Are EV's the new Betamax? Is Hydrogen the actual solution?
Are EV's the new Betamax? Is Hydrogen the actual solution?
Author
Discussion

sat1983

Original Poster:

1,253 posts

215 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
...... Discuss!

Is there a possible way ICE engines could run on Hydrogen?

PHuzzy

2,747 posts

203 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
No. /End thread

Caddyshack

15,377 posts

237 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Isn’t the problem how the hydrogen is produced in the first place…I think it may just move the non green problem to somewhere else in the chain.

Someone did explain it on here a while back.

GT9

9,104 posts

203 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Caddyshack said:
Isn’t the problem how the hydrogen is produced in the first place…I think it may just move the non green problem to somewhere else in the chain.

Someone did explain it on here a while back.
I wouldn't worry about that just yet, you've got to solve the onboard storage problem first.
All explained here in detail.
https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...

PHuzzy

2,747 posts

203 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Caddyshack said:
Isn’t the problem how the hydrogen is produced in the first place…I think it may just move the non green problem to somewhere else in the chain.

Someone did explain it on here a while back.
Pretty much, I can't be bothered doing it now but the calculations are in excess of 3x the amount of electricity to travel the same distance as a BEV using hydrogen.

GT9

9,104 posts

203 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
PHuzzy said:
Caddyshack said:
Isn’t the problem how the hydrogen is produced in the first place…I think it may just move the non green problem to somewhere else in the chain.

Someone did explain it on here a while back.
Pretty much, I can't be bothered doing it now but the calculations are in excess of 3x the amount of electricity to travel the same distance as a BEV using hydrogen.
Closer to 4x if you burn it inefficiently in an ICE.
Surely this thread is wind-up though.

hiccy18

4,247 posts

98 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
The concept of ICE running on hydrogen is something only for PHers to fantasize about, the other 99% are quite happy with BEV's. The EV infrastructure is by far the biggest weakness, but hydrogen shows no sign of being an alternative, never mind an improvement.

Mikehig

983 posts

92 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Groundhog Day!

mario328

161 posts

157 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Probably mentioned elsewhere on here but there was an interesting YT video by Harry’s Garage on using Hydrogen in future ICE see: https://youtu.be/19Q7nAYjAJY

TeaNoSugar

1,482 posts

196 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Mikehig said:
Groundhog Day!
All over again!!

tamore

10,118 posts

315 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
sat1983 said:
...... Discuss!

Is there a possible way ICE engines could run on Hydrogen?
possible, yes. absolutely ridiculous in every aspect, yes.

J4CKO

47,095 posts

231 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Go out for a drive, how many BEV's do you see, make a note of that number and also the number of Hydrogen powered cars.

In 2021 I saw more steam powered vehicles on the road, which was a total of one, a Traction Engine sat steaming gently whilst the crew had a drink at a pub in Goostrey, cant recall seeing anything powered by Hydrogen, at least not a Mirai or er, any other of the multitude of new Hydrogen powered models available.....

It would have happened by now, like BEV's have if it was going to in the short to medium turn, always possibility of a breakthrough but it just looks so inefficient.

I see it as (Tell me if I am wrong) make electricity, send it by wires, charge battery, drive car.

Vs, Make electricity, send it by wires, do chemistry to make Hydrogen, store Hydrogen, move Hydrogen to somewhere else, fill car with Hydrogen, car converts Hydrogen to electricity and water, drive car.

Has a future for some applications, but cant see passenger cars going that way, at the end of the day though its kind of another type of battery, but cant see it being routinely used in modified versions of IC Engines.

I feel the future of passenger cars (in Western/Mature markets) is incremental improvements to BEV's until they don't need compromises and excuses made, except the noise thing obviously.





PushedDover

7,722 posts

84 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
No.

In car storage is not feasible to any quantity, and the calorific value is unhelpful.

Oh and Zepplin.



LordFlathead

9,646 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Good factual explanation here compared to a dozen internet warriors wink

https://youtu.be/HKuKeKeUFTQ

JonnyVTEC

3,263 posts

206 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
Deja vu.
End

Gary C

15,374 posts

210 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
PushedDover said:
No.

and the calorific value is unhelpful.
Err, the calorific value of Hydrogen is about 3 times that of petrol smile

at about 142 MJ/kg against 45 MJ/kg

However, its density at atmospheric pressure is the problem, 1kg of hydrogen takes up a lot of space at 0 bar(g)

PushedDover

7,722 posts

84 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
Gary C said:
PushedDover said:
No.

and the calorific value is unhelpful.
Err, the calorific value of Hydrogen is about 3 times that of petrol smile

at about 142 MJ/kg against 45 MJ/kg

However, its density at atmospheric pressure is the problem, 1kg of hydrogen takes up a lot of space at 0 bar(g)
Yes - youre correct.
I meant the calorifc value of what one can store in a car is unhelpful.

LOHC is very interesting though for ships and alike where storage is less of an issue but very much 'wishful' at the mo.

aestetix1

873 posts

82 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
Unless I can make hydrogen at home, it's less convenient than electricity.

Carlososos

976 posts

127 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
In the very long term hydrogen is the answer right now but only when we have so much renewable excess electricity that’s too cheap to meter. That is so far away it’s not even worth discussing so apart from maybe lorries etc it’s not the viable option.

That may change depending on how in the meantime battery tech improves. If for example battery’s can be made from sand and don’t need any other toxic or rare materials then when we do have enough renewable electricity hydrogen simply won’t be needed.

GT9

9,104 posts

203 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
Carlososos said:
In the very long term hydrogen is the answer
That statement also depends on a step-change improvement in volumetric energy density, not just source energy availability.