992.1 touring v winged / pdk v manual
992.1 touring v winged / pdk v manual
Author
Discussion

Babw

Original Poster:

1,078 posts

177 months

Friday 2nd October
quotequote all
I m in a predicament, this week I ve sold my 991 GT3 Clubsport and track modified Exige V6. Owned both for 4 years and no longer have the time to do as many trackdays as I used to but I still want to enjoy the few I do.

I must have a GT3 in the garage, it exceeded my expectations hugely and has been an incredible car to own.

Lucky enough to have some other toys but having considered a 600LT, I would prefer the screaming flat 6 as a road x track car.

Would love to have a touring but one big issue is the lack of harnesses, for me being quite slim it makes a massive difference on track. Especially in a manual having to brace myself with my knee isn t very enjoyable.

Anyone worked around this? Removable harness bar or something?

So I m thinking I m going to have to go for a winged GT3 but then it seems sensible to have a PDK for full attack mode.

Can anyone give me an alternative perspective?

Edit - why did I sell the 991? I’ve owned it for 4 years and after trying a 992, I found the front end behaviour more inline with my driving style and preference.

Edited by Babw on Friday 2nd October 10:24

Quickmoose

5,412 posts

154 months

Friday 2nd October
quotequote all
PDK vs manual.... the age old debate
extra engagement vs ultimate lap time...
if ultimate track times are a goal, wouldn't you want mid engine'd too (GT4 RS)?
whatever
If I were lucky enough to have other toys and getting a track focused 911.... PDK for me, but I'd also be getting the 991.2 as I think it looks better, which obviously is both subjective and does sweet FA for track times smile

993rsr

3,678 posts

280 months

Friday 2nd October
quotequote all
Babw said:
I m in a predicament, this week I ve sold my 991 GT3 Clubsport and track modified Exige V6. Owned both for 4 years and no longer have the time to do as many trackdays as I used to but I still want to enjoy the few I do.

I must have a GT3 in the garage, it exceeded my expectations hugely and has been an incredible car to own.

Lucky enough to have some other toys but having considered a 600LT, I would prefer the screaming flat 6 as a road x track car.

Would love to have a touring but one big issue is the lack of harnesses, for me being quite slim it makes a massive difference on track. Especially in a manual having to brace myself with my knee isn t very enjoyable.

Anyone worked around this? Removable harness bar or something?

So I m thinking I m going to have to go for a winged GT3 but then it seems sensible to have a PDK for full attack mode.

Can anyone give me an alternative perspective?

Edit - why did I sell the 991? I ve owned it for 4 years and after trying a 992, I found the front end behaviour more inline with my driving style and preference.

Edited by Babw on Friday 2nd October 10:24
Yes fitted a Brey-Krause harness bar in my 991.2 gt3
Touring

https://www.bkauto.com/category_s/100.htm


Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Friday 2nd October
quotequote all
I am also rather tall and slim. The stock buckets are too wide for my frame. I get the upholstery adjusted so they fit snugly. That's still far away from a harness but for spirited road driving it's perfect

Babw

Original Poster:

1,078 posts

177 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
Rather unexpectedly (relative to when I began the thread anyway) I have put a deposit down on a 992.2 GT3 Weissach with Mag wheels in GT silver.

Looking forward to getting acquainted with possibly the final winged GT3 with a naturally aspirated engine.

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
lichfield will convert a winged car to touring spec


Kickstart

1,124 posts

268 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
markiii said:
lichfield will convert a winged car to touring spec
That's interesting - any idea on costs ?

markiii

4,340 posts

225 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
not cheap i seem to remember 10k

Babw

Original Poster:

1,078 posts

177 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
Iain knows how to charge (ex GTR owner) but their work is very good.

jcosh

1,248 posts

263 months

Saturday 17th October
quotequote all
markiii said:
not cheap i seem to remember 10k
£14K is more the number having considered this as an option earlier tis year. But its totally spot on and as per factory, unlike others that offer same.

