What's New page is a bit clunky
What's New page is a bit clunky
Author
Discussion

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,620 posts

284 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
The what's new page is a little clunky. I think it's because the lines are separated further than in the forums (if that makes sense) as the Topic column is halved to accomodate the Forum column.

I wonder if it's worth doing away with the Forum column completely?

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
Tricky one... it is worth having the forum column so 1) It makes you aware that forum exists and 2) you can then delve into that forum and get lost some more.

But on the other hand I do see the merit in having it look just like a forum in itself.

I will have a ponder!

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,620 posts

284 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
Perhaps a compromise would be to have the forum abbreviated, maybe with a "hover over" pop up. And/Or smaller fonts for the poster's names?

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
I was thinking whether putting the forum name to the right hand side so that the left looks the same as a normal forum, but the right hand side has the details.... what do you think?

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,620 posts

284 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
But keeping the details? The problem* is that the lines are spaced further apart because the thread title scrolls onto the next line. So it looks different to the forums and there are fewer titles per screen. Unless you reduce the font size I don't think it'll fit.



*Admittedly, it's only a small one
biggrin

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
With the line spacing the same as a normal topic by being clever somehow smile

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,620 posts

284 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
RacingPete said:
by being clever somehow smile
thumbupThat sounds like the perfect solutionhehe

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
I will mock up an alternative tomorrow and see if we can find an alternative thumbup

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,620 posts

284 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Have you tweaked it? The Forum column looks narrower, but that just means it becomes the problem as the forum name scrolls onto the next line.

theboyfold

11,469 posts

255 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Should the layout be the same as 'My Stuff' does having the additional column of the original author add anything?

mechsympathy

Original Poster:

58,620 posts

284 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
The My Stuff page is a different colour which helps to differentiate it from the forum pages, maybe that would help with What's New.

TBH though I think I was being over fussy. Now I'm used to it it's fine.

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Unfortunately we ran out of time to fully test the new page... we have tried several ideas and hopefully it will be much better, but have to wait till Tuesday for this... sorry paperbag

Sheets Tabuer

21,411 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
RacingPete said:
Unfortunately we ran out of time to fully test the new page
Yet you implemented it?

Wow, just wow.

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Sheets Tabuer said:
RacingPete said:
Unfortunately we ran out of time to fully test the new page
Yet you implemented it?

Wow, just wow.
Huh! Has it changed, I can't see a difference?

Sheets Tabuer

21,411 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Ahh I see you've not implemented it yet biggrin

Carry on, I have a party going on here with lots of drunk women and I can't hear myself think.

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Sheets Tabuer said:
Ahh I see you've not implemented it yet biggrin

Carry on, I have a party going on here with lots of drunk women and I can't hear myself think.
You have a party with drunk women and you are posting on PistonHeads... priorties need sorting biggrin

PS: Where is it, it not that exciting here smile

Sheets Tabuer

21,411 posts

244 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Mrs is in the same room so I am staying out of trouble on the net biggrin

RacingPete

9,197 posts

233 months

Thursday 9th April 2009
quotequote all
Sheets Tabuer said:
Mrs is in the same room so I am staying out of trouble on the net biggrin
Say no more... wink

eharding

14,648 posts

313 months

Friday 10th April 2009
quotequote all
RacingPete said:
But on the other hand I do see the merit in having it look just like a forum in itself.
I think you have hit upon the veritable Road to Damascus moment to solve the manure-storm which has been raging since Monday.

The 'What's New' page is a list of threads...much like any other forum category. So make it look *exactly* like one....and add a preference to delete the forum name the thread resides in.

Once you make the leap of faith to make the link to the 'What's New' page appear in the list of forums - rather than a clunky menu - and allow the user to decide 'What's New' should be called - I'd call mine the "Pie and Pie", and have it at the top of the list of forums, just beneath General Gassing.

Finally...add some preference templates: the one I'm thinking of adds "Pie and Pie" at the top of the forum list, includes all of the Balkanised old P&P forums, and doesn't have the forum name in the thread list. Damn me....it looks *just* like the old P&P. Preference templates are good, particularly if you use a big button to select them. Ideally with a profanity in the label.

Allow the user to select this preference template by clicking a big button marked "I Want My Fecking P&P Back...Now!", then..bish...bash...bosh, jobs a good'un, your average punter gets a P&P forum back in the forum list, and everyone's happy.

Obviously, there are some navigation nuances, and the question of where new threads posted into this view are placed, but we'll deal with that tomorrow.

In the meantime, you get the Nobel Piston Peace Prize, and a stonking pay-rise. You lucky git.



theboyfold

11,469 posts

255 months

Friday 10th April 2009
quotequote all
eharding said:
RacingPete said:
But on the other hand I do see the merit in having it look just like a forum in itself.
I think you have hit upon the veritable Road to Damascus moment to solve the manure-storm which has been raging since Monday.

The 'What's New' page is a list of threads...much like any other forum category. So make it look *exactly* like one....and add a preference to delete the forum name the thread resides in.

Once you make the leap of faith to make the link to the 'What's New' page appear in the list of forums - rather than a clunky menu - and allow the user to decide 'What's New' should be called - I'd call mine the "Pie and Pie", and have it at the top of the list of forums, just beneath General Gassing.

Finally...add some preference templates: the one I'm thinking of adds "Pie and Pie" at the top of the forum list, includes all of the Balkanised old P&P forums, and doesn't have the forum name in the thread list. Damn me....it looks *just* like the old P&P. Preference templates are good, particularly if you use a big button to select them. Ideally with a profanity in the label.

Allow the user to select this preference template by clicking a big button marked "I Want My Fecking P&P Back...Now!", then..bish...bash...bosh, jobs a good'un, your average punter gets a P&P forum back in the forum list, and everyone's happy.

Obviously, there are some navigation nuances, and the question of where new threads posted into this view are placed, but we'll deal with that tomorrow.

In the meantime, you get the Nobel Piston Peace Prize, and a stonking pay-rise. You lucky git.
We appear to be getting somewhere...

How about going back to how 'What's New' works before the great change. It only shows the forums that people have listed as favourites? So it's filtered to the users preference, so they don't have to see all the threads that they aren't interested in.