ecosport or kuga?
Author
Discussion

James-jupp

Original Poster:

47 posts

70 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
hi everyone, my current daily is a 2002 megane coupe. its on 250,000km on a petrol engine. Shes got a 2010 ibiza with the 1.0L 3cyl engine on 150,000km. We comute 25km to work each day, and once or twice a month do a 100km round trip to see the inlaws. I would like to tow a small trailer.

The missus thinks we should get rid and get an suv. she wants a kuga, but i´ve seen ecosports for the same price.

what would you go for ? i´m thinking the 1.0L ecosport.

I´m in spain - so the "go to" webpage is www.coches.net (dont tease me with autotrader and its sub 5k ford kuga titaniums.. i´ve seen them frown ) - we are looking at about 12k maximum, and for that price I can get a 2010ish (i prefer the mk1) kuga titanium spec for around 10k, with under 50k km, but then i saw that i can get a ecosport on a 18 or 19 plate for under 12k.

repayments on both would be about the same. I prefer the Kuga, but it seems silly to pay the same for a 10 year old car when we can get a 3 year old one for the same money?

Or should i just tell her to bugger off and i´m keeping the coupe, and putting a towbar on that, thereby saving 10 grand?. biggrin

James-jupp

Original Poster:

47 posts

70 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
I suppose if its going to be mid sized then probably a Renault Captur would be in the same price range? again with the 1.0L petrol?

ChrisH72

3,068 posts

80 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
From what I’ve seen the Ecosport gets terrible reviews.

I’d pick a kuga out of those two.

ZX10R NIN

30,478 posts

153 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
Get the Kuga it's the better car.

basherX

2,959 posts

189 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
Kuga all day long

Red9zero

11,143 posts

85 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
ChrisH72 said:
From what I’ve seen the Ecosport gets terrible reviews.

I’d pick a kuga out of those two.
My step Father has an Ecosport and loves it. They do seem to have a few known faults though, the rear door lock being one. I personally think they look a bit slab sided and much prefer the Kuga.

Boringvolvodriver

11,831 posts

71 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
The side opening rear door of the Ecosport would put me off regardless of anything else.

Depends how big a car you want, Kuga is relatively large - Focus size in length IIRC compared to the Fiesta sized EcoSport

How about the Seat Arona?


Mikebentley

8,579 posts

168 months

Sunday 28th February 2021
quotequote all
I can recommend the 1.0 Tce Dacia Duster or the new Sandero. Cheap to buy, warranty etc.

James-jupp

Original Poster:

47 posts

70 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
Thanks everyone for the replies - i also much prefer the looks of the kuga mk1 over the ecosport.

I drive both at work, and the kuga seems to drive better.

I guess age doesn't matter so much, if its gonna be a low milage example, i like the titanium spec for the full sunroof / half leather / 'tsw venom' type alloys.

I'm guessing it'd pull a trailer better too. I think they were all 2.0 tdci ? That'll bump up the insurance a little over what we have now or the ecosport/duster/captur tho, they all have the 1.0L petrol versions?

Pothole

34,367 posts

310 months

Monday 1st March 2021
quotequote all
James-jupp said:
hi everyone, my current daily is a 2002 megane coupe. its on 250,000km on a petrol engine. Shes got a 2010 ibiza with the 1.0L 3cyl engine on 150,000km. We comute 25km to work each day, and once or twice a month do a 100km round trip to see the inlaws. I would like to tow a small trailer.

The missus thinks we should get rid and get an suv. she wants a kuga, but i´ve seen ecosports for the same price.

what would you go for ? i´m thinking the 1.0L ecosport.

I´m in spain - so the "go to" webpage is www.coches.net (dont tease me with autotrader and its sub 5k ford kuga titaniums.. i´ve seen them frown ) - we are looking at about 12k maximum, and for that price I can get a 2010ish (i prefer the mk1) kuga titanium spec for around 10k, with under 50k km, but then i saw that i can get a ecosport on a 18 or 19 plate for under 12k.

repayments on both would be about the same. I prefer the Kuga, but it seems silly to pay the same for a 10 year old car when we can get a 3 year old one for the same money?

Or should i just tell her to bugger off and i´m keeping the coupe, and putting a towbar on that, thereby saving 10 grand?. biggrin
If you're in Spain, surely the vehicle you should have is a SEAT Arona?

James-jupp

Original Poster:

47 posts

70 months

Monday 8th March 2021
quotequote all
Pothole said:
If you're in Spain, surely the vehicle you should have is a SEAT Arona?
Haha.. yes, I suppose so !

we have been looking at the slightly larger of each brand, where the ecosport / captur / mk1 qashqai would be "suv" I would say that kuga / kadjar / mk2 qashqai would be the "bigger" versions - much more boot space etc ?

I´m leaning now towards a mk2 duster (sub €15k for a 0km car), or a kadjar, or an ateca?

James-jupp

Original Poster:

47 posts

70 months

Monday 8th March 2021
quotequote all
like this : https://www.clicars.com/coches-seminuevos/comprar-...

but i think that its not much bigger than her ibiza - I was looking at youtube and they had a review of that next to an ibiza and it was only 10cm? higher

I think its going to have to be a bigger one, if its worth doing