Mass Nested Quoting

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

Digger

Original Poster:

15,486 posts

203 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin

Super Sonic

8,869 posts

66 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.

Digger

Original Poster:

15,486 posts

203 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink

Super Sonic

8,869 posts

66 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink
Wait a minute, did you put that, or was it me?

Digger

Original Poster:

15,486 posts

203 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink
Wait a minute, did you put that, or was it me?
Nah it was the next bloke . . . any minute now . . .

hidetheelephants

29,451 posts

205 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink
Wait a minute, did you put that, or was it me?
Nah it was the next bloke . . . any minute now . . .
It used to be fine, then at the last facelift they made the quotes look vaguely like speechbubbles and it worked about as well as all the other tweaks, only the other st tweaks were tweaked until they were mostly not st whereas the bubble quotes have hung around like a persistent eggy fart in the toilet.

Super Sonic

8,869 posts

66 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Super Sonic said:
hidetheelephants said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink
Wait a minute, did you put that, or was it me?
Nah it was the next bloke . . . any minute now . . .
It used to be fine, then at the last facelift they made the quotes look vaguely like speechbubbles and it worked about as well as all the other tweaks, only the other st tweaks were tweaked until they were mostly not st whereas the bubble quotes have hung around like a persistent eggy fart in the toilet.
Super Sonic said
Would it be better if we put our names in the boxes?

thebraketester

14,922 posts

150 months

Friday 5th July 2024
quotequote all
Super Sonic said:
Super Sonic said:
hidetheelephants said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink
Wait a minute, did you put that, or was it me?
Nah it was the next bloke . . . any minute now . . .
It used to be fine, then at the last facelift they made the quotes look vaguely like speechbubbles and it worked about as well as all the other tweaks, only the other st tweaks were tweaked until they were mostly not st whereas the bubble quotes have hung around like a persistent eggy fart in the toilet.
Super Sonic said
Would it be better if we put our names in the boxes?
Are we at the tipping point yet?

grumbledoak

32,071 posts

245 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
thebraketester said:
Are we at the tipping point yet?
Removing the "quote all" button completely would do it. I'm sure they can find a dev capable of that one.

thebraketester

14,922 posts

150 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
thebraketester said:
Are we at the tipping point yet?
Removing the "quote all" button completely would do it. I'm sure they can find a dev capable of that one.
Have you thought about doing stand up?

Digger

Original Poster:

15,486 posts

203 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
thebraketester said:
grumbledoak said:
thebraketester said:
Are we at the tipping point yet?
Removing the "quote all" button completely would do it. I'm sure they can find a dev capable of that one.
Have you thought about doing stand up?
biggrin

HiAsAKite

2,462 posts

259 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
Really not seeing the issue here.. in many cases the "quote all" is key to understanding context of the quoted post

Yes, it can end up taking a lot of screen space when yiu get multiple quote alla, but this is better in my mind than not being able to quote all when needed

dickymint

26,845 posts

270 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
HiAsAKite said:
Really not seeing the issue here.. in many cases the "quote all" is key to understanding context of the quoted post

Yes, it can end up taking a lot of screen space when yiu get multiple quote alla, but this is better in my mind than not being able to quote all when needed
Quote and Quote all is not really the issue. The issue is the nested bubble type thing. I hated this since it started years ago and still do especially when the post gets lengthy! There are many times that my brain just can't compute.

Could a mod or anybody find (i'm useless using the 'way back machine') a good example of the old method we used to use?

It would be useful for people to compare and maybe understand the issue.

Digger

Original Poster:

15,486 posts

203 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
dickymint said:
HiAsAKite said:
Really not seeing the issue here.. in many cases the "quote all" is key to understanding context of the quoted post

Yes, it can end up taking a lot of screen space when yiu get multiple quote alla, but this is better in my mind than not being able to quote all when needed
Quote and Quote all is not really the issue. The issue is the nested bubble type thing. I hated this since it started years ago and still do especially when the post gets lengthy! There are many times that my brain just can't compute.

Could a mod or anybody find (i'm useless using the 'way back machine') a good example of the old method we used to use?

It would be useful for people to compare and maybe understand the issue.
Two alternating colours were used & visibly, you could then differentiate quite easily who said what - if i recall correctly.

Why it was changed . . . I have no idea.

B'stard Child

30,091 posts

258 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
Unfortunately - the "quote all" is actually very useful when PH'rs put their reply before the quoted section - the std "quote" thing doesn't work so well then but "quote all" does

grumbledoak said:
Removing the "quote all" button completely would do it. I'm sure they can find a dev capable of that one.

B'stard Child

30,091 posts

258 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
"Quote" you just get this

B'stard Child said:
"Quote All" you get all of it

B'stard Child said:
Unfortunately - the "quote all" is actually very useful when PH'rs put their reply before the quoted section - the std "quote" thing doesn't work so well then but "quote all" does

grumbledoak said:
Removing the "quote all" button completely would do it. I'm sure they can find a dev capable of that one.
JM2PW

Monkeylegend

27,532 posts

243 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
thebraketester said:
Super Sonic said:
Super Sonic said:
hidetheelephants said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink
Wait a minute, did you put that, or was it me?
Nah it was the next bloke . . . any minute now . . .
It used to be fine, then at the last facelift they made the quotes look vaguely like speechbubbles and it worked about as well as all the other tweaks, only the other st tweaks were tweaked until they were mostly not st whereas the bubble quotes have hung around like a persistent eggy fart in the toilet.
Super Sonic said
Would it be better if we put our names in the boxes?
Are we at the tipping point yet?
It was very predictable the way this thread would go hehe

dickymint

26,845 posts

270 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
Digger said:
dickymint said:
HiAsAKite said:
Really not seeing the issue here.. in many cases the "quote all" is key to understanding context of the quoted post

Yes, it can end up taking a lot of screen space when yiu get multiple quote alla, but this is better in my mind than not being able to quote all when needed
Quote and Quote all is not really the issue. The issue is the nested bubble type thing. I hated this since it started years ago and still do especially when the post gets lengthy! There are many times that my brain just can't compute.

Could a mod or anybody find (i'm useless using the 'way back machine') a good example of the old method we used to use?

It would be useful for people to compare and maybe understand the issue.
Two alternating colours were used & visibly, you could then differentiate quite easily who said what - if i recall correctly.

Why it was changed . . . I have no idea.
Yes that's about all I can remember of how it looked. I think at the time it was 'hailed' as purely a cosmetic thing to modernise what even back then was an old school looking forum - It looks neater but doesn't work!

Big Al.

69,211 posts

270 months

Saturday 6th July 2024
quotequote all
Monkeylegend said:
thebraketester said:
Super Sonic said:
Super Sonic said:
hidetheelephants said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Super Sonic said:
Digger said:
Now that the wes have (unfortunately) been resolved, can the mods now get their minds out of the gutter & look in to prodding that one part-time Dev to tweak nested quoting, so it is easier to make out who said what . . .

There was a relevant thread but can’t be arsed to find it biggrin
Don't really see it as a problem.
Let’s see about that . . . right here wink
Wait a minute, did you put that, or was it me?
Nah it was the next bloke . . . any minute now . . .
It used to be fine, then at the last facelift they made the quotes look vaguely like speechbubbles and it worked about as well as all the other tweaks, only the other st tweaks were tweaked until they were mostly not st whereas the bubble quotes have hung around like a persistent eggy fart in the toilet.
Super Sonic said
Would it be better if we put our names in the boxes?
Are we at the tipping point yet?
It was very predictable the way this thread would go hehe
Enough said.

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED