EV road trip - Cambridge to Lake Garda, Italy June 2021
EV road trip - Cambridge to Lake Garda, Italy June 2021
Author
Discussion

PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st September 2020
quotequote all
We are in the very early stages of planning a road trip to Lake Garda in Italy for a mid June 2021 departure - we plan to be away for 14 days ish

When i say we, it will just be me and my other half. No kids, no pets.

i have yet to pick an exact route, what places we want to hang around in, what hotels we want to stay in on the way, and we are going to have to factor in charging/rest stops and do we go through the centre of Switzerland or around the outside etc etc

We have never done anything like this before however i am not a stranger to up and down the country in the UK for work, i also enjoy driving in areas i've not been before, especially if they're pretty smile

  • what we do know
We want to end up in Lake Garda, and spend at least two nights there.
Distance - 900-950 miles (without any detours)
Car we will be using - Kia e-niro 150kw / 64kWh (being delivered this month)
Claimed electric range - 280 miles
Reported real world range - 250 miles
Our target per charge - 200 miles.

  • what we need to find out
What charging operator cards / apps to download/sign up for
Anything to watch out for / places to avoid

Has anyone else done something similar? any tips?

would people be interested in updates? how our experience went? any information you might want to see ?


PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st September 2020
quotequote all
Seems like i'll need one or more IDP(s) after Jan 2021

PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st September 2020
quotequote all
a better route planner suggests 7 stops, adding roughly 4 hours to do the drive - i had loosely planned to stop every 200 miles, but i like the idea of stopping in more places, just to have a look around and relax.

aestetix1

873 posts

73 months

Tuesday 1st September 2020
quotequote all
https://youtu.be/vSg5EYFk1I8

A Better Route Planner is a good tool but you need to plan in multiple stages if you intend to charge overnight at hotels.

EVLATECOMER

164 posts

99 months

Tuesday 1st September 2020
quotequote all
As others advise a better route planner is good (albeit geeky).

Personally I would just go the Ionity site and look at using them exclusively for the main journey there and back.

If you stay under 70mph, your eNiro will give you closer to 220 to 230 miles on fast roads with no real energy recovery from braking.

I think the e Niro can take charge at 77kW for the first 80% of the battery state of charge. I would work on charging back up to 80% at each stop as the charge rate drops down dramatically after that and you're better off driving that sat around trying to squeeze that last bit into your battery.

If you follow this logic, you;re looking at around 180 to 190 miles for each hop after the first charge.

Hope this helps.

PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Wednesday 2nd September 2020
quotequote all
EVLATECOMER said:
As others advise a better route planner is good (albeit geeky).

Personally I would just go the Ionity site and look at using them exclusively for the main journey there and back.

If you stay under 70mph, your eNiro will give you closer to 220 to 230 miles on fast roads with no real energy recovery from braking.

I think the e Niro can take charge at 77kW for the first 80% of the battery state of charge. I would work on charging back up to 80% at each stop as the charge rate drops down dramatically after that and you're better off driving that sat around trying to squeeze that last bit into your battery.

If you follow this logic, you;re looking at around 180 to 190 miles for each hop after the first charge.

Hope this helps.
that's fantastic, thank you. i had planned for the 80% soc theory, and the 180-190 miles kind of fits with my loose 200 mile breaks plan.

Ionity do seem to feature quite heavily, they were one of the main ones i was going to sign up with before departure.


Knock_knock

608 posts

198 months

Wednesday 2nd September 2020
quotequote all
I am looking to a similar sort of trip next also, also in a eNiro.

Having downloaded and registered with Shell Recharge, and obtained a RFID card, the app is showing several hundred eNiro compatible chargers between Coquelles and Italy.

Various networks appear to be represented, and it appears that they are all accessible with a mixture of using the app, using the card, and using a credit card. The costs are shown too, and vary between really pretty cheap to really rather expensive - not that I'm too sensitive to price on a long journey, it's more about availability and reliability.

Does anyone have any experiences of this app/card/network combo? It looks like a one-stop solution clap

JD

3,086 posts

250 months

Wednesday 2nd September 2020
quotequote all
Do you still have the Z4 in your profile?