Allocated

2 posts

2 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
On the manual vs PDK question, I went through every used 992.2 GT3 on Porsche Finder UK last Friday (23 Oct, asking prices, 40 cars at UK Porsche Centres), in case it's useful:

- Coupe: 3 manuals at £189,900-£201,900 against 20 PDKs at £172,500-£207,950. The cheapest manual is £17,400 over the cheapest PDK, but 11 of the 20 PDKs ask more than it, and the dearest coupe is a PDK.
- Touring: 6 manuals at £195,950-£221,990 against 11 PDKs at £187,000-£209,900. As of the 23rd that's £8,950 more at the bottom and £12,090 more at the top, about 5-6%. (The cheapest PDK Touring has since gone up to £194,750, so the gap at the bottom is closing.)
- All 40 ask more than the £159,700 list, and the manual is a £0 option new.

Worth knowing if you're shopping: Swindon's 267-mile manual showed £182,850 on the Finder search page, £191,000 on its own Finder page, and £182,850 on its PH advert, so ask which one stands. Perth's manual dropped from £197,900 to £189,900 within a few hours on Friday. Outside the OPC network, Romans International had a 2,220-mile car at £184,950.

For comparison, Germany is much closer to list (€211,200). There the cheapest manual Touring was €400 above the cheapest PDK, but 5 of the 8 manuals asked more than the dearest PDK.

(Disclosure: I put this together for a free weekly price newsletter I write. I'm not in the trade and have nothing for sale.)

Tuftie

182 posts

3 months

Tuesday 27th October
quotequote all
Allocated said:
On the manual vs PDK question, I went through every used 992.2 GT3 on Porsche Finder UK last Friday (23 Oct, asking prices, 40 cars at UK Porsche Centres), in case it's useful:

- Coupe: 3 manuals at £189,900-£201,900 against 20 PDKs at £172,500-£207,950. The cheapest manual is £17,400 over the cheapest PDK, but 11 of the 20 PDKs ask more than it, and the dearest coupe is a PDK.
- Touring: 6 manuals at £195,950-£221,990 against 11 PDKs at £187,000-£209,900. As of the 23rd that's £8,950 more at the bottom and £12,090 more at the top, about 5-6%. (The cheapest PDK Touring has since gone up to £194,750, so the gap at the bottom is closing.)
- All 40 ask more than the £159,700 list, and the manual is a £0 option new.

Worth knowing if you're shopping: Swindon's 267-mile manual showed £182,850 on the Finder search page, £191,000 on its own Finder page, and £182,850 on its PH advert, so ask which one stands. Perth's manual dropped from £197,900 to £189,900 within a few hours on Friday. Outside the OPC network, Romans International had a 2,220-mile car at £184,950.

For comparison, Germany is much closer to list ( 211,200). There the cheapest manual Touring was 400 above the cheapest PDK, but 5 of the 8 manuals asked more than the dearest PDK.

(Disclosure: I put this together for a free weekly price newsletter I write. I'm not in the trade and have nothing for sale.)
Good work!

I dabbled with the idea of a manual Touring a few months ago but after finally driving one I realised that it wasn’t for me, maybe 20 years ago! Anyway, my searching revealed just how hit and miss the market is, with some surprising variance in prices and it was hard to understand what a good deal looks like.

There’s lots of chat on 911 forums about prices crashing as the flippers start to disappear, along with Porsche reducing U.K. deliveries while hiking up prices.

Babw

Original Poster:

1,078 posts

177 months

Saturday 31st October
quotequote all
Have done 200 miles in the 992.2 Weissach and what an incredible upgrade over the 991. If you drive your cars with any kind of intent to dynamically push the car, the 992.2 is better than a 991 in every single way. It also sounds just as good, if not better (my 991 had a Sharkwerks).

The front and end, chassis control over undulations and braking is outstanding, the way you can threshold brake over a crest and turn in is very Lotus like, the 991 would have you waiting or under steering.

The engine start stop being hidden away in a menu is kind of annoying but it is hands down the best 911 I’ve ever driven. What a car.


Implus1

205 posts

71 months

Saturday 31st October
quotequote all
Manual or PDK in the end? How does it compare to the LT?

