C63/RS5 dilemma

[escos67]

Hi all new to this posting lark so please bear with me.
I currently have (own outright) a 19 plate C63 cabriolet face lift (non S) with 3000 miles on the clock. Took an 18 plate RS5 with 3600 miles on the clock for a test drive at the weekend and was impressed with its road holding ability compared with C63. Main dealer has offered a straight swap and am in a bit of a dilemma……stick or twist.
Would really appreciate what people would suggest
Any suggestions/opinions would be greatly appreciated
Thanks

[jason61c]

stick.

Thats why the dealer is offering a straight swap.

[Over over under steer]

I'd stick.

[fflump]

If you prefer the RS5 then just uncouple the deals.
Take your C63 cab to WBAC or wherever, and use the cash to buy a RS5.

That would probably save you around £10,000 compared to what the dealer's 'deal' is.

About £50k would get you that RS5.
Anyone wanting to buy a 19 C63 cab would need £65+ I'd have thought.

[GreatGranny]

There's easily £10k difference in the values.

Go on WBAC and compare what they would give for both of them.

That's a good way of knowing how much the dealer is taking the mick.

[escos67]

Thanks for the advice guys. Motorway have got the RS5 valued 6k cheaper than ours :Nono:

[fflump]

GreatGranny said:

There's easily £10k difference in the values.

Go on WBAC and compare what they would give for both of them.

I think there’s an echo on this forum 😂

[BrettMRC]

I found the current RS5 to feel tinny and flimsy compared to previous ones as well... didn't feel like a good long term prospect.

Stick with the C63!

[escos67]

It does stick to the road like s..t to a blanket though. I haven’t enough driving skill to take the 63 sideways round a roundabout