If so, take that.

You will be in reach of some of the greatest driving roads in Europe, and will regret being in the EV when you get there.

PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Wednesday 2nd September 2020
quotequote all
JD said:
Do you still have the Z4 in your profile?

If so, take that.

You will be in reach of some of the greatest driving roads in Europe, and will regret being in the EV when you get there.
We do have the Z4 still, but there is no way if would be practical for that whole journey. Totally hear what you're saying, and agree, for 10-20% of the trip i'd wish we were in the BMW, but for the other 80, the practicality of a good sized, brand new car that costs pennies to run would win out.

have you seen the size of the z4 boot when you have the metal roof in there too? yikes


JD

3,086 posts

250 months

Wednesday 2nd September 2020
quotequote all
PixelpeepZ4 said:
We do have the Z4 still, but there is no way if would be practical for that whole journey. Totally hear what you're saying, and agree, for 10-20% of the trip i'd wish we were in the BMW, but for the other 80, the practicality of a good sized, brand new car that costs pennies to run would win out.

have you seen the size of the z4 boot when you have the metal roof in there too? yikes
For 90% of the trip where it matters you want to be in the convertible, for 10% of the trip (when you just want to come home) you want to be able to just crack on you can do it easily in one day in Z4, it would kill you to do it in a day the Niro.

EV doesn't avoid the tolls, and doesn't avoid the Vignette in Switzerland

YoungMD

326 posts

142 months

Wednesday 2nd September 2020
quotequote all
Well we are planning to go from London to lake garda in a couple of weeks corona dependent! I certainly thought shell and ionity were the answer although I'm not sure in Switzerland, although I can tell you they have loads of electric chargers just not sure want make/cards/app etc...


PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Thursday 3rd September 2020
quotequote all
YoungMD said:
Well we are planning to go from London to lake garda in a couple of weeks corona dependent! I certainly thought shell and ionity were the answer although I'm not sure in Switzerland, although I can tell you they have loads of electric chargers just not sure want make/cards/app etc...
where are you planning on staying and what car are you going in?

Maracus

4,545 posts

190 months

Thursday 3rd September 2020
quotequote all
Is Ionity 0.69 Euros per KW?

EmilA

1,776 posts

179 months

Thursday 3rd September 2020
quotequote all
Sorry if this isn't constructive but I found Lake Como to be much nicer than Lake Garda when I did a road trip in 2016.

PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Thursday 3rd September 2020
quotequote all
EmilA said:
Sorry if this isn't constructive but I found Lake Como to be much nicer than Lake Garda when I did a road trip in 2016.
i heard teresa may hangs around in como hence my choice of garda laugh

but hey, we are just at the early stages of planning. maybe we could do both smile

PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Thursday 3rd September 2020
quotequote all
Maracus said:
Is Ionity 0.69 Euros per KW?
it worked out about 45p which with some real rough math worked out around £90 each way (1500kms one way)

JD

3,086 posts

250 months

Thursday 3rd September 2020
quotequote all
PixelpeepZ4 said:
it worked out about 45p which with some real rough math worked out around £90 each way (1500kms one way)
I think that makes you even more mad to take the EV, I have done the journey for £120 at 85mph in a 335i, also Don't forget the €45 tolls and €40 vignette.



YoungMD

326 posts

142 months

Saturday 5th September 2020
quotequote all
PixelpeepZ4 said:
where are you planning on staying and what car are you going in?
So I am going in an ipace and probably planning to stay in Malcesine, I know lake garda very well I can recommend a good are to stay if you tell me what you are looking for.

Trip delayed now but planning on going next Friday......

PixelpeepZ4

Original Poster:

8,600 posts

164 months

Monday 14th September 2020
quotequote all
YoungMD said:
PixelpeepZ4 said:
where are you planning on staying and what car are you going in?
So I am going in an ipace and probably planning to stay in Malcesine, I know lake garda very well I can recommend a good are to stay if you tell me what you are looking for.

Trip delayed now but planning on going next Friday......
Somewhere quiet, with a view and good food - pretty simple really smile