New Driver Car Choice?
New Driver Car Choice?
Author
Discussion

Bercilac

Original Poster:

302 posts

98 months

Tuesday 30th June 2020
quotequote all
I bought my eldest a Pug 206 1.4 16v Sport as his first car and its been good as gold for four years. Now number two son is learning in it and I want to get him a motor.

Decent 206s (ours is superb) are thin on the ground, so I figured I would go for the 207 1.4 16v Sport, which are more plentiful. Weirdly these 1360cc twin cams are cheaper to insure than the diesels despite being three insurance groups higher and a mighty 20 bhp more powerful.

So the point of this post is does anyone have any other cheap sporty(ish) cars that would be ideal for a young lad's first motor?

For comparison the insurance aged 17 with no NCB and a freshly minted full licence is circa £900 fully comp for a year.

340600

605 posts

172 months

Tuesday 30th June 2020
quotequote all
Would it not make more sense to pass the 206 onto lad 2 and let the eldest upgrade? Or is he too attached to it now?

Bercilac

Original Poster:

302 posts

98 months

Tuesday 30th June 2020
quotequote all
Good idea but he's bonded - mind you, we were talking about MK1 Scirocco's the other day so you could be onto something there - always fancied rebuilding one of those.

340600

605 posts

172 months

Tuesday 30th June 2020
quotequote all
That's it then. Keeps the 206 in the family and the eldest gets an upgrade/project after (I'm assuming) 4 years without getting into trouble. smile

Bercilac

Original Poster:

302 posts

98 months

Tuesday 30th June 2020
quotequote all
Yeh oldest is sensible lad, youngest is already eyeing up the TVR rolleyes

Falconer

299 posts

79 months

Wednesday 1st July 2020
quotequote all
Bercilac said:
I bought my eldest a Pug 206 1.4 16v Sport as his first car and its been good as gold for four years. Now number two son is learning in it and I want to get him a motor.

Decent 206s (ours is superb) are thin on the ground, so I figured I would go for the 207 1.4 16v Sport, which are more plentiful. Weirdly these 1360cc twin cams are cheaper to insure than the diesels despite being three insurance groups higher and a mighty 20 bhp more powerful.

So the point of this post is does anyone have any other cheap sporty(ish) cars that would be ideal for a young lad's first motor?

For comparison the insurance aged 17 with no NCB and a freshly minted full licence is circa £900 fully comp for a year.
Insurance quotes are unfathomable. My son having just past his test, got cheaper insurance moving to Glasgow city centre from rural Borders.
Where did you get £900 from? Ours was £1200 for a 107, anything more than 1.0 was nearer £2k.

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

255 months

Thursday 2nd July 2020
quotequote all
Location is everything when looking at insurance.

We paid about £900 on my 18 year old daughter's insurance 2 years ago on a 206 1.4.
Living in rural Lincolnshire helps a huge amount.
Pay just under £800 now on a Fiesta 1.4TDCi Titanium with her now 20 as main driver, my 17 year old (provisional) and my wife as added drivers.
Think it will go up quite a lot when my 17 year old passes her test.

blueg33

46,248 posts

253 months

Thursday 2nd July 2020
quotequote all
Bought a 1.4 Fiesta for my daughter. Really like it, great handling, revvy duratec engine.

Sadly it was wriiten off 2 weeks ago by a delivery driver frown and is almost impossible to replace as its a Ghia and insurance co are not paying enough to buy the same age and spec car rage

Being a girl wink she is mostly concerned with colour, has to be purple or blue. We pick up a Mazda 2 in metallic purple on saturday. Drove it, its a really nice car, nearly as good handling as the Fiesta, slightly more power, slightly less mass, but odd gearing 1st to 2nd. It cost more but is newer with less mileage. Insurance - she is 19 with 2yrs ncb is £400 ish