly then, aren't you?

I'm not a massive fan, but at this price point it's a great mobility option.

andy43

13,080 posts

282 months

Yesterday (23:43)
quotequote all
Mazinbrum said:
andy43 said:
Our P100D did eleven grands worth of warranty claims in two years. Driveshafts, AC pump, suspension bits etc.
I d still have another, they re getting embarrassingly cheap now - 20 grand gets a very nice 100 now, and the whole Tesla infrastructure is still the best bar none.
Eg this one https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202607304... with only 27k miles on it.

Edited by andy43 on Monday 24th August 20:10
Looks to be carefully driven too.

Werthers in the oddments tray, the confidence trick every car dealer should use.