Which diesel? Used Porsche Macan or New Alfa Stelvio?

[uzyg]

I'm probably living in Dreamland thinking about either of these but would be interested to know which would you go for between a Macan (used) Vs Stelvio (new)?
Engine must be diesel due to high miles per year.

Edited by uzyg on Wednesday 27th December 02:02

[ZX10R NIN]

The OH had the Macan S diesel & it was a very nice car but from what I've seen of the Alfa I'd take that everytime also consider the Maserati Levante all three are nice places to be only a test drive will give you a definitive answer.

[Actus Reus]

Sat in a Stelvio - didn't impress me like the Porsche did. Add on to that the woeful service from the local dealer when trying to sell me the car, and for me it's the Pork all day.

[FWIW]

+1 for the Macan, although our is a GTS. The interior quality makes everything else feel second rate. Plus the residuals are excellent.

[Yipper]

Would take the Maserati because it has the best badge.

[CountZero23]

Yipper said:

Would take the Maserati because it has the best badge.

Insightful as ever Yipper

[DoctorX]

Yipper said:

Would take the Maserati because it has the best badge.

If I was shelling out that much cash, I’d take the best car, not the best badge. Macan for me.

[Actus Reus]

I'd also take a look at the Audi SQ5 as they're in budget (unlike, I suspect, the Maser).

[Summit_Detailing]

Levante is fine in isolation, drive a Macan, F-pace (and maybe the Stelvio) afterwards and it'll put into perspective how average the Levante is.

I'd want to have a decent drive in the Stelvio before going down the Macan route.

cheers

Chris

[AAD44H]

Macan

[BlackLabel]

From those 2 I’d pick the Macan.

Another suggestion - have you considered the new xc60? It’s a lovely looking car - inside and out. No 6 cylinder engine though, only comes in a 4 pot which will probably put a lot of people off.