what car you've owned has most surprised you?
what car you've owned has most surprised you?
Author
Discussion

dev635

Original Poster:

62 posts

195 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
As above, what car have you owned that has really surprised you by being either 'really good' or 'really bad' say pro rata to expectations, value or general ownership experience

It's my old Ford puma for me on the good side, was so surprised just how much fun it was and didn't give any nasty bills.
I had a nightmare with a vw polo gti that just gave up on life after 40k miles, so that would be my lemon unfortunately.
Would really like to see p/h ers' opinions on their cars, the ones you regret selling on and indeed the ones you regret buying?

Jasandjules

71,295 posts

246 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
My Passat Diesel is a lot better than I was expecting, it is ok to drive and comfy over long distances etc... and still going strong (touch wood!!) at 135k miles too. Far better than the Mondeo estate I upgraded from.

I was most disappointed with my TVR 350i but that's just because it went wrong so much.


Matt UK

18,079 posts

217 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Best: £1,500 worth of Mk1 MX5. Thought I'd only have it a summer, but it's such fun, so it stays.
Worst: Audi A6 purchased new. Rattled, sqeaked, moaned and groaned from new. Audi have some properly crap dealers as well. Never again.

Jonboy_t

5,038 posts

200 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
My first car, an A reg Ford Fiesta 1.1. It was amazing, did everything I wanted when I was 17, the only time it ever broke was when I was showing off so that was my own fault and doesn't count! The engine usde to rattle so badly that the main lead kept falling off the starter motor whenever I fired her up, that was my 'security' device - wouldn't start without putting it back on!

I also used to be able to start it, take the keys out and carry on driving, managed Basingstoke to Southampton with a mate before he clocked on that he was holding the keys to the very car we were doing '70' in down the M3.

I would have that car back any day of the week, seriously. So much character it was untrue, it always made me smile seeing other peoples faces when 4 or 5, 6 foot plus rugby players (honestly, and not 'PH' 6 foot'ers!!) got out of this shoe sized car and toddled off down the road!

Good times, good times!

Eunos

111 posts

186 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Both the MX-3 & my MGF really. Very underrated cars, especially the MX-3.

W00DY

16,174 posts

243 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Bought my 309 GTI because it was great value and people raved about them. I was expecting to miss RWD and wish I'd bought another E30.

I was wrong, it is way, way more fun than an E30 and the handling is sublime. The dash may rattle and look a bit cheap, but once you start driving you don't even notice.

My best car purchase by some margin.

PaulB81

883 posts

177 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
My current car. I went from an Impreza WRX to my 320d Compact on a 52 plate (was doing some long commutes) and I actually really love it. Its my first BMW but I'm a convert now. It pulls quite nicely, can go a bit sidewise when required and handles really nicely around the country roads here. Expected it to be quite boring.

Now I need an e46 M3 in my life though smile

jannthaman

106 posts

174 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
W00DY said:
Bought my 309 GTI because it was great value and people raved about them. I was expecting to miss RWD and wish I'd bought another E30.

I was wrong, it is way, way more fun than an E30 and the handling is sublime. The dash may rattle and look a bit cheap, but once you start driving you don't even notice.

My best car purchase by some margin.
I was very nearly going to buy a 309GTi for my first car, I wanted a phase1 version, but after waiting around 6months I couldn't fined one so i brought a E30 lol.

Baryonyx

18,146 posts

176 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
My MX5 has been a pleasant surprise, of being absolutely incredible for £2500. However, my big surprise is my old Ford Focus Ebony 1.6 Zetec. It was a really nice car to drive, with nicely weighted steering and excellent handling. It had a full leather interior and it was a lovely place to sit, and served me well for the one and a half years I owned it. If I had any complaints, it's that it suffered from minor electrical faults and the engine was fairly gutless, but it responded well to being driven hard to unlock it's meagre power. The suspension was excellently judged and relatively stiff without being crashy. It left me with a very favourable opinion of Fords, as did my mkV Fiesta Zetec S.

ewenm

28,506 posts

262 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
The Caterham - yes, I expected it to be amazing on track and on b-road blasts, the surprising thing was how usable it was as my only car for 5 years.

mrtwisty

3,057 posts

182 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
I'll echo the op's comments about the Puma. Bought mine because I needed a car pretty quick and the seller was just round the corner from me. Thought it would be pretty dull and gutless after my MR2, how wrong I was!

GHW

1,294 posts

238 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
The Legacy. On the way home from collecting it, I mashed the accelerator expecting to be blown away by the performance. It was relatively entertaining as it came on boost, then thoroughly disappointing as it fell off the boost again...

... and then the second turbo spooled up and it felt thoroughly epic. A whole new order of magnitude of power compared to the MX5 that I'd just sold.

jsg612

571 posts

185 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Has to be my Renault Twingo GT 1.2 Turbo I had back in 2008. At just 1149cc with a tiny turbo, I was expecting it to be nippy-ish, but it really could shift and even sat well on the motorway. Bit of a tyre shredder to be honest. Great fun little car, I miss it!

dugsud

1,125 posts

280 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Most surprisingly bad car Alfa 159 frown

Most surprisingly good car E90 BMW 320d....particularly after the 159!!!

DannyVTS

7,543 posts

185 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Astra Sxi, not exciting, or PH like, but it was my first proper car and I loved it!

Makem

156 posts

199 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
An old rover 827 Vitesse. Big barge of a thing. Had a 2.7 litre (i believe Honda wuad cam engine). Bought for £250 and loved it.

Stu - B

502 posts

193 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Aston Martin Vantage Auto (5.3 litre version) because it was so awful and Ford Sierra 2.9i XR4x4 because it was so terrific to drive, have fun in, hoon, do a daily commute, reliability, practicality, comfort. Much, much better than I ever could have expected.

dev635

Original Poster:

62 posts

195 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
Interesting replies, I wondered whether more people would say their first car as many hold a special affection for them. Personally I had a 1989 mini that refused to work when it rained! Fun and anguish in equal measure

Stu-b, out of interest why was the aston so bad?

Stu - B

502 posts

193 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
dev635 said:
Interesting replies, I wondered whether more people would say their first car as many hold a special affection for them. Personally I had a 1989 mini that refused to work when it rained! Fun and anguish in equal measure

Stu-b, out of interest why was the aston so bad?
Not very quick. At the time the manual version was mooted as being the fastest in the World. Water ingress. Have had a few and very common problem that is difficult to eradicate. Sound deadening was - and I still find this difficult to believe - lead with foam stuck to either side. Made me think car was not well thought through at all. In other words a heavy car gets heavier and water problem is compounded. Just a poor driving car really with headline statistics blantantly a lie. Quality under the beautiful skin was shocking.

007 VXR

64,187 posts

204 months

Monday 7th March 2011
quotequote all
My current car, My Monaro
1st surprise was buying a new car
2nd suprise was loving it So much I have now spent more on mods
than the car cost new laugh
3rd still love it as much as the day I got it smile