What car for my parents?
What car for my parents?
Author
Discussion

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

253 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
Right then. My Gran, at the tender old age of 86, has decided to give up driving as she only does 30 miles per week and her car's costing £750 per year to insure. This leaves our household with my BMW (which no one else is allowed to drive), Dad's broken Corsa and my Mum's Mk2 Tigra (only two seats); the plan is to sell the Peugeot, Corsa and Tigra and put all the money together and buy one car, as that's basically all that gets used these days anyway.

Based on what I think the rock bottom value of each car is I believe this should amount to at least £8000, so here are the pre-requisites.

  • Up to £8000, no extra money will be put towards this, although I appreciate that most cars have room for haggling from their listed value.
  • MUST be a convertible.
  • MUST have four seats.
  • MUST have leather seats (my Gran doesn't like cloth).
  • Insurance is a non-issue.
  • My Dad will have to drive it too, so it needs to be a convertible that is both manly and lady like.
  • Performance is a non-issue.
  • No more than 60000 miles, my Mum won't budge on that.
  • No older than 2004, again Mum won't budge.
  • This'll sound daft, but ideally being sold by a trader/dealer so that we can p/ex the Corsa. I think it'll be nigh on impossible to sell privately.
  • Mum wants more than 30mpg, but her commute is a steady 10 mile slog up a traffic free part of the A5. 30mpg would be doable in mine, so it's no great shakes really.
My thoughts were along the lines of an E46 318Ci, a Saab 9-3 Aero or an Audi A4 1.8T. I also suggested the Volvo C70 for if we get a bit more than £8k as that has a folding hard top similar to her Tigra's. MX5s have been discounted as they have two seats and we can't afford a 335d, so leave it out.

Any other suggestions would be welcomed. I get quite a big say in this as she's leaving it up to me to look for a car with her having the final word, and I don't want her in an Astra/Megane/307 CC, not because they're bad cars but because I'd feel sorry for my Dad moping around in something that's so overwhelmingly style over substance.

Thanks in advance.

alfa pint

3,856 posts

233 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2484783.htm

E class Merc. Might be a bit on the old side.

Loads of convertible C class for that budget though - even me and another sizeable bloke were comfortable in the back for an hour.

anonymous-user

76 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
VW Eos?

Mustardo

95 posts

180 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
Audi A4 Cab would be my choice.

edo

16,699 posts

287 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all

edo

16,699 posts

287 months

edo

16,699 posts

287 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all

edo

16,699 posts

287 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

253 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
I like all of the suggestions so far, although my Mum has expressed distaste for the Eos on the past.

Can't believe I didn't think of a CLK. Would probably be a 200/230 though as I don't think she'd be overly keen on a V8.

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

253 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
Cheers doogz. The 9-3 is currently my favourite, as they're the best priced and I'm a fan of Saabs.

I shouldn't imagine the interior would be any more flimsy than her current Tigra, could it? I'd try to get her into an Aero, as there's little/no difference in fuel economy and they can all be picked up for a fair price. I should imagine an Aero would hold its value better in the long run, too.

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

253 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
doogz said:
That reminds me, fuel economy.

My Mum's averages 25mpg, bit rubbish.
Good to know. Is it an auto? What sort of driving does she do?

Jayho

2,390 posts

192 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
Weld 2 MX-5's together? Haha jokes.

Seems like the Audi A4 as suggested above seems like best choice to me.

2 Wycked

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

253 months

Thursday 24th February 2011
quotequote all
doogz said:
Manual, she's fairly tame, it doesn't get driven hard, although her daily commute is about 5 miles along a 30 road each way, which won't be helping.

I dunno what i was expecting tbh, just wasn't that impressed when it said 24.7mpg.
I shouldn't imagine you were. My 325i tops that.