Roof boxes
Author
Discussion

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

285 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
Anybody use a huge roof box for stuff like golf clubs x several..?

Hints on problems, what to avoid and good kit would be appreciated.

Boba Fret

438 posts

186 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
just make sure you take it off when you've finished using it.

Was chatting to an 'aquaintance' the other day who couldn't understand why the 'economy' on his piece of crap X3 had gone down since his skiing trip (and yes, he looks SOOOOOO feckin stupid with the 'panda eyes, then again he is a complete c**t).

Looked out of the pub window, "You still have your roofbox on you utter tw*t" "Oh, would that make a difference?" He's been driving around with it on since mid feb. rolleyes

Just the sort of c*** that buys an X3 I guess.

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

285 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
Oh dear...hehe

PaulB81

883 posts

190 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
I have an irrational hatred of roof boxes. Everyime I see one I just think 'you should have just bought a bigger car'

Minemapper

933 posts

186 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
Why? So I can lug around the extra space that I need for maybe 3 weeks for the entire year instead?

No thanks.

OP, as usual, you get what you pay for. I forked out for the top of the line Thule in the States about 6 years ago. It's served us well and still works as it did when new. A little faded and scratched up, but patina adds value, right? smile

I would look at the long and tall, versus the short and wide editions. We had the latter briefly as a freebie, and it wasn't nearly as useful.

Edited by Minemapper on Tuesday 19th April 19:17

raktor

1 posts

189 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
I have a Kame roofbox that opens from both sides (can be very useful). Is very good for camping trips etc. The only issue I've had is storage of the roofbox when it is not on the car. Is now suspended from garage roof.

theboss

7,506 posts

249 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
Boba Fret said:
Just the sort of c*** that buys an X3 I guess.
Yeah thanks for that...

I did 2000 miles around Spain in our X3 with a box and it knocked 2-3mpg off... not exactly a big deal.

dowahdiddyman

965 posts

241 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
Roof boxes, why not just by a bleedin car that is up to your needs. Nothing makes me chuckle more than seeing something like an Astra with a bleedin shed on it`s roof, by an Insignia Estate or something similar ffs.
Mate of mine has a 1 series BMW that has had a box on since day one because there is nowhere to put the pram, should have bought a 3 series touring then.

jkh112

23,938 posts

188 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
dowahdiddyman said:
Roof boxes, why not just by a bleedin car that is up to your needs.
Why buy a larger, more expensive car than you need for 48 weeks of the year, when you can use a roofbox for the few weeks holiday and spend the bulk of the year driving a more appropriate (sportier?) car?
I use an atera box for a few weeks each year when my family do beach holidays. It is ideal for carrying wetsuits, bodyboards, buckets etc. without filling the car with sand and sea-water.
As before, I would recommend a long thin box rather than short fat, and dual sided opening is really useful.

Boba Fret

438 posts

186 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
jkh112 said:
Why buy a larger, more expensive car than you need for 48 weeks of the year, when you can use a roofbox for the few weeks holiday and spend the bulk of the year driving a more appropriate (sportier?) car?
I use an atera box for a few weeks each year when my family do beach holidays. It is ideal for carrying wetsuits, bodyboards, buckets etc. without filling the car with sand and sea-water.
As before, I would recommend a long thin box rather than short fat, and dual sided opening is really useful.
because people are SO lazy or stupid they don't take them off.

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

285 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
dowahdiddyman said:
Roof boxes, why not just by a bleedin car that is up to your needs.
Volvo V70, five adults, with luggage and golf x 4 or skis, just won't go. Looks like a long and wide box is needed...

Tally Ho...smile

Macd355

320 posts

204 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
How about one of these?


s2driveruk

350 posts

239 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
another thumbs up for a Thule...think its an atlantic 600 whatever that means. They wear well, no real additional wind noise and swallows a ton of gear. I never understand the resistance to them...they do what they do well and are secure. Gold clubs shouldnt be an issue..at least a couple of bags should go in no trouble.

jkh112

23,938 posts

188 months

Tuesday 19th April 2011
quotequote all
Boba Fret said:
because people are SO lazy or stupid they don't take them off.
So because some people are lazy or stupid that doesn't mean that active/intelligent people shouldn't choose to use them for a few weeks each year instead of buying a car which is larger than they normally need.

CanadianScot

1,916 posts

196 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
dowahdiddyman said:
Roof boxes, why not just by a bleedin car that is up to your needs. Nothing makes me chuckle more than seeing something like an Astra with a bleedin shed on it`s roof, by an Insignia Estate or something similar ffs.
Mate of mine has a 1 series BMW that has had a box on since day one because there is nowhere to put the pram, should have bought a 3 series touring then.
What if it's already a big Estate and that still isn't enough?

We have a V70 that has to fit 4 people, a big Dobermann and all the luggage to go with.

A roof box really helps for those longer stints.

LMC

918 posts

243 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Boba Fret said:
because people are SO lazy or stupid they don't take them off.
Who is this fanny?

angusc43

13,618 posts

238 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
dowahdiddyman said:
Roof boxes, why not just by a bleedin car that is up to your needs.
I've got a 2005 E Class estate. When four up with camping gear I need it.

Next.

Fleckers

2,880 posts

231 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Quinny said:
I use a Thule roof box on the jeep, when we go away in the caravan...

...
I dont understand this, I have seen it lots, you have a caravan but people still load the car up with roof boxes, luggage, bikes etc, why noy put it all in site the caravan ?


croyde

26,373 posts

260 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
I have a roof box and agree with the comments of why have a much larger car for most of the year when the box on my 3 series saloon suffices when needed.

Takes minutes to put on and seconds to remove.

Storage is a bit of a problem though and currently it is leaning against the fence in the back garden.

There is a numpty around the corner with a Freelander 2 plus a roof box on permanently the wrong way round. So much for the aerodynamic shape.

anonymous-user

84 months

Sunday 15th May 2011
quotequote all
Fleckers said:
I dont understand this, I have seen it lots, you have a caravan but people still load the car up with roof boxes, luggage, bikes etc, why noy put it all in site the caravan ?
Because you want to minimise the weight you are hanging off your tow bar.