Suggestions for improvement to the forum
Suggestions for improvement to the forum
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

AndrewMontgomery

Original Poster:

501 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
Just to start with I think this is the best and most informative Porsche forum Ive seen. Excellent. Nonetheless there seem to my subjective eye to be a few things which could be done to improve it further (imho).

So if the moderators don't mind a novice telling them how to improve things here's my few pence worth.

1. Brighten the colour scheme. Grey on dark grey is a bit oppressive.

2. Increase the number of threads per page by, say, 5?

3. Add a search facility. Great for info and cuts out some repetition.

4. Improve the "quote feature" so that it distinguishes more clearly between messages by eg. putting quoted portion in a box. From what I can tell the existing one creates threads which contain huge indistinguishable posts of identical text which are very hard to follow and unnecessarily bulky.

Just a few ideas but interested to see what others think or suggest.

Andrew

spenny_b

1,071 posts

272 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
Sorry fella - there's already a dedicated forum for this (after all, none of your comments are Porsche specific)....

Website Feedback

Burnham

3,668 posts

288 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
AndrewMontgomery said:
Just to start with I think this is the best and most informative Porsche forum Ive seen. Excellent. Nonetheless there seem to my subjective eye to be a few things which could be done to improve it further (imho).

So if the moderators don't mind a novice telling them how to improve things here's my few pence worth.

1. Brighten the colour scheme. Grey on dark grey is a bit oppressive.

2. Increase the number of threads per page by, say, 5?

3. Add a search facility. Great for info and cuts out some repetition.

4. Improve the "quote feature" so that it distinguishes more clearly between messages by eg. putting quoted portion in a box. From what I can tell the existing one creates threads which contain huge indistinguishable posts of identical text which are very hard to follow and unnecessarily bulky.

Just a few ideas but interested to see what others think or suggest.

Andrew
I'm all for improvement, but:

1. The grey is very easy on the eye...and no doubt 993 owners love it, as it matches their trousers.

2. Any more threads on the main page, and they will drop off the bottom, resulting in having to scroll.

3. There is a search facility, that can be secified to 'porsche' forum only, or the whole site.

4. See above, seems fine to me?

Other than that, I think your ideas are great!

smile

hunt_the_fox

1,044 posts

254 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
spenny_b said:
Sorry fella - there's already a dedicated forum for this (after all, none of your comments are Porsche specific)....

Website Feedback
He may well be looking at the forum through www.porkers.co.uk which takes this sub forum and masquerades it as a unique forum.

Burnham

3,668 posts

288 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
hunt_the_fox said:
spenny_b said:
Sorry fella - there's already a dedicated forum for this (after all, none of your comments are Porsche specific)....

Website Feedback
He may well be looking at the forum through www.porkers.co.uk which takes this sub forum and masquerades it as a unique forum.
The cheek of it!

Yes, Andrew, if this si the case you need to come here: http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/forum.asp?h=0...

2something

2,145 posts

237 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
AndrewMontgomery said:
Just to start with I think this is the best and most informative Porsche forum Ive seen. Excellent. Nonetheless there seem to my subjective eye to be a few things which could be done to improve it further (imho).

So if the moderators don't mind a novice telling them how to improve things here's my few pence worth.

1. Brighten the colour scheme. Grey on dark grey is a bit oppressive.

2. Increase the number of threads per page by, say, 5?

3. Add a search facility. Great for info and cuts out some repetition.

4. Improve the "quote feature" so that it distinguishes more clearly between messages by eg. putting quoted portion in a box. From what I can tell the existing one creates threads which contain huge indistinguishable posts of identical text which are very hard to follow and unnecessarily bulky.

Just a few ideas but interested to see what others think or suggest.

Andrew
On Pistonheads.co.uk ...

1. Under preferences you can set your own 'skin'
2. Also under preferences, mine is set to 20, but you can set it higher
3. There is a search facility, but using google with pistonheads.co.uk works nicely.
4. More of a user issue than a forum issue ?