Babw

Original Poster:

1,078 posts

177 months

Saturday 31st October
quotequote all
PDK, if I had gone for a touring I think it would be manual but the immediacy of the thing makes a PDK more suited. The turn in is ridiculous and mid corner shifting will be the norm so glad I went for the PDK.

LT back next Sunday so should be able to do some decent back to back but first impressions are that it's the most Mclaren like in the way it rides the bumps. 991 and 992.1 was far less sophisticated IMO.

Implus1

205 posts

71 months

Saturday 31st October
quotequote all
Interesting, thanks. Would be keen to hear more about the LT comparison and which you think is the better road car!

jcosh

1,248 posts

263 months

Saturday 31st October
quotequote all
Babw said:
PDK, if I had gone for a touring I think it would be manual but the immediacy of the thing makes a PDK more suited. The turn in is ridiculous and mid corner shifting will be the norm so glad I went for the PDK.

LT back next Sunday so should be able to do some decent back to back but first impressions are that it's the most Mclaren like in the way it rides the bumps. 991 and 992.1 was far less sophisticated IMO.
How much difference are you experiencing between a 991.1 and 991.2 GT3?

MDL111

8,937 posts

208 months

Sunday 1st November
quotequote all
Allocated said:
On the manual vs PDK question, I went through every used 992.2 GT3 on Porsche Finder UK last Friday (23 Oct, asking prices, 40 cars at UK Porsche Centres), in case it's useful:

- Coupe: 3 manuals at £189,900-£201,900 against 20 PDKs at £172,500-£207,950. The cheapest manual is £17,400 over the cheapest PDK, but 11 of the 20 PDKs ask more than it, and the dearest coupe is a PDK.
- Touring: 6 manuals at £195,950-£221,990 against 11 PDKs at £187,000-£209,900. As of the 23rd that's £8,950 more at the bottom and £12,090 more at the top, about 5-6%. (The cheapest PDK Touring has since gone up to £194,750, so the gap at the bottom is closing.)
- All 40 ask more than the £159,700 list, and the manual is a £0 option new.

Worth knowing if you're shopping: Swindon's 267-mile manual showed £182,850 on the Finder search page, £191,000 on its own Finder page, and £182,850 on its PH advert, so ask which one stands. Perth's manual dropped from £197,900 to £189,900 within a few hours on Friday. Outside the OPC network, Romans International had a 2,220-mile car at £184,950.

For comparison, Germany is much closer to list ( 211,200). There the cheapest manual Touring was 400 above the cheapest PDK, but 5 of the 8 manuals asked more than the dearest PDK.

(Disclosure: I put this together for a free weekly price newsletter I write. I'm not in the trade and have nothing for sale.)
Re Germany - friend of mine just bought a new PDK Touring below list of the car incl options. I think it was c 10% below.
Edit: from an OPC

Babw

Original Poster:

1,078 posts

177 months

Sunday 1st November
quotequote all
jcosh said:
How much difference are you experiencing between a 991.1 and 991.2 GT3?
Not a whole lot to be honest, I found the .1 a bit more unfiltered and the .2 a bit more tied down but it was marginal. Certainly a fraction from a 991.2 to 992.1.

hornbaek

3,847 posts

266 months

Sunday 1st November
quotequote all
I have had a 992.1 GT3 Touring PDK for 4 years now and just came back from a trackday having driven a 992.2 the entire day. There is not a lot in it to be honest. I find my car to be a little louder, having a more lively steering and the instrumentation is a bit nicer with the fixed central rev dial. The new buckets are a bit narrower than the 918 seats and the removable head cushion is practical (but I didn't think it was a problem before). The big difference is that the seats tilt forwards - that is a real inconvenience of the 918 seats, but I think the 918 seats look nicer with less visible plastic. Also, the driver aids are quicker to turn off in the .1 generation. Really like the GT3 Touring. Done 25.000km with ca. 10 track days in Monza, Imola, Missano and Red Bull Ring. Have an 992 GT3 SC on order.





Edited by hornbaek on Sunday 1st November 13:31


Edited by hornbaek on Sunday 1st November 13:35