Mileage history query
Mileage history query
Author
Discussion

pubrunner

Original Poster:

517 posts

112 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
Hi All,

My son is/was interested in a car advertised through the auspices of this forum.

Although it is 7 years old, it is advertised with a mileage of just under 18K.

I went on the government website to check the MOT history and it states that in 2017, it had done 22k, in 2018 it had done 26K, but in 2019 it had done just 11 (eleven) K and it is currently being advertised as 18K.

By some means, between 2018 and 2019, the mileage reduced 15K - is there any legitimate away, by which this anomaly can be explained ?

Rchamps

55 posts

127 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
Most likely not - and it will forever be this way so your son would have the same questions raised to him come resale.

Nickp82

3,943 posts

122 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
The mileage reading in KM rather than Miles is a reasonably common occurrence but the numbers don’t stack up in this instance for that to be the likely explanation. A change of clocks or a good old haircut would be my suspicion.

datum77

470 posts

150 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all

It is a buyers market out there. There is plenty of choice from every means available.

Get onto all the car websites and find exactly what you want.

3 rules for buying a car:-

(1) Research
(2) Research
(3) Research

pubrunner

Original Poster:

517 posts

112 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
datum77 said:
It is a buyers market out there. There is plenty of choice from every means available.

Get onto all the car websites and find exactly what you want.

3 rules for buying a car:-

(1) Research
(2) Research
(3) Research
Indeed !

A shame that we should need to make such checks though; as already mentioned, had my son purchased the car, if he wanted to sell it on, he'd have a problem explaining the mileage. Given that the mileage has been reduced, no-one can know how many miles it has actually done.

Another rule for buying a car

(4) If it looks very good 'value', be very suspicious.



aaron_2000

5,407 posts

112 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
Unless it's a one off car that he'll never get the chance to own again, just leave it. There's plenty out there

pubrunner

Original Poster:

517 posts

112 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
aaron_2000 said:
. . . . . . . just leave it.
You're right there - wouldn't touch it; it's most likely done twice the advertised mileage.


aaron_2000 said:
There's plenty out there
Hopefully, we'll find something in his price bracket soon.

Rod200SX

8,176 posts

205 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
I think you've pretty much got it nailed but as a previous posted mentioned, it'd just maek it more difficult to sell on at a later date.

It's a bugger as it's not even a massive, though double, mileage jump. It's hardly like 30k (assumed) is a massive mileage on a car of that age, assuming it's not an exotic.

pubrunner

Original Poster:

517 posts

112 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
Rod200SX said:
It's a bugger as it's not even a massive, though double, mileage jump. It's hardly like 30k (assumed) is a massive mileage on a car of that age, assuming it's not an exotic.
You're quite right about the mileage - something in the 30K region isn't that high. For me, it's a question of trust, if someone's gone to the trouble to lower

the mileage, what else might come to the surface in future ?


Edited by pubrunner on Thursday 18th June 16:31

Pupbelly

1,413 posts

158 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
Why not just ask the seller and see what response you get?

Trevor555

5,399 posts

113 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
pubrunner said:
Hi All,

My son is/was interested in a car advertised through the auspices of this forum.

Although it is 7 years old, it is advertised with a mileage of just under 18K.

I went on the government website to check the MOT history and it states that in 2017, it had done 22k, in 2018 it had done 26K, but in 2019 it had done just 11 (eleven) K and it is currently being advertised as 18K.

By some means, between 2018 and 2019, the mileage reduced 15K - is there any legitimate away, by which this anomaly can be explained ?
Maybe it had a new speedo just after 26k?

If that's the case the seller should be stating 44,000 miles, or thereabouts.

Maybe the seller is unaware, have you asked them?

Might be worth some more research if there isn't others out there, and a little drop in price of course.

pubrunner

Original Poster:

517 posts

112 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
Trevor555 said:
Maybe it had a new speedo just after 26k?

If that's the case the seller should be stating 44,000 miles, or thereabouts.

Maybe the seller is unaware, have you asked them?

Might be worth some more research if there isn't others out there, and a little drop in price of course.
We have contacted the seller, but they didn't respond.

Pupbelly

1,413 posts

158 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
pubrunner said:
We have contacted the seller, but they didn't respond.
Run away then me thinks!

Majorslow

1,299 posts

158 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
100,000's cars out there....go for another if not happy, buy in haste repent at leisure

What do the floor mats look like?....worn? then maybe more miles than suggested?

pedal rubbers worn? gear stick look worn (one handed driving, and ring marks on older higher miles cars)

Steering wheel worn?

Wheel rims kerbed or as new?

Original tyres? likely to be if that low a mileage?

Stone chips on front of car....loads then maybe more miles....or they just drive too close to car in front

Drivers seat showing wear?

Service history?

Should a 17 year old have such an expensive car as a first one? (having said that my 17 year old bought a 5k car for a first one, and now 19 without a prang) (my daughter bought a shedish car 1k as a first....and just as well she did, she ain't bothered by kerb scars, minor walls jumping out at her etc...)

Edited by Majorslow on Thursday 18th June 17:29

Trevor555

5,399 posts

113 months

Thursday 18th June 2020
quotequote all
Pupbelly said:
pubrunner said:
We have contacted the seller, but they didn't respond.
Run away then me thinks!
+1