ETA: So eh, well um as for the quoting being a user issue ..

Edited by 2something on Wednesday 21st January 17:32

AndrewMontgomery

Original Poster:

501 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
Cheers guys. yes I am accessing through the Porkers site.

Good to see so many people quoting my original post in full in the same indistinguishable text as their own posts :-)

Neatly ironic!

Will have a look through the links and set it up as best I can.

2something

2,145 posts

237 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
Ah, but the quoting works nicely on the pistonheads site!

AndrewMontgomery

Original Poster:

501 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
2something said:
Ah, but the quoting works nicely on the pistonheads site!


Yes, but Im not on the Pistonheads site :-)

tertius

6,914 posts

259 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
AndrewMontgomery said:
2something said:
Ah, but the quoting works nicely on the pistonheads site!
Yes, but Im not on the Pistonheads site :-)
Why not?
I took a look at that porkers thing and frankly its sh*te I'm not surprised you don't like it.

Gordon Bennett

3,003 posts

214 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
Burnham said:
I'm all for improvement, but:

1. The grey is very easy on the eye...and no doubt 993 owners love it, as it matches their trousers.
I just spat my tea over my screen. That is funny.

Absolute load of bo llox, but funny.

Big Al.

69,336 posts

287 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
As this isn't Porsche specific I'm going to move to website feedback.

A question to the OP what colour scheme do you suggest? smile

I’m personally very happy with the present set up.

Burnham

3,668 posts

288 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
Gordon Bennett said:
Burnham said:
I'm all for improvement, but:

1. The grey is very easy on the eye...and no doubt 993 owners love it, as it matches their trousers.
I just spat my tea over my screen. That is funny.

Absolute load of bo llox, but funny.
Hey, I' an ex-993 owner so its all tongue in cheek buddy smile

tubbystu

3,846 posts

289 months

Wednesday 21st January 2009
quotequote all
AndrewMontgomery said:
2something said:
Ah, but the quoting works nicely on the pistonheads site!
Yes, but Im not on the Pistonheads site :-)
Well get here then. rolleyes

Mr Will

13,719 posts

235 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
AndrewMontgomery said:
2something said:
Ah, but the quoting works nicely on the pistonheads site!
Yes, but Im not on the Pistonheads site :-)
You really should move over, porkers.co.uk is just a very old re-skin of our porsche forum.

You will find exactly the same information of here, but it will solve all the problems you are having!

thumbup

AndrewMontgomery

Original Poster:

501 posts

224 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
Thanks gentlemen. Have now moved over from the dark side and the world has brightened up!

Cheers

TheBoo

979 posts

228 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
Gordon Bennett said:
Burnham said:
I'm all for improvement, but:

1. The grey is very easy on the eye...and no doubt 993 owners love it, as it matches their trousers.
I just spat my tea over my screen. That is funny.

Absolute load of bo llox, but funny.
This week 993 owners are mostly wearing jeans wavey

robinhood21

31,116 posts

261 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
Big Al. said:
A question to the OP what colour scheme do you suggest? smile

I’m personally very happy with the present set up.
Er, I thought the present colour was so it did not look 'out of place' on work monitors. smile

AndrewMontgomery

Original Poster:

501 posts

224 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
robinhood21 said:
Big Al. said:
A question to the OP what colour scheme do you suggest? smile

I’m personally very happy with the present set up.
Er, I thought the present colour was so it did not look 'out of place' on work monitors. smile
I am the OP. This colour scheme is just fine. I was logging in through the Porkers site and it is dark grey with light grey. Truly dank. Much more acceptable here. Also Ive now got the search facility I wanted and more than 10 threads per page. So all well!

Big Al.

69,336 posts

287 months

Thursday 22nd January 2009
quotequote all
Alls well that ends well thumbup

Pointless to leave open now me thinks. smile
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED