Economical, reliable, cheap wafter
Economical, reliable, cheap wafter
Author
Discussion

flatso

Original Poster:

1,360 posts

156 months

Sunday 29th January 2023
quotequote all
Needed for a 1x/week round trip of 100 km on a highly restricted motorway, to waft a family of 4. Maximum comfort and reliability are the top criteria. Decent fuel economy would also be nice, as would be an attractive purchase price.
Curious to see what suggestions will be posted.

ZX10R NIN

30,401 posts

152 months

Sunday 29th January 2023
quotequote all
Need a price point to start with?

flatso

Original Poster:

1,360 posts

156 months

Sunday 29th January 2023
quotequote all
10 tsd

Snow and Rocks

3,356 posts

54 months

Sunday 29th January 2023
quotequote all
If that's all it's going to be used for then economy is surely almost irrelevant. 240 miles a month means fuel cost will be negligible compared to all the other costs of running a car.

Lexus GS or LS of some variety depending on budget will take some beating I think. Even a V8 LS should manage 30 mpg+ on that sort of run.

flatso

Original Poster:

1,360 posts

156 months

Sunday 29th January 2023
quotequote all
Budget can be higher, and yes fuel economy is not the main issue. The miser inside however hates the pump visits lately.
An LS is the obvious choice, however I am also open to unexpected suggestions. I would love a w222 S-klasse, however I have had some hoorid experiences with MB servicing and their horrendously overpriced services; not sure what engine choice is the most reliable.
A8 is also on the radar but the same question as above.

Snow and Rocks

3,356 posts

54 months

Sunday 29th January 2023
quotequote all
flatso said:
Budget can be higher, and yes fuel economy is not the main issue. The miser inside however hates the pump visits lately.
An LS is the obvious choice, however I am also open to unexpected suggestions. I would love a w222 S-klasse, however I have had some hoorid experiences with MB servicing and their horrendously overpriced services; not sure what engine choice is the most reliable.
A8 is also on the radar but the same question as above.
From experience - both an A8 and S class will go wrong at some point and the bills won't be cheap. Our A8 with the 3.0 tdi did go on to do 240k miles but needed a lot of money spent on it to get that far.

There are obviously still things that could go wrong with a Lexus but the odds are stacked much more highly in your favour. Honda Legend might be worth a look, not as wafty as an LS but still pretty good.

flatso

Original Poster:

1,360 posts

156 months

Monday 30th January 2023
quotequote all
Allready have an Infiniti (EX 37s) which was decent value, the chasis is a bit stiff and would like something else.
The Honda Legend looks very intrigueing, seems like a LOT of car for the money. Is it comfy?

Will look into an LS, however the prices seem to have gone up here in CH .

Jag XJ the newer body style? are they as unreliable as their reputation suggests?

Snow and Rocks

3,356 posts

54 months

Monday 30th January 2023
quotequote all
flatso said:
Allready have an Infiniti (EX 37s) which was decent value, the chasis is a bit stiff and would like something else.
The Honda Legend looks very intrigueing, seems like a LOT of car for the money. Is it comfy?

Will look into an LS, however the prices seem to have gone up here in CH .

Jag XJ the newer body style? are they as unreliable as their reputation suggests?
I've only had a brief ride in a Legend as a passenger but I would say it's more luxurious than a 5 series or e class but not quite on the same waftiness level as an LS. They apparently handle surprisingly well too.

No direct experience of the XJ but a friend got rid of his before the warranty ran out as it was proving to be unreliable on a Range Rover style scale.

QJumper

3,238 posts

53 months

Monday 30th January 2023
quotequote all
If you're not wedded to saloons, then a Lexus RX 450h is reliable and very comfortable for wafting. As for motorway economy, I get just over 30mpg at 70ish, although my last trip to France I averaged 40mpg doing mostly 60-65 mph on the way out.

Chromegrill

1,137 posts

113 months

Monday 30th January 2023
quotequote all
What's the little indentation under the boot lid in the Infiniti G? Where the boot normally goes? Looks barely big enough for a wallet let alone a suitcase, if thats the boot it's tiny. And with that fuel consumption.ption plus £615 VED you won't have a wallet left after long. The Infiniti M looks bigger yet has vastly better fuel, plus much lower tax. Don't hear a yrhing a out them though, are they any good?