BMW X3/520d/xc60

[jason61c]

Sorry, I must point out I always end a thread with a purchase!

Having taking Mrs Jason to look at cars, a v60 is a no go(she doesn't like the shape), 3 series estate is too small(3 kids), so looking at a x3 or 5 series estate. She likes the xc60 but I'm on the fence.

any horror stories to look for? is the x3 the 5 series chassis or similar?(quality is better than a 3 and I think the same as the 5).

with the v60, any big negatives?

Thanks.

[ZX10R NIN]

jason61c said:

Sorry, I must point out I always end a thread with a purchase!

Having taking Mrs Jason to look at cars, a v60 is a no go(she doesn't like the shape), 3 series estate is too small(3 kids), so looking at a x3 or 5 series estate. She likes the xc60 but I'm on the fence.

any horror stories to look for? is the x3 the 5 series chassis or similar?(quality is better than a 3 and I think the same as the 5).

with the v60, any big negatives?

Thanks.

Budget?

[jason61c]

ZX10R NIN said:

Budget?

budget creep needed.

£35. for something in warranty and under 40k.

[Trailhead]

X3 isn’t a 3 series on stilts isn’t it?

[ZX10R NIN]

jason61c said:

ZX10R NIN said:

Budget?

budget creep needed.

£35. for something in warranty and under 40k.

The X3 35d M Sport Pro

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202109227...

30d M Sport

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202108136...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202110148...

Jaguar F Pace

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202108045...

The XC60 is a very good buy at your new price point they're good value the diesel hybrid is a good pick:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202109147...

R Design Pro

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202110118...

[jason61c]

ZX10R NIN said:

jason61c said:

ZX10R NIN said:

Budget?

budget creep needed.

£35. for something in warranty and under 40k.

The X3 35d M Sport Pro

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202109227...

30d M Sport

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202108136...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202110148...

Jaguar F Pace

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202108045...

The XC60 is a very good buy at your new price point they're good value the diesel hybrid is a good pick:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202109147...

R Design Pro

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202110118...

As always, some great suggestions. 2.0d will be fine though, its totally for family duties. ideally 2018/19 onwards... with 3 young kids, a darker seat colour would be best!

[toon10]

My household has a BMW 540i (although the saloon version) and 2019 XC60 T5, the 247bhp petrol version. I also have access to an X3 although that is an older model so less relevant. If there's anything specific you want to know, give me a shout. The 5 series is a fantastic car but Mrs Toon prefers the SUV seating position which a lot of women seem to prefer so that may be a factor. The Volvo is a good car but I find the touch screen controls are not very intuitive. I always find what I want but tend to be scrolling around the place for a while first.

[jason61c]

This is leading the way currently, based on spec/age/milage etc

https://usedcars.bmw.co.uk/vehicle/202108316825824

[SpanishTony]

Not a thread hi-jack but, that car's a diesel, does your wife do the mileage to justify diesel? I say this because my wife is looking at changing at some point and the x3 seems to be heading the pack in what she's looking for. But her profile is really lots of fairly short trips, so that's pointing us towards electric and consequently, out of budget.

[jason61c]

She does 10k a year. So it does balance up. I’d have a petrol one at circa £2.5k cheaper. Fuel savings with the diesel are around £600 a year.

We’ll have one ev in the household, so we need a hassle free long range family car also.

[Ranger 6]

I'm on my fourth X3 and would really recommend a six cylinder. The extra torque and smooth power delivery really suits the SUV and also is much quieter on long runs.

[Challo]

We had the X3 2.0d and now have a 520d Touring (OH works for BMW) and i much prefer the 5 series over the X3. Its nicer to drive, better fuel economy, inside it feels nice as well. The touring is really practical as well, and you get the spilt tailgate which is handy.

Never driven a new Volvo but they look very nice.

[scot_aln]

jason61c said:

This is leading the way currently, based on spec/age/milage etc

https://usedcars.bmw.co.uk/vehicle/202108316825824

That looks rather nice although even as a family bus the 3.0d is much smoother. Did wonder why it says "
BMW Finance not available on this vehicle."

Have you also looked at the x1 as if I recall it's actually more spacious inside than the X3.

[fflump]

scot_aln said:

That looks rather nice although even as a family bus the 3.0d is much smoother. Did wonder why it says "
BMW Finance not available on this vehicle."

Have you also looked at the x1 as if I recall it's actually more spacious inside than the X3.

IMO don't go down to the 1-series go up to the 5-series if you are splurging 35-40k. A six-pot diesel 5-series Touring would be a very nice place to be and to drive. But check out E-Class equivalents.

[flying-banana]

Trailhead said:

X3 isn’t a 3 series on stilts isn’t it?

Yes, basically

[flying-banana]

The OH currently has an X3 3.0d...unfortunately it replaced an X5 V8 petrol...it's only good point is 35mpg rather than 21mpg

[scot_aln]

fflump said:

IMO don't go down to the 1-series go up to the 5-series if you are splurging 35-40k. A six-pot diesel 5-series Touring would be a very nice place to be and to drive. But check out E-Class equivalents.

The X1 isn't a 1 series as such. It was not on the F20 platform. The budget also had only just crept up to £35k and if it climbs further the discussion will probably move to X5s. Also as family bus, so assuming school runs then the 5 and the E Class whilst all being nice places to be are a pain to park. The OPs partner may of course disagree.

[jason61c]

scot_aln said:

fflump said:

IMO don't go down to the 1-series go up to the 5-series if you are splurging 35-40k. A six-pot diesel 5-series Touring would be a very nice place to be and to drive. But check out E-Class equivalents.

The X1 isn't a 1 series as such. It was not on the F20 platform. The budget also had only just crept up to £35k and if it climbs further the discussion will probably move to X5s. Also as family bus, so assuming school runs then the 5 and the E Class whilst all being nice places to be are a pain to park. The OPs partner may of course disagree.

can't be an e-class, x5 is too big and too brash.

[jason61c]

scot_aln said:

fflump said:

IMO don't go down to the 1-series go up to the 5-series if you are splurging 35-40k. A six-pot diesel 5-series Touring would be a very nice place to be and to drive. But check out E-Class equivalents.

The X1 isn't a 1 series as such. It was not on the F20 platform. The budget also had only just crept up to £35k and if it climbs further the discussion will probably move to X5s. Also as family bus, so assuming school runs then the 5 and the E Class whilst all being nice places to be are a pain to park. The OPs partner may of course disagree.

What’s the width inside an x1? I’d prefer budget to go down, I know an il6 would be smoother but for it’s duties, I’m happy with a 4 pot

[Challo]

jason61c said:

scot_aln said:

fflump said:

IMO don't go down to the 1-series go up to the 5-series if you are splurging 35-40k. A six-pot diesel 5-series Touring would be a very nice place to be and to drive. But check out E-Class equivalents.

The X1 isn't a 1 series as such. It was not on the F20 platform. The budget also had only just crept up to £35k and if it climbs further the discussion will probably move to X5s. Also as family bus, so assuming school runs then the 5 and the E Class whilst all being nice places to be are a pain to park. The OPs partner may of course disagree.

What’s the width inside an x1? I’d prefer budget to go down, I know an il6 would be smoother but for it’s duties, I’m happy with a 4 pot

If she thinks the 3 Touring is too small I wouldnt bother with the X1 as that will be too small as well. I would stick with the X3 if she wants a SUV and go with the 2.0d over the 2.0i.